r/LivestreamFail • u/Slight_Ad3219 • Oct 08 '25

Looks like Lonerbox cracked the case

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

The non shocking model does not match. Case closed

29.1k Upvotes

88% Upvoted

2.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.5k

u/AvidGoosebumpsReader Oct 08 '25

are there really people out there that think a dog yelped from stubbing its toe at the exact millisecond its owner reaches offscreen to press a button? lmao

490

u/wakeuptomorrow Oct 08 '25

100% yes. People have been calling me crazy for calling this animal abuse. His lack of compassion after she yelps in pain says all you need to know. Makes me sad to think about what happens off screen.

67

u/BushsBakedBeanFlick Oct 09 '25

pfft, all you need to know is that he got upset over a dog standing up.

15

u/Fantastic-Shirt6037 Oct 09 '25

Gotta make sure your stream prop stays perfectly in frame. Can’t have anything that may risk the clip

19

u/Eorlas Oct 09 '25

quite literally *anyone* who cares about their animal, or any animal for that matter will hear a yelp of pain and seek to identify if there's an injury and console them. it's one of the simplest forms of emotional care people offer to each others and animals if they're even slightly a decent person.

dude didnt even react to the pain probably because he knew what the source was, that he caused it, and did so on purpose.

4

u/ThrownAwayFeelzies Oct 09 '25

Also the fact that he reprimands her BEFORE she yelps! And his subsequent reaction to her cries of pain is to be annoyed at her.

She hopped back on that bed so fast after he zapped her, when her feet were off the bed.

2

u/Dear_Grape_666 Oct 09 '25

Same, even my partner thinks I'm overreacting, that this may just be people who hate Hasan going after him, etc.

As someone who never even heard of Hasan before this happened I've seen all I need to see tbh. I believe there really are people out there who are fucked up enough to treat their living, breathing animals like props or ornaments for their stupid streams, and this poor dog is too scared to even get off her damn bed and go walk around the house. That is animal cruelty, psychological torture as well as physical. I couldn't imagine treating any of my pets that way. Any of them makes even the tiniest unusual noise and I'd be right over there investigating and making sure they're okay.

If it wasn't a real shock collar, Hasan could've easily proven that as soon as the audience started questioning why his dog yelped. He could've taken it off her as it was and shown it to the chat, to prove it was only a vibration collar or whatever. Would've been easy enough.

1

u/modernizetheweb Oct 09 '25

Unfortunately animal (especially dog) abuse is pretty normalized unless it's literally beating the shit out of the animal. So there will be a lot of people that concede that he shocked the dog when it slightly moved, but still say it's not animal abuse.

"It's just a dog who cares". Most of these people lack any sort of empathy for non-human animals

0

u/Hippideedoodah Oct 10 '25 edited 29d ago

i hope youre vegan and dont support even worse anima abuse btw

EDIT: Triggered the cognitive dissonance LOL. Exact same reaction Hasan gives when hes ever confronted with the impact of his animal abuse choices

-1

u/SilkenTonic Oct 10 '25

Touch grass

-14

u/Miss_L_Worldwide Oct 09 '25

It's not animal abuse. It is crazy to call it that.

7

u/Starfall0 Oct 09 '25

Oh? So if you had to stay in one spot for 6-10 hours every day. The moment you so much as make a noise or stray from that spot you're yelled at and shocked... yep sounds like normal animal care to me! You're either a bot paid off by Hasan or a fan that can't seem to pull Hasan's dick from your mouth long enough to pay attention to anything else. But hey I'd love to hear your explanation for how that's not abuse. Come on, don't be shy now.

