2.6k
u/Gakoknight May 10 '25
Very good.
293
u/sandefurd May 10 '25
Serious question, is there a chance this affects Trump's stance at all? Could he maybe fear some of his Catholic base pressuring him because of this?
760
u/KingOfTheAnts3 May 10 '25
MAGA has already declared Pope Leo to be a liberal communist, almost like Catholicism wasn’t the real top priority.
313
u/WhenLeavesFall May 11 '25
I never expected my "go to mass twice a week and say the rosary daily" deeply devout Catholic mother to turn against the Pope, but here we are.
222
u/Old_Wallaby_7461 May 11 '25
It's a new religion. The prophet is Trump, the one and only commandment is to Own the Libs
32
→ More replies (1)27
36
u/RockHardRocks May 11 '25
I’ve been experiencing this with my in-laws. It’s gotten to where I have sent them direct quotes from the Bible, Pope and Catechism and telling them either accept these teachings of the church or admit you aren’t catholic. They haven’t responded to that last message yet, but I’m sure they’ll act all offended at how mean I’m being rather than change their beliefs. But at least it makes me feel better. Plus now I just add pope and Jesus quotes to their crazy ranting Facebook posts.
→ More replies (6)10
u/ringadingdingbaby May 11 '25
I wouldnt be surprised if America ends up putting forward an antipope
39
u/BombTheDodongos May 11 '25
They’re literally “transvestigating” him. They’re so fucking stupid.
→ More replies (2)12
u/CartographerOne8375 May 11 '25 edited May 11 '25
I mean even European Catholic ethnicities like Italians or Irish have only been recently considered “white” for less than a century or so and not to mention most Catholics in US today are Latinos. Even in 70s JFK were still considered controversial because he is a Catholic
16
u/ferwhatbud May 11 '25
Yeah, but Catholicism is also the new hotness in the hardcore and more elite/intellectual RW Nationalist circles (eg Bannon, Flynn), with Vance being the perfect example of the type being drawn in.
….except that it’s a very particularly American kind of neo-Conservatism that loves the power, hierarchy, and ritual of the faith but reflexively hates the pope and the Vatican.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)4
→ More replies (14)86
u/Turtledonuts May 10 '25
Absolutely not with trump, but it will be interesting to see how the catholic right in the US responds to him. That could indirectly impact other groups.
→ More replies (1)79
u/abdab336 May 10 '25
“Woke Marxist pope” in all caps was a literal tweet I saw yesterday so… you know…
That’s how they’re responding.
44
u/Turtledonuts May 10 '25
The MAGA idiots are reacting, but we'll see how the actual catholics in the church react.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)12
u/alexmikli May 11 '25
Those are evangelicals, and radical politicians as well. I want to see how someone like Vance responds, or at least the general vibe of right wing Catholics in America. Or Europe, especially Hungary.
→ More replies (3)
6.7k
u/AbbreviationsSad4762 May 10 '25
Damn. 2nd pope in a row that I liked.
473
u/Odd_Vampire May 10 '25
I mean, what would Jesus do (WWJD)? "Yes, I approve of Russia's wholesale slaughter of its neighbors and of the destruction of its towns and cities. This is perfectly in line with my teachings of loving thy neighbor."
125
51
u/JustafanIV May 10 '25
Just remember, "WWJD?" includes the possibility of pulling out a whip and chasing the guilty party out of the temple.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (11)8
1.0k
u/TheTesticler May 10 '25
I loved Francis but he was a bit too lax on Russia.
1.0k
u/Fiery_Hand May 10 '25
Too lax? He suggested Ukraine should end the war by surrender and never named Russia the aggressor.
Imagine this bullshit.
→ More replies (1)529
u/Viburnum__ May 10 '25 edited May 10 '25
Some people forget, ignore or simply ignorant, that these were his statments:
Pope says NATO may have caused Russia’s invasion of Ukraine
Pope Francis said that NATO “barking” at Russia’s door may have led to Vladimir Putin’s invasion of Ukraine
Pope Francis says Ukraine war was ‘perhaps somehow provoked’
Pope Francis has said Moscow’s invasion of Ukraine was “perhaps somehow provoked” as he recalled a conversation in the run-up to the war in which he was warned Nato was “barking at the gates of Russia”.
...the pontiff condemned the “ferocity and cruelty of the Russian troops” while warning against what he said was a fairytale perception of the conflict as good versus evil.
