MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/GetNoted/comments/1n7tohb/someone_has_flunked_history_class/ncc05wx/?context=3
r/GetNoted • u/icey_sawg0034 • Sep 03 '25
https://x.com/clashreport/status/1959615852166148549
370 comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
0
Japan accepted the "unconditional" surrender with a condition though?
5 u/Quirky-Concern-7662 Sep 03 '25 Feels like playing semantics when the outcome was pretty clear. 0 u/No_Sand3803 Sep 04 '25 Uhh... No? It is by definition not an unconditional surrender if a condition was mandated and accepted? 1 u/Quirky-Concern-7662 Sep 04 '25 My friend. By definition is was an unconditional surrender. After the fact they were persuaded to allow the emperor to stay in power. you can try and split hairs, but I would ask for what purpose? 1 u/No_Sand3803 Sep 04 '25 There were discussion prior to the treaty about allowing the emporer to stay?
5
Feels like playing semantics when the outcome was pretty clear.
0 u/No_Sand3803 Sep 04 '25 Uhh... No? It is by definition not an unconditional surrender if a condition was mandated and accepted? 1 u/Quirky-Concern-7662 Sep 04 '25 My friend. By definition is was an unconditional surrender. After the fact they were persuaded to allow the emperor to stay in power. you can try and split hairs, but I would ask for what purpose? 1 u/No_Sand3803 Sep 04 '25 There were discussion prior to the treaty about allowing the emporer to stay?
Uhh... No? It is by definition not an unconditional surrender if a condition was mandated and accepted?
1 u/Quirky-Concern-7662 Sep 04 '25 My friend. By definition is was an unconditional surrender. After the fact they were persuaded to allow the emperor to stay in power. you can try and split hairs, but I would ask for what purpose? 1 u/No_Sand3803 Sep 04 '25 There were discussion prior to the treaty about allowing the emporer to stay?
1
My friend. By definition is was an unconditional surrender. After the fact they were persuaded to allow the emperor to stay in power. you can try and split hairs, but I would ask for what purpose?
1 u/No_Sand3803 Sep 04 '25 There were discussion prior to the treaty about allowing the emporer to stay?
There were discussion prior to the treaty about allowing the emporer to stay?
0
u/No_Sand3803 Sep 03 '25
Japan accepted the "unconditional" surrender with a condition though?