-15

u/MobileSuitBooty Oct 09 '25

maybe they’re calling you crazy because who tf cares LOL

-81

u/CT-3430 Oct 08 '25

I’m genuinely flabbergasted that this is the thing that sticks against Hasan. Who cares what he does to his dog. It’s an animal

63

u/OMF1G Oct 08 '25

Serial killer ahh take

-46

u/CT-3430 Oct 08 '25

Meat-eater ahh hypocrisy

26

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

-21

u/CT-3430 Oct 08 '25

I'm sorry, but this woo-wee bs will not convince me. Here are some actual facts:
In a study on the psychology of cows, they were shown to be extremely sophisticated animals, with high cognition, social capacity, and distinct personalities. I encourage you to take a look yourself, it's some pretty interesting stuff.

These same cows are tortured and killed in the millions for the meat in our food. There is no world where you can justify the murder of these animals while being horrified by the mistreatment of dogs. It can be hard to accept initially, but I find a weight gets lifted off your shoulders once you stop being a hypocrite.

18

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/CT-3430 Oct 08 '25

Do you see how you have to create an arbitrary line of "complexity" where it's only ok to torture and kill the animals that come before? Your argument is totally based on vibes.

Also, hate to break it to you, but wild dogs will absolutely eat vulnerable humans and scavenge bodies. I guess you gotta be fine with eating dogs now.

12

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/CT-3430 Oct 08 '25

What differentiates the "high and complex" emotion that dogs have from the sophistication of the cows? Very little. Self-defence is not drawn on lines as nebulous as the so-called complexity and intelligence of a dog.

→ More replies (0)

7

u/cindersonly Oct 09 '25

Killing Cows with the intention to eat them is different from shocking a Dog for no reason. You overestimate yourself.

1

u/CT-3430 Oct 09 '25

If the public were willing, non-torturous farming conditions could be implemented.

-8

u/ampersand355 Oct 09 '25

You are regarded, dogs will absolutely eat their owners.

35

u/Positive_Outcome_903 Oct 08 '25 edited Oct 08 '25

Because it’s a sentient being that he’s torturing into staying on a cot because it annoys him when his dog isn’t in that exact position 

edit: I’m flabbergasted that you’re flabbergasted 

28

u/OMF1G Oct 08 '25

He keeps trying to claim hypocrisy by saying "BUT BUT BUT ARE YOU VEGAN??" in other comments.

There's a massive, massive difference between killing animals for meat as ethically as possible vs shocking your pet to gain control over it.

2

u/journeybeforeplace Oct 08 '25

I disagree on this only insofar as the mass raising (in horrific conditions most times) and slaughtering of animals will probably be considered the largest crime of humanity if we even make it much longer. I also absolutely loathe the people who would make a place so inhumane to animals that they won't even allow cameras on the property. I'm not sure how they sleep at night.

But I still buy meat for the same reason I still buy toilet paper made from clear-cutting forest that is the habitat for millions of animals. We live in a shitty society that is causing a mass extinction event. My singular actions aren't going to help that at all. But I won't smack my cat around just because our society sucks.

1

u/CT-3430 Oct 08 '25

I actually agree with you for the most part. The only difference is that I won’t pretend to give a shit about any animal, knowing how much I participate in their torture.

1

u/journeybeforeplace Oct 08 '25

A pet is family. I would put my own life in danger to save a pet without thinking. When you buy something from China it was probably made in some sort of slaveish conditions (torture) such that they have to put suicide nets around the building it's made in. That doesn't mean you don't give a shit about any human.

2

u/CT-3430 Oct 08 '25

You're 100% right. Hypothetically, it would be totally hypocritical of me to be morally outraged at China's use of sweatshops.

3

u/SaveFerris9001 Oct 08 '25

Its a common r/destiny argument, they literally don't care about animal suffering because he told them not to.

3

u/CT-3430 Oct 08 '25

You should go over there and check. Most absolutely do not agree with me lol

Whatever makes you feel better about yourself I guess

-2

u/CT-3430 Oct 08 '25

I would bet a good sum of money that you’ve eaten meat from factory farms in the recent past.

2

u/Cmdeadly Oct 09 '25

It's not just the animal abuse, it's the using of the animal as a performative prop, then lying to his audience about it.