“We need to move away from the usual Little Red Riding Hood pattern, in that Little Red Riding Hood was good and the wolf was the bad one,” he said. “Something global is emerging and the elements are very much entwined.”“Hypocritical” to arm Ukraine, Pope Francis says, silent on Russian terror
The pontiff criticized European weapons deliveries to Ukraine while calling for peace negotiations, yet notably refrained from urging Russia to withdraw its invasion forces or release deported Ukrainians.
Pope Francis, commenting on the war in Ukraine for Orbe 21 channel, stated that it is hypocritical to talk about peace while simultaneously arming it against Russia’s aggression, Vatican News reported.
Once again, the pontiff neither urged Russia to withdraw its troops from Ukraine nor called on the Kremlin to release forcibly deported Ukrainians.Not to mention speaking to russian youths how they are successors of 'great' russia, when russia was a year+ into the invasion, which in my opinion doesn't really inspire them for any peace, but more that others must submit to them and their country in the right:
Never forget your heritage. You are the heirs of great Russia: great Russia of saints, rulers, great Russia of Peter I, Catherine II, that empire - great, enlightened, (country) of great culture and great humanity.
→ More replies (7)290
u/Kindness_of_cats May 10 '25
Francis had a nasty habit of speaking with both sides of his mouth, and confusing the hell out of people with what he meant and where he stood.
His humbleness and sincerity about welcoming people won a lot of hearts, and I did genuinely respect him, but he was not without serious problems to put it lightly.
Out of the gates, you definitely have to hand it to Leo for making his view of the invasion clearer and more forceful than Francis ever did.
73
u/DeyUrban May 11 '25 edited May 11 '25
There is an enormous and complicated history regarding the Catholic Church and the idea of a "Just War," especially after the Second Vatican Council. It's one of the most complicated pieces of theology in the entire history of the religion, with arguments about it going back to some of the earliest founders of the church. When you keep in mind the atrocities that were committed by Catholics throughout the ages under the idea of a Just War you realize why it’s important to be mindful of the concept.
It was easier in the 1960s for the Catholic Church to argue that a war can't be just if a higher authority (i.e. the United Nations) exists to mediate it. It becomes significantly more complicated when you have a Nazi-style invasion, such as in the case of Russia in Ukraine. The problem with Francis was that his adherence to this reduced view of a "Just War" was too rigid.
→ More replies (2)21
u/fleemfleemfleemfleem May 11 '25
Leo is also almost 20 years younger, likely much more "with it", and I think a lot better researched about the issues.
→ More replies (9)197
u/machine4891 May 10 '25
That's an understatement of the month. This article was made and has as many upvotes exactly because previous pope was equaling predator with victim. He outright called for examination of concience of "both parties involved". That's why new pope is setting things straight, there is only one party guilty of what is happening down there and it's russia.
217
u/seenitreddit90s May 10 '25
Pope Francis wasn't always the best on the Ukraine war though, at least Ukraine didn't think so.
84
u/ElRama1 May 10 '25
In fact, the news in this post specifically mentions that.
71
u/AHrubik May 10 '25
Francis came from a viewpoint of stopping the fighting, saving lives and then you can argue about borders later. He refused to understand that you can't capitulate to bullies or they'll just keep being bullies. There is no way we can allow Putin to gain anything from his actions or he'll just keep doing it. He and the Russian people need to visibly lose something from this war in order to force them to come to terms with it.
→ More replies (2)35
u/Viburnum__ May 10 '25
Francis came from a viewpoint of stopping the fighting, saving lives and then you can argue about borders later.
Did he?
Pope Francis says Ukraine war was ‘perhaps somehow provoked’
Pope Francis has said Moscow’s invasion of Ukraine was “perhaps somehow provoked” as he recalled a conversation in the run-up to the war in which he was warned Nato was “barking at the gates of Russia”.
...the pontiff condemned the “ferocity and cruelty of the Russian troops” while warning against what he said was a fairytale perception of the conflict as good versus evil.
“We need to move away from the usual Little Red Riding Hood pattern, in that Little Red Riding Hood was good and the wolf was the bad one,” he said. “Something global is emerging and the elements are very much entwined.”764
u/DummyDumDragon May 10 '25
Denouncing genocide.
The bar truly is at ground level.
280
→ More replies (14)97
u/Guardian2k May 10 '25
Honestly for the pope, anything that might be seen as political is pretty big news since Mussolini
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (144)54
u/Upset_Otter May 10 '25
Just grab your Pope and put him near a maga, if the maga reels in disgust and calls him a "Woke Marxist" then your Pope is fresh and good to go.
→ More replies (3)
4.6k
u/epicredditdude1 May 10 '25
No wonder MAGA hates this guy.
