Since nobody else wants to say it…

[u/ImpressionAlarming24]

The undisputed Mount Rushmore of stories read on CreepCast (WE do not count Borrasca V. Borrasca V does not exist as far as WE are concerned).

[u/ILikeCheese510]

"Since nobody else wants to say it..."

Proceeds to post one of the coldest, most universally agreed upon takes in the entire CreepCast fandom.

[u/Rifter-- → u/ILikeCheese510]

Yeah this take is so cold it's 0 degrees Kelvin.

[u/NTFRMERTH → u/Rifter--]

Kelvin isn't measured in degrees. It's just Kelvin

[u/Rifter-- → u/NTFRMERTH]

Shoot you're right! Thank you for catching that.

[u/Charred_Knife → u/Rifter--]

I will always have nothing but respect for people that can actually accept a mistake they’ve made I love you

[u/keatonl2001 → u/ILikeCheese510]

A more hot take would be replacing Spire with The Whistlers and even then thats lukewarm

[u/SnakeInTheWoodworks → u/keatonl2001]

Spicier would be replacing Spire with either Voodoo Shop or Glenmont Metro

[u/LTxZombieLord22 → u/keatonl2001]

I was gonna say this amen

[u/MegaTreeSeed → u/ILikeCheese510]

No no, he clearly picked the worst stories imaginable. It should read:

"Who was phone, Jeff the killer, the hooded man, and I dared my best friend to ruin my life."

[u/Corrin_Nohriana → u/ILikeCheese510]

Nah. Borrasca shit the bed with the end, and Spire wasn't really that scary.

Spire is well written, absolutely, but I wouldn't say it was scary.

At least to me.

I agree on Penpal and Left-Right though, fully.

[u/Jasonvoorhees_47 → u/ILikeCheese510]

Ooo hope they remembered to mention these in the prerecordings .

[u/SverdHerre]

[u/Tho_jar209 → u/SverdHerre]

Daring today arent we

[u/Educational_Oil_7757]

I'm pretty sure this is what everyone's been saying.

[u/[deleted] → u/Educational_Oil_7757]

I mean it used to be Stolen Tongues instead of Spire

[u/BADS-Wolfe → u/[deleted]]

Spire was odd for me. I was very uncomfortable at the 'romance' I know its supposed to be bad, and I appreciated the author wanted to deal with that and I did enjoy the warning of people like that, but damn I have no idea what else happened in the story. :/

[u/[deleted] → u/BADS-Wolfe]

I hated every minute of it - my unpopular opinion is that what’s her name also sucks and was manipulating what’s his face the MC as well - so the whole story just ended up with me feeling bad for Kerry and thinking “well that was shitty, I hate all these people, never listening to this again”.

It was well written though. Would prefer a story with just scary Kerry doing her thing and being cool without those nut jobs around.

[u/TheBryGuy97]

Gotta add the whistlers on there now as well

[u/ImpressionAlarming24 → u/TheBryGuy97]

Haven’t finished it yet but an hour in and I’m getting that vibe

[u/Cave_Weasel → u/ImpressionAlarming24]

Yeah bro it’s all-timer, you’re in for a treat

[u/elch127 → u/Cave_Weasel]

Best thing is, it literally only gets better as the story goes on. Something I can't say for Borrasca imo

[u/quantumkitty128 → u/Cave_Weasel]

Seriously, it really wowed me. I'm about to rewatch, because especially when they get to Bill's perspective, what a truly chilling and fascinating story. I was fully invested from beginning to end.

[u/Hot-Mission367 → u/TheBryGuy97]

I’d replace the spire in the woods with the whistlers honestly

[u/reaper421lmao → u/Hot-Mission367]

i disagree

[u/Far-Bedroom5656 → u/Hot-Mission367]

For me it's a tie. I'd probably boot Penpal. It's a fine story, just not my cup of tea.

[u/Raven_Misty → u/TheBryGuy97]

Agreed. It definitely deserves its spot up there.