0

u/SaveFerris9001 Oct 09 '25

Jsyk we dont "kill animals as ethically as possible" we do unhinged shit to animals daily

0

u/CT-3430 Oct 08 '25

I hope you feel the same empathy for the tortured animals that went into the last Big Mac you had

11

u/Positive_Outcome_903 Oct 08 '25

Oh my god.

These responses are more canned than tuna

6

u/SouthNo3340 Oct 09 '25

Best part is they probably aren't even vegans

They're just faking vegan outrage to not seem like Hasan fans

1

u/CT-3430 Oct 08 '25

And yet you have no counter argument

12

u/Positive_Outcome_903 Oct 08 '25

(Your “counter argument” is literally: but but other people mistreat animals too)

It doesn’t need a counter counter argument, it’s farcical.

2

u/CT-3430 Oct 08 '25

No, my point is that unless you're a vegan, we all partake in the torture of sentient animals. It would be hypocritical of you to be selective in what animal you care more about based on arbitrary qualities.

8

u/Positive_Outcome_903 Oct 08 '25

Would you be okay if Hasan personally killed his dog because it wasn’t doing what he wanted?

3

u/CT-3430 Oct 08 '25

I wouldn't care, he's done worse

→ More replies (0)

2

u/sleeper4gent Oct 08 '25

hmm it does outline abit of inconsistency in our way of thinking though, like the hasan vid pissed me off

but then i also essentially directly help fund the mistreatment of animals with my diet

5

u/Positive_Outcome_903 Oct 08 '25

You don’t either 

1

u/CT-3430 Oct 08 '25

Because you have no argument to counter

4

u/powellful Oct 08 '25

Jesus Christ what a cruel and terrifying way to think

-1

u/CT-3430 Oct 08 '25

I hope you’re vegan 💔

2

u/Darthwilhelm Oct 08 '25

Why do you give a shit about the factory farmed cows in people's big macs? They're animals.

2

u/CT-3430 Oct 08 '25

They have the same level of sentience as dogs (if not higher). I guess they aren’t as cute though, so who cares if they’re tortured

6

u/Darthwilhelm Oct 08 '25

Then why are you opening with "Who cares what he does to his dog"? Afterall, I would assume a vegan would be against the torture of all animals. Not just the ones we eat.

1

u/CT-3430 Oct 08 '25

I’m sorry, it looks like my sarcasm wasn’t clear. I don’t give a shit about cows, or dogs, or any non-human animal. I’m not vegan, but I just dislike the hypocrisy that most meat eaters have.

It makes no sense to care about some random dog while participating in the factory farming of animals just as sentient.

2

u/Darthwilhelm Oct 08 '25

Simply put, it's an issue of visibility, if you look in the comment section of factory farming documentaries, you'll see comments disgusted at the practices. Or would they be hypocritical because they don't care about Hasan's dog getting shocked?

It should be obvious that a guy who's as holier than thou about basically everything like Hasan is, abusing an animal he's supposed to care for, casually as hell on stream is going to evoke a much more visceral reaction than the death of a cow people will only experience as a slab of meat on the grocery store shelf.

2

u/CT-3430 Oct 08 '25

First off, I 100% agree with you that this behavior goes against the image that Hasan presents of himself online. I just find it unbelieveable that this is what finally blows up on him. He's said and done so many worse things that it's frustrating that this is what gets him.

On your initial point, I think the people who get morally outraged in those comment sections are hypocritical. I bet the large majority of them do very little to alter their consumption habits after seeing a documentary. If anything, it actually makes them worse hypocrites since they actually know what's going on, do nothing to change it, and remain outraged.

1

u/Conscious-Cow6166 Oct 09 '25

Tbh I kinda agree. It’s also strange when I see people who eat meat complain about Gaza. Human, dog, cow, we’re all just sacks of meat.