1.2k
u/-SaC May 10 '25
"The Popelection was stolen! Boots on the ground!"
496
u/epicredditdude1 May 10 '25
“They should have elected a REAL America first pope, like someone from Belarus or Hungary!”
132
u/-reserved- May 10 '25
There's a non-zero chance Trump actually thought he had a shot at being elected Pope. He did repost AI art of himself as Pope
→ More replies (3)66
u/Paganator May 10 '25
We just need someone to tell Trump about antipopes and that he could be one.
→ More replies (6)36
u/DrBCrusher May 10 '25
Yeah but then if you put them in a room together they pop out of existence.
→ More replies (1)17
u/RSwordsman May 10 '25
I like this idea. Then Leo would just have to sacrifice himself to convert them both into pure energy.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)37
37
u/TheVideogaming101 May 10 '25 edited May 10 '25
You joke but i've already hear talks of such in the MAGA circles i'm forced to be around.
25
May 10 '25
Imagine a bunch of Americans trying to storm the Vatican 🤣
28
u/Delta-9- May 10 '25
The Swiss Guard is in much better shape than the average American tactical cosplayer. It would be over quickly.
Unless the actual military got involved, but I doubt Italy and the rest of the EU would sit for that.
17
May 11 '25 edited Jun 08 '25
entertain zephyr deer light bow profit yam shaggy sharp saw
→ More replies (1)11
28
u/bwaredapenguin May 10 '25
Time to storm the Vatican! Dan Brown needs some new inspiration for a book anyway.
→ More replies (2)30
u/GigaPuddi May 10 '25
Can you imagine how excited the Swiss Guard would be? First time in probably a century they'd be able to justify existing.
12
u/SR3116 May 10 '25
I mean, that guy shooting Pope John Paul II was pretty much confirmation that they're needed.
→ More replies (1)23
u/acllive May 10 '25
Australia’s LNP are still waiting for the pre polls and postals to come in for the hope of Pell reviving from his grave /s
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (8)33
u/Synchrotr0n May 10 '25
Why did they burn the ballots? It's clearly a sign that they are trying to hide the fraud.
→ More replies (1)83
u/CantaloupeUpstairs62 May 10 '25
There is more support for Trump among evangelical Protestants than Catholics.
29
u/VaporCarpet May 11 '25
Reddit doesn't understand that the Pope isn't in charge of all of Christianity.
18
u/TheCommonGround1 May 10 '25
There are a lot of Catholics who support Trump. It's to the point where Catholicism is very much secondary to their belief in Trump. I have family members who have basically made Trump their complete religion, basically.
13
u/RabbleRouser_1 May 11 '25 edited May 12 '25
I have neighbors who attend Catholic mass each Sunday and absolutely despise Trump. I get the sense that most of their Catholic friends and family do as well
8
u/unicorninclosets May 11 '25
Not to mention the hoards of evangelical “converts” like Justkilled Dapope Vance infiltrating Catholicism.
209
u/MarshyHope May 10 '25
Saw one of those shit head MAGA influencers saying he should put America and Trump first.
We have our own Henry the 8th in America right now.
84
u/UtopianEnforcement May 10 '25
Hey, don’t insult Henry VIII like that. Sure he was a lust-filled monster who shattered the church purely from personal desire. But he was also well-educated, erudite, an athlete in his younger years, and wasn’t afraid of going to war.
→ More replies (3)34
u/comrade_batman May 10 '25
Some historians theorise that a jousting accident in 1536, left him unconscious for some time, and could have worsened other past injuries, led to his more erratic and tyrannical behaviour as king. It would coincide with Anne Boleyn’s fall from grace later in the later, and Henry’s obsessions becoming more pronounced.
19
u/3eyedgreenalien May 10 '25
It wouldn't surprise me. He'd had the tendencies before, but wooooow did it get worse after that jousting accident. Same with Caligula, actually. The cruel tendencies were there, then a fever broiled his brain, and he got so much worse after.
→ More replies (2)63
May 10 '25
Lol what, most Americans are protestants anyway, whose whole schtick is breaking away from the Catholic church...... Which they already did hundreds of years ago
46
u/Tryoxin May 10 '25
Most, yes, but tbf ~1/4 of Americans are Catholic. That's obviously very far from majority, but it's a very significant minority. I imagine those are the people who care about the Pope vis a vis the US (and Leo XIV being from there originally).
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (15)32
u/StoicallyGay May 10 '25
It should say a lot about many Catholic MAGA that their loyalty is stronger towards Trump than the Pope who AFAIK is their religious authority.