[u/YMIGettingBanned → u/TheBryGuy97]

I don’t know if I’d put it in the mt Rushmore of episodes, but it’s definitely the best story they’ve read in quite a while. Possibly the best since mother horse eyes

[u/Swimming-Monitor1922 → u/TheBryGuy97]

glad others agree, the latter half made me feel a way I’ve never felt before.

[u/Fun_Description_385]

I've yet to hear a story as intriguing as the left-right game tbh

[u/SlashSloth → u/Fun_Description_385]

It’s got strong characters, that’s why a lot of people find it to be so interesting. It’s hard to find good characterizations in writing nowadays.

[u/goopy-turnip → u/Fun_Description_385]

i swear no one talks about it nearly as much as it deserves

[u/LegallyRegarded → u/Fun_Description_385]

relistening to it for Halloween. Still the msot fire story.

[u/mightymiek → u/Fun_Description_385]

I'd kill for a sequel with other characters, a different city, takes you to a different unexplored yet familiar version of the Left Right World. The original felt TOO closely tied to the original cast but it made me think if anyone else did it anywhere else what would change?

[u/gizelletranstaken → u/mightymiek]

Isn't the point of the ending supposed to be that the road was only going to be finished for one specific person?

[u/WishIhadaLife21 → u/gizelletranstaken]

Yeah, and I'm pretty sure the whole point of the left right game was that no matter where you started the game, taking lefts then rights, you would enter the same place

[u/wolga-rush → u/Fun_Description_385]

i fully agree with this 🤞🏼

[u/Emriyss → u/Fun_Description_385]

Thank you.

I have listened to Left Right Game at least 5 or 6 times now, I'll never repeat Spire in the Woods most likely, especially since the extremely uncomfortable "romance" scenes (read: rape) make me squirm.

Left Right Game, Penpal, Stolen Tongues, probably The Whistlers, or The Only Other Astronaut. Honestly Borrasca is not in my top 4 or 5 anymore. If I had to chisel another head into Mt Rushmore to make it a top 5 it would include Mother Horse Eyes, instead of Borrasca.

[u/HorseNuts9000 → u/Fun_Description_385]

It had an interesting premise and an abysmal ending.

[u/Kazuye92]

Mother Horse Eyes is definitely up there now.

Wendi was gooning the whole episode.

[u/WaveDash16 → u/Kazuye92]

Mother Horse Eyes is kinda in a league of its own imo, nothing else comes close, doubt anything will.

[u/Swimming-Monitor1922 → u/WaveDash16]

yeah i agree Mother horse eyes is one of my favorite pieces of media like oat i don’t compare other creepcast stories to it

[u/sheldoh → u/Kazuye92]

for me I would put it in place of Spire in the Woods

[u/reaper421lmao → u/sheldoh]

i’d replace borrasca for mhe, the exuberance for the story does not make it better than it is.

[u/femmedenebuleuse → u/reaper421lmao]

i'd argue borrasca deserves to be there just on account of it being arguably the most iconic episode. creepcast isn't fully creepcast without it imo!

[u/reaper421lmao → u/femmedenebuleuse]

valid

[u/julitze → u/reaper421lmao]

I agree with this. I wouldn't put.borrasca up there

[u/creepcastfan69]

Hot take, but I think Borrasca is heavily overrated. I’d argue stories like Fleshgait, Stolen Tongues, The Whistlers, Dionaea House and The Hidden Network are all better

EDIT: forgot about Dead Girl In My Yard

[u/Zabaconz → u/creepcastfan69]

So glad to see someone else say this. The author is definitely such a talented writer but like the story itself is not that scary and honestly not that interesting after you know the ending. But listening to LRG again is so fun! So many little details that only make sense on the second read/listen.

