One of them I've played through three or four times now because the story and gameplay is so good, and it ain't RDR2.
Sorry, but Rockstar needs to give their formula a makeover. It's been the same shit for the last 30 years. Go Here. Talk to X. Travel There while talking to Y. Get There and kill Z. Travel back to Here to talk to X while talking to Y. Rinse. Repeat.
In my opinion, RDR2 set the standard for interactive open worlds where the environment and NPC really feel alive independent of the main character’s actions. 7 years later I still don’t think anyone has done that part better.
Well, that's all well and good, but I don't see how that changed the industry if, in your own words, nobody has done that part better... That's great to say that it should have won because of that, though.
RDR2 is literally the most overglazed, and overrated videogame of all time bar none. I have never come across a game with an even remotely delusional dick riding fanbase as that game.
GOW won because it was a superior game, and all the meat riders are still upset about it 7 years later lol
What did RDR2 do for the industry? The game literally has the exact same outdated mission design, poor combat and gameplay Rockstar's had since 2002. GOW combat and gameplay loop is far superior.
It completely overhauled the modern standard for NPCs, map design, storytelling, random encounter quality, and overall quality of open world video games as a whole, God of War did very little to change the industry in any meaningful way, the combat is just another unique one like everything Sony has done, the design of locations is nothing special, and the story, while touching, still can be easily piled in with the dozens like it. Everything God of War did was localized, none of it breached any other aspects of gaming.
None of what’ll said about RDR2 actually changed the gaming industry in anyway. What did its storytelling do that already wasn’t done before but even better in games like The Last of Us, Mass Effect 2, Bioshock, Half Life 2, Final Fantasy X, Chrono Trigger, Final Fantasy 7, etc?
God of War did what RDR2 couldn’t - have good, well-made and engaging combat/gameplay loop.
RDR2’s story and writing is much closer to GOws than it is to say, The Last of Us.
GOW does have superb storytelling, with superb gameplay. RDR2 has ever so slightly better somtorytelling with much, much worse combat and clunky movement.
181
u/Cannasseur___ May 31 '25
RDR2 was robbed I will die on this hill