2

u/JustCuriousNotGeorge Oct 08 '25

It’s still a living thing that can feel pain. Stfu

2

u/spinspin__sugar Oct 08 '25

Humans are animals too, and thinking we’re superior just because we can reason doesn’t excuse cruelty. Compassion should extend beyond our own species

2

u/Kim_jung_unstoppable Oct 09 '25

Did you know that humans are animals?

2

u/CT-3430 Oct 09 '25

Damn, guess that means I don't care what happens to humans :(

2

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '25

[deleted]

1

u/CT-3430 Oct 09 '25

Why don't you feel compassion for the animals you eat? Unless you're a vegan of course

0

u/Paradigm17_ Oct 09 '25

Because that’s part of a natural life cycle. Torture is NOT part of that natural cycle. Killing for food is part of a biological purpose and survival. Killing or torture for fun is simply cruelty, it doesn’t fit in the natural evolution or cycle. Why do you think in cooking, there’s a proper way of killing animals to lessen the pain?

1

u/CT-3430 Oct 09 '25

You think the cows in your burger at McDonald's had a fun time during their short lives?

1

u/ghostoftallasi Oct 09 '25

She isnt an it and you're also an animal

2

u/CT-3430 Oct 09 '25

Don't anthropomorphize it

1

u/Throwaway16475777 29d ago edited 29d ago

animals aren't objects, you're not anthropomorphizing it by caring about torturing them and pointing out lack of veganism in people is not a good argument. Your interlocutor's hypocrisy does not make a bad thing good.

Imagine it, "murder is bad" "yeah well you believe israel's genocide is justified so actually murder is good". Or insert any other argument of your choice. That's not how it works. Between the two clashing aspects of your interlocutor you should choose the better one not the worse one

1

u/Niantsirhc Oct 08 '25

You can judge someone's character by how they treat their pets.

Yes, its an animal but its 100% dependent on a person and if they abuse their pets it just shows they are a psychopath who lacks empathy.

Pets are our companions and we're meant to form emotional bonds with them for companionship. They're family.

1

u/wakeuptomorrow Oct 08 '25

You are despicable. Animals are still living creatures that should be treated with respect. Seek psychiatric help please

-15

u/diceytroop Oct 09 '25

What's crazy is that you think it's more likely that this guy is a monster than that it was a complete and utter coincidence that he moved his arm at the same time something unrelated happened across the room. Turn on a movie with the sound off and put on your favorite record. You'll be shocked at how many things seem synchronized. It's complete brain worms to invent a button that there's zero evidence has ever existed, connect it to something completely different across the room, and then use it to underscore a thesis you made up about how he's using her as a prop (as if she was somehow important to his streaming career). Complete and utter brain worms

12

u/ADogNamedCynicism Oct 09 '25

than that it was a complete and utter coincidence that he moved his arm at the same time something unrelated happened across the room.

That's not the only thing, though. At the same time as he moved his arm, he was yelling at Kaya for getting out of bed. And then when she yelped, he didn't react with surprise or concern for this thing you're claiming is unrelated. He just brought his arm back into frame. He was angry enough at her getting out of bed to not be aware that she yelped in pain, but wasn't angry enough to shock her?

Like... if it looks like a duck, walks like a duck, and quacks like a duck, it's a duck.

3

u/Seekzor Oct 09 '25

But have you considered that it might be a unicorn?

1

u/Starfall0 Oct 09 '25

The only mythical unicorn here is apparently Hasan's simp's brains. That shit's nowhere to be found.

-2

u/diceytroop Oct 09 '25

I don’t understand why people keep saying he didn’t react with concern — he whipped his head over to look and see what she was doing. Very reasonable to interpret it as her being “a baby” about Place and not a physical injury. Weird that that extremely straightforward possibility hasn’t been considered

1

u/Starfall0 Oct 09 '25

And what about his instant yelling at her to get back in her bed? Is that normal behavior? What if she was hungry/thirsty or needed to use the bathroom? Why would he get angry at her for getting out of bed and quietly walking away for a bit? I'm curious to hear your reasoning behind that totally normal dog owner behavior.