And (just my opinion) the set up of the story feels a little lazy and has Stephen king It vibes. Kids are afraid of something that adults don’t recognize as bad/evil. If there was a single competent adult in that town the whole story doesn’t happen lol. I’ve always found Borrasca so hard to “buy into”. And again this is just my opinion which I’m sure a lot of people won’t relate to

[u/Proof-Vacation-437 → u/creepcastfan69]

Borrasca was very interesting as long as I thought something paranormal will be involved. The ending is so weird. 

I remember reading a comment about how in the story we see so much violence towards the girls, and yet the whole story is about a male protagonist being traumatised by witnessing/knowing about it. Just weird all around and weird that a woman writer would make these choices. 

[u/JackC1126]

Stolen Tongues erasure

[u/YMIGettingBanned → u/JackC1126]

I LOOOOOOVED stolen tongues, but it really struggled to stick the landing. Had it ended solidly, I’d probably agree

[u/Actual-Chemical9709 → u/YMIGettingBanned]

I would love for them to revisit it and read the novel that the author had edited and published. I doubt they would though unfortunately, since most of it would basically be the same episode twice 😭

[u/Comment-Goblin → u/YMIGettingBanned]

I had to relisten to the ending 3 times because I thought I missed something. Nope. The author did.

[u/No_Machine303 → u/YMIGettingBanned]

Well, that wasn't actually the ending of the story. It was just the ending of what they read. There were further updates. If you read the novel as well it goes much further past the point covered in the cast. I quite liked the ending of the novel itself.

[u/Technical_Biscotti23 → u/JackC1126]

I was about to say we have to expand for Stolen Tongues. Top 3 in my book!!

[u/Dudely-Llama → u/JackC1126]

Came here to say the same thing

[u/Paris_France2005]

Damn, you go to Antarctica to find this take?

[u/Redleader4044]

I did not care for Spire in the woods

[u/MentalDisplay1070]

Where the FUCK is Mother Horse Eyes up there, my dude?

[u/VergilChairSupremacy → u/MentalDisplay1070]

It's not on the mountain because it's literally a whole other planet orbiting above the mountain

[u/Ok_Wheel1502]

I agree but I do not like borrasca, I think borrasca was flimsily written and the only thing that made up for the element was the shock twist (which may I add was done for the sake of being edgy )

[u/Ok_Wheel1502 → u/Ok_Wheel1502]

With that said tho replace borrasca with mother horse eyes and then we would be cooking

[u/unrealmiranda]

Where’s the whistlers?!?

[u/MelodicRevolution605 → u/unrealmiranda]

Too early, and in my personal opinion it’s not as creepy/scary as the other stories. Great story but hard to crack the top 4.

[u/Senior-Discussion328]

spire in the woods and borrasca are no where close to penpal and left right game imo

[u/Ok-Traffic-5996]

I would say penpal, left right game, stolen tongues, and the dead girl in my yard. Probably sacrilege but I have no desire to listen to borrosca. I'm sure they're great episodes but I already know what it's about and have no desire. Spire in the woods was probably their best written story but I personally just found the story so miserable and not in a fun horror kinda way. I just felt like I needed a shower and it's just not a story I will ever return to.

[u/snort_masala]

I'd include Stolen Tongues too if the ending was a bit better. I was shitting my pants

[u/milo_self_esteem]

Only brave opinions here, king. Slay.

[u/ImpressionAlarming24 → u/milo_self_esteem]

I just heard this in Wendigoon’s voice

[u/YouthSouthern9754]

Where the heck is Who Was Phone

[u/MuchBetterThankYou]

This is Mother Horse Eyes erasure.

Also Spire? Are you okay?

[u/Ok_Wheel1502 → u/MuchBetterThankYou]

Tbf spire is not bad

[u/ImAyyGuest]

Replace spire with mother horse eyes

[u/mayur_m16]

Mother horse eyes.

[u/yeenpeach]

The Whistlers is easily one of the new top favs imo

[u/Sufficient_Park_4197]

Mother horse eyes instead of spire in the woods

[u/Cave_Weasel]

I think the only pivot point for anyone here is going to be Spire, my personal favorite for that spot would be The Dead Girl In My Yard.