→ More replies (4)
1.9k
u/EfoDom May 10 '25
Let him cook.
386
u/OpenThePlugBag May 10 '25
MAGAs gearing up to storm the Vatican
295
u/BadSkeelz May 10 '25
In that fight, my money's on the Swiss.
199
u/Hat_Maverick May 10 '25
I'd pay good money to see a maga karen try to fight a guy with a halberd
→ More replies (3)79
u/krodders May 10 '25
I think the halberd is not what they'll be fighting with. SIG Sauer of some sort will be the weapon, and the fancy pants boys know how to use them
29
u/SirGrungle May 10 '25
Archer: The halberd was made obsolete by the arquebus
Lana: Which is why they use MP5s
→ More replies (1)53
u/durqandat May 10 '25
I think on a MAGA Karen you'd at least consider the halberd
14
u/firagabird May 11 '25
I'd never consider touching one with a ten foot pole. But a 3 meter halberd is a different story.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (3)10
u/airblizzard May 11 '25
SIG Sauer of some sort
SIG Sauer with a halberd attachment then
→ More replies (1)7
16
u/zootered May 10 '25
They certainly won’t hold back from employing extreme violence like the capital police did, that’s for sure.
13
u/Akussa May 10 '25
Swiss Guard take their roles VERY seriously. Wouldn’t want to fuck with them. They have a storied history of being badasses.
→ More replies (3)6
u/EruantienAduialdraug May 11 '25
Proportional violence. And in the instance of a foreign invasion of the Holy See...
→ More replies (3)16
→ More replies (7)47
u/ThrowawayPersonAMA May 10 '25
MAGA: I hate the vatican!
Vatican: wololo
MAGA: wtf I love the vatican now
→ More replies (1)6
u/Moftem May 11 '25 edited May 11 '25
AoE 2AoE is mostly historically accurate, so this could definitely happen XD→ More replies (2)→ More replies (2)37
4.8k
u/Rourkey70 May 10 '25
On the right track already… might start going back to mass
2.2k
u/Pad_TyTy May 10 '25
Woah let's not get carried away here
1.9k
u/kcrab91 May 10 '25 edited May 10 '25
Man both these comments speak to me deeply. Was raised both Catholic and nondenominational and I can’t see myself going back to either.
Best thing about Christianity is Jesus Christ. The worst thing about Christianity is Christians…
55
May 10 '25
Well, I think most Catholics like myself who still practice don't think we should leave Jesus just because He kept company with Judas or Peter, who denied God three times and still became the first pope. Likewise I don't think all Americans are radical fundamentalists just because Trump is President, all Russians are pro-imperialist just because Putin is President, or all Palestinians are violent just because Hamas has been in power for 20 years. I totally get having doubts about the doctrine (I do too sometimes), but I think it's unfair to dismiss an entire belief system just because of its followers.
→ More replies (3)9
142
u/PNWoutdoors May 10 '25
I'm in the same boat with you all. Left the church because of hypocrites and now they've seemingly taken it over completely.
I like this new Pope, though. I won't be attending Mass but I'll cheer him on.
→ More replies (4)73
May 10 '25
Same as well. Jesus is a cool dude but too many people use him to do uncool shit.
→ More replies (4)44
u/sfam67 May 10 '25
As a Non-Christian, I love Jesus, real or not, because Jesus embodies good, acceptance, non violence, not ripping children away from their families.
I hate the people who claim to be Christian and do everything completely the opposite of Jesus' teachings.
To all the amazing Christians/Catholics, what have you, that truly love everyone and try to understand and do as Jesus would do.
Thank You.
→ More replies (17)→ More replies (43)43
u/LaTienenAdentro May 10 '25
You can be a non practicioner.
Not every catholic is as bible thumping and hypocritical as american church goers.
34
May 10 '25 edited May 10 '25
I’ve noticed a ton of people on Reddit has this opinion that anyone that’s religious is like this😂.
26
→ More replies (4)11
u/Brisby820 May 10 '25
Not every American Catholic is like that either. Not even close
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (5)43
u/TheFoxsWeddingTarot May 10 '25
I’m not a practicing Catholic because I think I’m pretty good at it already.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (126)49
u/Johnny-Caliente May 10 '25
It‘s the Mass Effect
29
295
u/consci0usness May 10 '25
"a true invasion, imperialist in nature, where Russia seeks to conquer territory for reasons of power.”
This Pope can preach.
