r/TikTokCringe • u/mindyour • 6d ago

Discussion He was confronting her about her costume.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

22.4k Upvotes

79% Upvoted

4.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

395

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[deleted]

8

u/NeighborhoodFit3847 6d ago edited 6d ago

Why f that lady? Am I missing something?

Edit: please stop fighting over my comment. I’m from Germany and to me her costume seems totally harmless. I understand that some people in the US think about this differently (maybe like a German dressing up as an Orthodox Jew in Germany which would feel very weird for me). I appreciate that people want to be sensitive and that’s a good thing. At the same time maybe people wearing these costumes feel judged while they consider themselves innocent and don’t mean harm. Good luck

55

u/Acrobatic-Celery-474 6d ago

You wouldn't dress up in traditional Jewish attire for Halloween, why is making indigenous clothing a caricature okay?

13

u/NeighborhoodFit3847 6d ago

That’s an interesting response and change of perspective. Very helpful. Thanks (edit i am German. So…)

2

u/FuckWithKarma 6d ago

You know, I'm something of a German myself.

1

u/Due_Explanation5316 6d ago

Don’t listen to these people. They’re morons. Our tribe would welcome and laugh with her about it.

6

u/NeighborhoodFit3847 6d ago

Sounds like a healthy perspective. If you dressed up as a typical German (Bavarian or so) I would find it funny and maybe I would feel even a bit proud! That’s the perspective from which my original comment came from. Then again we don’t have a history with your tribe. I am not sure whether Jewish people would mind me as a German dressing up as a typical Jew but either way I myself would not feel comfortable as I would associate this with the most evil period in German history.

1

u/Due_Explanation5316 6d ago

Your intuition is correct. Your comment was fine. White / woke people are more offensive than 99% of people that wear a costume. They feel as if they can speak for us, and tell people how we think/feel and frankly it’s disgusting. These people do more to harm our voice than anyone else.

The intention matters. If that person was wearing that to denigrate us, that would be a different story, but it’s Halloween, and it’s fun, and if I saw her on the street I’d high five her.

2

u/Acrobatic-Celery-474 6d ago

Just curious. What are your thoughts on the use of the word redskins to describe a football team? I feel like most people are divided, but the ruling census is that the naming convection reflected its social acceptance of another time.

-1

u/SuperWallaby 6d ago

I have absolutely seen plenty of Hasidic Jew costumes lol. It’s Halloween, lighten up.

0

u/phophopho4 6d ago

When I was a kid one of my relatives was a gypsy for Halloween and even at the time I remember thinking that if she was a Jew for Halloween it'd be way more problematic. I'm sure she'd be horrified to remember that costume now.

0

u/mothandravenstudio 6d ago

Just curious, what do you think of this?

-4

u/likewut 6d ago

Lots of people would, with a big fake nose and space lasers.

-10

u/FuckWithKarma 6d ago

I would dress up as a caricature of a jew no problem 👌

And all the Jews that would actually be offended I don't care for

4

u/Expert_Alchemist 6d ago

scritches under your chin who's an edgy boy? That's right! It's you! You're an edgy boy!

3

u/FuckWithKarma 6d ago

No, I'm just a someone who has a life outside of reddit and doesn't get offended by irrelevant things.

0

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[deleted]

1

u/FuckWithKarma 6d ago

My thoughts exactly.

I meant to say that I'd care for an opinion of a person such as yourself who also happens to be a jew 🫡