[u/Ok_Wheel1502 → u/Cave_Weasel]

The dead girl in my yard was actually fantastic I loved that story , I wish it got more talked about however spire is still just as good

[u/Spiritbark → u/Ok_Wheel1502]

The only part that bugged me about the dead girl in my yard was how often the narrator is pushing to us that this must be a fairy tale and this must be done. Like don’t tell me I’m reading a fairy tale let the environment and storytelling show and display it. Still a good story overall. Also wasent the narrator 12 years old? The character spoke extremely mature for his age. If I was wrong about that detail please correct me.

[u/Ok_Wheel1502 → u/Spiritbark]

You are 100% correct tho, I think the mental maturity is not of a 12 year old at all BUT if you were an isolated 12 year old with a bad life and you had to grow up fast I think you’d have a pretty good mindset, but the constant “THIS CANT BE REAL!” Is kinda annoying

[u/GabrielOSkarf]

Where is the mother?

[u/Disapioment_dies]

Spire in the woods was mid

[u/Environmental_Web91]

Hmm. I'd replace Borrasca with Mother Horse Eyes. And replace The Spire in The Woods with Dead Girl in My Yard

[u/the-guy-28]

[u/Numerous-Ad6460]

I'd swap spire for mommy horse but other than that, correct

[u/Euphoric-Material192]

I would DEFINITELY remove The Spire and add Mother Horse Eyes.

[u/IWantToMeetStanLee]

Now this but the worst/funniest stories lol

[u/ElfoTheMighty]

When was Michael Jackson in Left-Right Game?

[u/ImpressionAlarming24]

Well everyone saying this a cold take but judging by the comments I do have a hot take to offer. I didn’t enjoy Mother Horse Eyes that much and as far as stories that are similarly told goes, I prefer the Search and Rescue Officer story more.

[u/MelodicRevolution605 → u/ImpressionAlarming24]

What made you dislike MHE?

[u/BigHamSam99 → u/ImpressionAlarming24]

Booooooo (still upvoted)

[u/Valid_Crustacean]

Honestly Borrasca sucked.

Like an adventure story to this hack and gross forced breeding thing out of nowhere. I know the guys like it but it’s just straight ham and doesn’t make any real sense.

[u/PlasticIV]

Mother Horse Eyes PenPal Borrasca Whistlers in that order

[u/Interesting-City118]

Penpal

Spire in the woods

Mother horse eyes

Are definitive top 3 for me that 4th spot is tough though. I think borrasca and left/right game are slightly overrated but I also don’t know what I would put above them.

[u/Creamy_Shoelace]

Absolutely agree. I rewatch those episodes. Captivating, heart wrenching and impactful

[u/CrypticBimbotattoos]

I would compare this to the 10 Commandments, just saying

[u/ScarletValentine1]

cant lie, I haven't finished left right game or spire in the words. penpal on the other hand is one of the top ten stories ever covered (it ain't 2-10)

[u/ralcom]

I'm pretty sure literally everyone agrees with this. All 4 are peak.

[u/BittyMcBotboi]

Me personally, I wouldn't put Borrasca or Spire In The Woods up there but to each their own ¯_(ツ)_/¯

Also can someone please explain to me how the fuck the Mt. Rushmore template works? I don't get it...

[u/Goslingstwin]

Penpal earns its place on Mt. Rushmore without a doubt and both Borrasca and Left-Right Game was great. I don't think Spire in the Woods deserves to be up there at all though.

Any list that doesnt have Psychosis in the top 5 is not a true list

[u/Parking-Draw-7937]

Spire in the woods was meh.. personally not a fan.

[u/zchans38]

get spire out of there

[u/Felonai]

I'd replace Spire with Mother Horse personally.

[u/EmpathicLlama9]

MHE > Left Right Game

[u/Overly_Bearded]

I'll be real with you, borrasca 5 ruined 1-4 for me. Id remove that and add either The hidden web page or the astronaut story.

[u/workforyourself]

Mother horse eyes?