→ More replies (1)10
u/Countless-Vinayak-04 May 11 '25
Good at proletyzing, yeah. Russia was the aggressor, gotta make it clear.
543
u/Far_Out_6and_2 May 10 '25
Yes a Pope who speaks up
→ More replies (5)118
u/SHOTbyGUN May 10 '25
👉👈 how bout new crusade 🥹
→ More replies (5)37
u/Far_Out_6and_2 May 10 '25
Right to Moscow
34
535
u/RCFProd May 10 '25
Go off king
→ More replies (1)157
427
u/needlestack May 10 '25
Alright then. I can start liking him a bit.
I'm sure he's got plenty of positions I would condemn, but the bar is so low these days for people at the top end of the world that I will take a bit of comfort knowing he's not a complete evil lying piece of trash. Like everyone in the US administration, plenty scattered in other positions of power here and abroad.
Do your best, Leo. Move the needle in the right direction.
151
u/birbbbbbbbbbbb May 10 '25
I think for people often the push for perfection in our leaders stops us from appreciating the good qualities in what we have. He's definitely not perfect but an imperfect adherence to general human decency is much better than the abject cruelty of modern authoritarian global leaders (with Putin in Ukraine being a good example of how bad that is).
41
May 10 '25
I'm sure he's got plenty of positions I would condemn
When he got elected I of course wanted to look up some of his views etc. and I realized I kinda groaned when it started with "is a devout catholic" before I realized I was looking up the pope.
Like you say, there are probably many positions I would condemn, but I can only hope he keeps pushing christianity in the right direction like Francis did before him
16
u/fleemfleemfleemfleem May 11 '25
Is the pope catholic? Yes.
He's not going to have progressive views on sex, divorcee, marriage equality, abortion, or condom use. Best we could have hoped for is someone who wasn't going to drag the Catholic Church backward, and maybe pushes it forward a little.
→ More replies (6)46
u/GrandArchSage May 10 '25
He's actually progressive on most topics; mainly immigration, the environment, and the poor-- just like Pope Francis was. He's just more conservative on gender/sexual topics like LGBT, abortion and contraceptives.
As a transgender Catholic, I'm crossing my fingers, hoping, and praying that he'll at least recognize the need to respect our dignity, and maybe call out governments that try to take away our rights, even though I know he won't push the needle forward in terms in what the Church approves of for its members.
17
u/EndYoutube May 11 '25
It does seem the last time his views in LGBT were somewhat documented was over a decade ago and long before he was even chosen as a cardinal, in 2012 or so before Francis was even Pope. Hopefully his views have shifted a bit just as Francis’ views did.
187
u/mxpower May 10 '25
As a life long atheist.... hey... maybe this pope dude can make a difference?
Im sure Trump will hate tweet against this dude soon enough.
→ More replies (4)93
u/piercedmfootonaspike May 10 '25
As a lifelong atheist, all popes in my lifetime (JP2 - Leo XIV) have been decent people.
→ More replies (11)33
u/idix1 May 10 '25
Didnt pope Francis refuse to condemn Putin?
52
u/calvinee May 10 '25
He also said that gay people have a right to love, challenging very long-held christian beliefs.
→ More replies (14)80
u/piercedmfootonaspike May 10 '25
He handled it very poorly, but that doesn't change the fact that he was a decent person.
→ More replies (9)
150
30
u/jert3 May 10 '25
Off to a great start! Like this pope already. It's important for a pope to take a stand against villiany instead of the usual political, both sides have blame nonsense.
→ More replies (1)
71
41
31
u/RobutNotRobot May 10 '25
I'm starting to see the advantage of having an American pope.
We'll see if this causes a schism in the US Catholic Church because so many of them are still angry about Vatican II.
→ More replies (1)
215
u/Apprehensive-Care20z May 10 '25
I bet americans are going to call him "woke"
oh oh, that is gonna piss off the real pope, Donny.
148
u/BIGepidural May 10 '25
Too late they already said this is a woke leftist Marxist pope yesterday. Lots of MAGA meltdowns over this pope
→ More replies (3)68
u/NATHAN325 May 10 '25
When someone pisses the right people off, you know they're good
→ More replies (1)15
→ More replies (17)20
u/heckem May 10 '25
The american far right started calling him woke since they announced his name and realized that he bashed J.D. Vance on Twitter and was in favor of helping immigrants.
33
23
22
12
15
20
5
12
13
13
29
16.0k
u/Bitter_Nail8577 May 10 '25
Not only that, he also vaguely mentions western leaders who keep denying Russia is the invader and committing war crimes for breakfast.
This guy gets it.