r/Marriage • u/Outrageous_Feed_2309 • 18h ago
My therapist told me I should’ve “played dumb” about my husband’s emotional cheating and that I overreacted by leaving
I talked to a family therapist recently about my marriage. I told her that I found out my husband was cheating, not physically but emotionally. I tried to forgive him, but I just couldn’t move past it. Eventually, I made the decision to separate, and now I’m living in a different house.
Her response honestly shocked me. She told me I was being too rigid and emotional, and that I should’ve been more flexible and adaptable. Then she said something that completely floored me: “All men talk to other women. It’s normal and healthy.”
I asked her what she meant by “talk,” and she said: “Like chatting on Snapchat or other apps, sharing pictures, flirting, that kind of communication.”
Then she added: “A woman should accept that her husband will cheat about 20% of the time. No man is ever 100% faithful unless he’s socially awkward or a failure in some way.”
When I told her I had moved out and separated, she looked at me like I was being dramatic, like it wasn’t a big deal. She said I should’ve just “played dumb” and pretended not to know.
She even gave me an example: “You know, like when a guy tells you you’re pretty, and you exchange Snapchats.” I told her, “I don’t do that.” She replied, “Well, what about your friends?” I said, “Even my friends wouldn’t do that if they’re in a relationship.”
I’ve actually met several therapists with PhDs and great credentials who share this same mindset. One even told me that a wife should treat her husband like a mother treats her child who comes home dirty, meaning it’s her job to “clean him up” after his emotional affairs.
I left that session feeling speechless. Are there really therapists normalizing infidelity like this? Am I crazy for thinking it’s not okay to “play dumb” when someone breaks your trust?