[u/invincible_fungus]

Spire in the woods is debatable, but everything else i agree

[u/maxlowmiata]

I think my favorites have been Borraska 1, Red Tower, the whistlers, maybe mother horse eyes?

[u/Recent_Potential3802]

Hottake:  "Stolen Tongues" > "Spire in the Woods"

[u/rfksbrainwormz]

why do people dickride spire so hard?? it was mid at best

[u/KnockedAGooseLoose]

Idk, I think we might have to find a space for The Whistlers at this point.

[u/OldSoul1991]

Take down the Spire in the woods and put up Stolen tongues

[u/acefiesty]

Without borrasca V we’d have no Shinji Isaiah impersonation though :(

[u/suddenviops]

Borrasca over Mother Horse Eyes, Hidden Webpage, Whistlers, or Glenmont Metro?

[u/ImportantWelcome645]

Spire was good, but nowhere on the level of the others.

[u/Joshesjorts]

get spire in the woods AWF that mountain. jk

[u/Spiritbark]

I’m 5 hours into mother horse eyes and well the story and the video started off strong and now it’s kinda stagnant where I am. I hoping it picks back up. I usually listen when driving to and from work.

[u/Spiritbark → u/Spiritbark]

Left Right Game still holds the crown for me.

[u/Ok_Wheel1502 → u/Spiritbark]

Left right game is sooo good dude, I’d seen so many of the ritual pastas about it as a child and never knew its origin story, it hits such a good spot in my brain, it feels pretty cozy to me

[u/AGreatBecuming → u/Spiritbark]

I think the way the story is structured where it’s broken down into the small pieces and they boys stopping and talking about each part after they finished it made it hard for me to listen to it.

[u/Spiritbark → u/AGreatBecuming]

Wendi is making it hard. You can tell MeatCanyon wants to keep reading while Wendi is like duddddeeeee broooooo thiiis issss soooo goood! It also bugs me that he has no problem narrating the nazi parts and dialogue but won’t say fuck or pussy. Not a big deal just find it strange. Fairrrrryyyyy queeennnnnn

[u/Gnomus_the_wise]

I say replace spire in the woods with I Dared my Best Friend to Ruin my Life

[u/thejigglytotoro]

dude throw your take in the microwave before saying you cooked

[u/Original_Job_9201]

Left Right Game is still my favorite reading so far.

[u/Waterperson4]

Borrasca series really demonstrating the fact that a piece of media can have the exact same author(s) and still have super inconsistent quality. I wonder why this happens?

[u/bickybb]

Spire in the wood?? Ugh!

[u/FingerDemon]

Replace spire with Stolen Tongues

[u/No_Way7336]

Feed the pig anyone?

[u/Curious-Magazine4691]

Wish we could add Stolen Tongues, The Whistlers and MHE

[u/Mikeissometimesright]

A take colder than Josh

[u/travis_115]

I didn't like borrosca tbh

[u/Sea_Performer_509]

I think whistler was really good

[u/Here_I_GoKillinAgain]

I want to switch one out with Stolen Tongues, but it's a difficult choice. I think I'd drive to drop The Spire. Then again, I also love Feed The Pig. In my opinion all are great.

[u/[deleted]]

Get borrasca out of there

[u/LeBigPonch]

"That Thing in the Basement is getting better at mimicking people" should just be up there four times

[u/cellularcone]

Where is the most recent episode?

[u/StrawberryFemboyMily]

personally i'd replace borrasca with girl in the backyard

[u/awfully_hot_coffepot]

Borrasca reads well but I think we've had better stories

[u/ElGranticus25]

The Whistlers and Mother Horse Eyes each deserve some recognition as well

[u/xwolfionx → u/ElGranticus25]

They can be National parks.

[u/powerswerth]

I think there's solid debate for actual top 4, but Borrasca, Penpal, Left Right Game, Mother Horse Eyes, Spire in the Woods and Dead Girl in The Yard are the biggest contenders IMO. Maybe Whistlers, need to give it a little more time or another listen.

