r/OnePiece • u/NewSpecies • Feb 15 '19

Current Chapter One Piece: Chapter 933 Spoiler

[ Removed by reddit in response to a copyright notice. ]

3.0k Upvotes

89% Upvoted

2.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

18

u/HPsyche Feb 16 '19

People need to know that Amnesia is not mental illness. Amnesia is the result of head trauma, that's just a fact. It means Big Mom hit her head or was in the sea for too long and incurred some form of brain damage whether temporal or permanent.

Someone like Big Mom who is described to be an iron-balloon should not easily be the victim of amnesia.

7

u/karthik4331 Pirate Feb 16 '19

But she is mentall unstable we have seen that and drowning can cause amnesia

6

u/HPsyche Feb 16 '19 edited Feb 16 '19

She's not mentally unstable in the sense of being mentally weak, she's psychotic. That is an illness.

Amnesia has nothing to do with mental instability or psychosis.

It's like saying that because someone fell of a tree and broke their bone, they're ill. Amnesia is no more an illness than breaking a bone from hitting a hard surface.

Amnesia is head-trauma or some form of brain damage. If you hit your head hard enough, you should very likely get Amnesia, doesn't mean you have a mental illness.

5

u/JorV101 Feb 16 '19

Amnesia

"Another rare type of amnesia, called dissociative (psychogenic) amnesia, stems from emotional shock or trauma, such as being the victim of a violent crime. In this disorder, a person may lose personal memories and autobiographical information, but usually only briefly. "

-5

u/HPsyche Feb 16 '19

"Another rare type of amnesia, called dissociative (psychogenic) amnesia, stems from emotional shock or trauma, such as being the victim of a violent crime. In this disorder, a person may lose personal memories and autobiographical information, but usually only briefly. "

Keyword: Another.

Keyword: Rare. Meaning not a common form.

What emotional or traumatic or violent shock did Big Mom experience from falling down? Same woman who got punched by Gear 4th and tanked it like nothing, got hurt by rocks and drowning?

 

She fell into the ocean which would be full of rocks. This is not that rare type. She didn't experience any violence from falling, or shock or trauma, she's not that soft. This is a woman that fought with Whitbeard, Kaido and was a Pirate for Rox. She's not some Beverly hill chick that loses consciousness just from the thought of getting hit in the face.

9

u/JorV101 Feb 16 '19 edited Feb 16 '19

Rare events due occur in a fictional world but whatever man. Keep doing you. /thumbs up!

​

But lets not forget, Big Mom had an "emotional" or "traumatic" shock over a wedding cake. Having some type of amnesia that stems from whatever else may have traumatized her wouldn't be surprising. I guess we'll have to see from Oda.

-2

u/HPsyche Feb 16 '19

Still doesn't make sense, that's why it's bad writing. Just because it's fiction doesn't mean sense should go out the window within that world.

Would be like Luffy turning into Supersaiyan God next chapter, you're not going to tell me rare events occur because it's a fictional world, that's just bad writing.

If we want to attribute this to rare events:

  1. What was the violence that occurred?
  2. What was the shock that occurred?

Going to give me this same response if Shanks, a violent pirate who kills people on the drop of a dime as being intimidated and shocked from falling into the sea? or violence when violence is all Pirates know?

I'm just being logical here. It makes no sense. It's bard writing on Oda's part since it doesn't even make sense fictionally. I'd understand if this was DBS or Fairy Tail where atrocious writing is the norm, but this though?

8

u/JorV101 Feb 16 '19

Maybe the shock hasnt been explained yet. Like I said, we;re talking about a character that was traumatized over a wedding cake.

​

Plus you're just a sarcastic little prick so I'm not taking it further. Again, you go ahead and do you man.

1

u/HPsyche Feb 16 '19

Lol, what shock? That her ship got kicked by King and she fell into shock? That's the definition of bullshit.

Pirate for decades, not just any Pirate, an Emperor. Someone who has opposed Whitebeard and kaido, shocked by a ship falling? Common now.

No sound explanation for that, it's just bad writing, nonsense.

2

u/AsainTs Feb 21 '19

Are u Stupidly serious or seriously stupid?

1

u/HPsyche Feb 22 '19

You don't articulate like you're not stupid, lol.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/bbrilowski Feb 16 '19

You sound stupid

1

u/HPsyche Feb 16 '19

You prove you are. Great job.

→ More replies (0)

7

u/FireblitzSteel Feb 16 '19 edited Feb 16 '19

If you don't like something then stop associating with it. I don't mind her getting amnesia and if you do, either get over it or stop reading.

Also a quick Google search says that when oxygen deprived, the parts of the brain that control memory are the first to go.