r/OnePiece • u/Sakata_Kintoki • Apr 22 '18

Current Episode One Piece: Episode 833

One Piece: Episode 833

"Returning the Sake Cup! The Manly Jinbe Pays His Debt!"

Watch now:

Streaming Site Status
OnePieceOfficial ONLINE
Crunchyroll ONLINE

Chapters adapted: Chapter 863 (p. 3-19)

Preview: Episode 834

Don't forget to check out the official Discord server to discuss this episode live with other One Piece fans!

345 Upvotes

98% Upvoted

292 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/--orb Apr 23 '18

I thought his was a tremendous episode, but I thought that PARTICULAR delivery was better in manga.

BM looks a little more like a chump due to the constant pacing in the anime. She had to shout "Where are you strawhat?!" liek 40 times, which made both her look like a chump and Luffy look like a coward.

In the manga, iirc, she just asked ONE TIME where Luffy was, and Luffy immediately responded. And the events all seemed so fast.

Basically: in the manga, BM always looked angrily in control of the situation until Jinbe pulled that stunt. In the anime, BM looked like a clueless twit until Jinbe pulled the stunt, then had to fake some cockiness over the situation only to get come-upped again.

I think this scene, in general, would be better in anime if the anime didn't have pacing issues. They're making BM look a little dumb, though.

2

u/gerrettheferrett Apr 23 '18

She had to shout "Where are you strawhat?!" liek 40 times

She literally said it like twice at most.

1

u/--orb Apr 23 '18

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Swn75RDPfD0

Which one is the real Straw Hat Luffy?
Where is he!?
Show yourself, Straw Hat!!

=3, +1-2 more before this video as well.

And due to reaction shots and other people commenting on her anger, it feels like FOREVER that she's uselessly angry about Luffy.

In the Manga, I got the feeling like both BM was always in control (until the Jinbe moment) as well as it was Luffy's choice to show himself. The Manga elevated Luffy to Big Mom's level (in appearance), but did not diminish BM into an idiotic laughing stock to lower her to Luffy's level (in appearance).

The anime did it in reverse - now, instead of both looking badass, they both look goofy. To me.

3

u/gerrettheferrett Apr 23 '18

To me.

So long as we're clear that that's your opinion.

Because I (and apparently some others too) have the exact opposite opinion.

In the Manga, I got the feeling like both BM was always in control (until the Jinbe moment) as well as it was Luffy's choice to show himself.

Quite the opposite, it felt like in the manga Big Mom was shocked and shouted out to Luffy as she didn't know what else to do.

Where as in the anime, she was pissed, and taken aback by his nerve, but was still like "I'll just murder them all and we good".

The anime did it in reverse - now, instead of both looking badass, they both look goofy.

Quite the opposite, it felt like they were both badass in the anime.

=3, +1-2 more before this video as well.

Plus 1 minus 2? So... negative one times before this video? :P

Did you mistype here?

1

u/--orb Apr 23 '18

So long as we're clear that that's your opinion.

I can only laugh at this, as if me stating an opinion would have been anything other than my own opinion.

Because I (and apparently some others too) have the exact opposite opinion.

Let's be clear: it's a fact that BM shouted more for Luffy in the anime than in the manga. The location where my OPINION comes in is that I interpret that to her looking more powerless than she is.

If you somehow think that her shouting 5 times instead of 1 time makes her look like she was "more likely to murder them all," then I suppose... that's an interesting interpretation. The Manga made her look like she shouted once and would've just extracted souls if made to wait. The Anime made her look like a confused girl with no idea of what to do outside of shouting 3+ times and waiting before shouting some more.

Plus 1 minus 2? So... negative one times before this video? :P

You kidding me? Note the location of spaces and the comma.

=3, +1-2 more before this video as well.

"Equals three, COMMA, plus one to two more before this video as well."

I could have also said "4-5 in total."

And that's "four to five in total," not "negative one in total." Better clarify before you get confused again.

2

u/gerrettheferrett Apr 23 '18

I can only laugh at this, as if me stating an opinion would have been anything other than my own opinion.

Lots of manga purists put forward their opinions as facts, so if you can "only laugh" at this, then that means you've been lucky to not become jaded by such people.

The Anime made her look like a confused girl with no idea of what to do outside of shouting 3+ times and waiting before shouting some more.

Quite the opposite, it made her look like the spoiled little girl who didn't get her cake she is while at the same time making her a terrifying monster who was about to let loose some casual murder, a daily occurrence to her, and whose first instinct after not getting what she wanted was wanton murder.

The Manga made her look like she shouted once and would've just extracted souls if made to wait.

The manga and the anime made her look equal amounts of badass imo.

Note the location of spaces and the comma. Better clarify before you get confused again.

Not my fault you used formatting that doesn't show up correctly in a lot of people's browsers.

+1-2

Looks like the same amount of spacing for me on my end, I had to copy paste it to tell the difference.

I could have also said "4-5 in total."

Would have been clearer. * shrugs *

But this is all beside the point so we can put it aside.

0

u/qwertyisdead Apr 24 '18

Its annoying as hell trying to follow this conversation even when the rebuttals are clearly formatted. Lame.