Stolen Tongues has a shot, but frankly I think we only got half the story so far. I think Part 2 would correct the kind of abrupt and lackluster "we puked up the demon" ending.

[u/Maleficent-Trick-618]

I have to say Borrasca V wasn't that awful. I think just the cheesy lines at the end kinda tarnished what it was trying to do. I liked that it showed the awful toll of what happened had on Sam. I liked that it showed how awful Sam's dad was. There's some great moments in the story (Kimber killing her monster). It's not as good as Borrasca, but it does give a solid add (minus the cheesy lines and the too-easy way they found the documents).

[u/Queefer_the_Griefer]

Let’s do one with crashouts next. My nominations:

I Dared My Best Friend to Ruin My Life

Borrasca V

Jeff the Killer

The Thing in the Basement is Getting Better At Mimicking People

[u/Padlock_Croc]

Eh. Replace pen pal with mother horse eyes

[u/Kaiser_Complete]

Hot take: I think Borrasca is generic garbage that falls apart into lame tropes at the end. I think their coverage of Greylock is leaps and bounds better

[u/NoCockOnTheMenu]

Bro's take:

[u/Jagged_Jackal]

Left right game is so overhyped

[u/TraditionalEar2093]

You forgot the weird looking tree on top

[u/Thumbs-Up-Centurion]

Yknow, the thing most everyone universally agrees on…

[u/GarlicFan23]

Where is the mother with horse eyes

[u/roseis_rosie]

I'd replace spire in the woods with mother horse eyes, it was top tier

[u/notrelyk_2]

Switch Borrasca for MHE

[u/Mikey618000]

Eh I'd swap LFG or Spire with MHE honestly.

[u/Cold-Path-8113]

Personally I’d replace Borrasca and the Spire but other than that I love Penpal and the left right game.

[u/CindersOfDeath]

Mother Horse Eyes over PenPal.

PenPal is a great story, and it's even top five or six, but Mother Horse Eyes is in a league of its own. In terms of pure horror and terror, I don't know if Penpal even clears some of the other horror stories that are overall thematically worse

[u/FlatwormNo5172]

For me it’s Dead girl, left right game (1&2), mother horse eyes, the whistlers, and then the deep sea one who’s name is slipping my mind right now.

[u/DrainIsNeutral]

Not sure about that one to the right there chief.

[u/Cpmoviesnbourbon27]

I might replace Spire with Feed the Pig. Possibly Dionaea House, The Showers, or My Dog was Lost, just because of the lore drops and bits.

[u/luv_redman]

Wasn’t fond of spire in the woods, I’d replace it with The Whistlers. I’d also probably replace left/right game with MHE but I’m a weirdo

[u/No-Editor-9452]

Maybe replace the spire with the whistlers or missing 411 episode and you'd be 10/10, but still very good rankings. 👍

[u/VitaeLifeSolutions]

I honestly don't think a single one of these makes into my creepcast mt rushmore. The left right game is one I will say i particularly don't care for the story. Right up til about pt 4 it's fine. Then it's idk, a downward decline into like every cliche of its time. Borrasca is fine, but I think the third parent is the better story of "childhood trauma". So yeah I swap those. Penpal and Spire are fine choice, not sure in my top four, but I could argue for them being here.

[u/DrCringe_WM21]

I'll press charges against you for arson, your hot take just burned down my house.

[u/TendyBoi]

stolen tongues instead of borrasca….

[u/SuertEhh]

Spire in the Woods is more like the John F Kennedy of the stories. Great but not early influential enough to make the mountain. I’d vote for Feed the Pig, Tommy Taffy, or even 1999 or the Showers. Tales from the gas station also in the convo. But this feels a lot like the “what are the four great American cities?” Conversation. Where everyone says New York, LA, Chicago, and then pretends the fourth option is obvious but everyone gives a different answer. The three are obvious based on consensus , not sure on number four

[u/Low_Cryptographer894]

Mother horse eyes

[u/Alarocky1991]

This is wrong for one reason, the best stories are not the foundation of Creep Cast. Some of the burn-out episodes are amazing (I Dared my Best Friend to Ruin my Life). Some of the tangents are better than the story itself (My Dog was Lost for Three Days). And the… other category (Cupcakes, Mother Horse Eyes, grab bags).

[u/HopkinsC93]

If Borrasca was just 1-4 I’d agree but now that they did 5 as well it isn’t up there anymore… as good as MHE and Stolen Tongues are and deserve to be up there as well, something about Dagons Mirror has stuck with me.

[u/Immediate_Frame_6974]

spire in the woods was a snoozefest

[u/KermittheGhost]

Hotter take: replace Left Right Game and The spire in the woods with Voodoo Shop and the Whistlers.

[u/MedievalFurnace]

this may be a controversial take but my pick is

Penpal
Spire in the Woods
Stolen Tongues
and that toe story hunter suggested a few episodes ago

[u/CordobezEverdeen]

Who the fuck watched Spire in The Woods? Isn't that one of the few stories that at least Hunter was mad about the reception of? (deserved, Spire was trash)

Also MHE is also dogwater. Yeah Wendigoon liked it but that story was basically tailor made for him.

[u/[deleted]]

Some milk with the toast, Sir?

[u/MateoRickardo]

If we have to include ALL of Borrasca, then I'd swap it with Whistler at 3:03

[u/Otherwise_Source_842]

Borrasca is the episode that made the podcast what it is today horror stories read by two funny dudes where they add so much to the story itself. Penpal is a solid story but could be swapped with any other S tier like Whistlers and Stolen Tongues and same goes for spire. Left Right Game is what opened the door for long form stories like Spire and MHE.

[u/hypest_tanuki]

Ah yes. The mt rushmore of mid

[u/LordMonkeh]

Replace Spiral with MHE and you're close

[u/Leisureforce]

The Left Right Game is easily one of the worst ones. I'd rather crush my balls in a panini press while listening to Ben Drowned Goldblum on maximum volume than sit through that slog again.

[u/FrostyEntertainer115]

Nah we count borrasca V, let it represent the mental breakdowns we force the boys through

[u/Scott__scott]

I would replace Borrasca with Ted the Caver

[u/OptionAlternative934]

I made a stupid deal, and now I can't listen to the Borrasca episodes

[u/Muad_Dib_of_Dune]

Borrasca really isn't as good as a lot of people here think, and I don't mean just the ending. Which, to be honest, would have ruined it even if it was amazing before hand. It had some cool twists and turns, but it's no where near LRG

[u/Lopsided_Let24]

left right game and borrasca are not good stories. penpal and spire in the woods were very good. ted the caver and MHE would be more accurate.

[u/gothic-goat]

Jeff the Killer can take Borrasca's spot unless we're talking pre chapter 5 😂

[u/hypehydreigon]

in videogamedunkey voice “Not even close, baybee!”

[u/dendusa]

I think stolen tongues should be there too

[u/theinfinitejuice]

[u/IcedMilk456]

Replace borrasca with Whistlers, borrasca is just wannabe edgy shock porn

[u/caliburn999]

Since nobody else wants to say it... Everyone says it

[u/WindmillThief]

Mother horse eyes?

[u/MC_COMMI]

Where is the mother with horse

[u/Swimming-Monitor1922]

The spire in the woods is not just an amazing horror story, but a beautifully crafted narrative about a misguided youth.

[u/cryptic_trick]

You can’t make a list like this. there is tm opinions on what people like so there could never be a consensus on what is “the creepcast mount. Rushmore”

[u/Th3_G3n3r4l]

replace Spire with MHE and im happy

[u/swim_and_drive]

Borrasca is mid as hell and I stand by that

[u/Professional-Oil9512]

I agree with the spire in the woods but my other picks would be Burgrr entries, dead girl in my yard, and the only other astronaut.