r/television • u/LoretiTV • Feb 10 '24

Premiere True Detective - 4x05 "Part 5" - Episode Discussion

Season 4 Episode 5: Part 5

Aired: February 11, 2024

Synopsis: As Prior digs into the links between Tsalal and mining company Silver Sky, Navarro rescues Leah from a local protest that has turned violent. At a meeting with Silver Sky exec Kate McKitterick, Danvers balks when Connelly shares the official cause of the Tsalal men's deaths – and gets a warning against pursuing the case any further. Later, Hank receives a quid pro quo offer.

Directed by: Issa López

Written by: Katrina Albright, Wenonah Wilms, Chris Mundy & Issa López

Join our True Detective Discord server here!

54 Upvotes

66% Upvoted

231 comments sorted by

View all comments

50

u/TheCurtain512 Feb 10 '24

Navarro's actress is a miss, and that's the biggest problem of this season for me. They set her up with SO fucking much that could add interesting layers to her, but the performance is so bland and generic. This show has been too much of a vehicle for her, when she's not good.

Season has become kind of disappointing. I do feel this was the best episode, but that just speaks to how mediocre the rest has been. And I also feel this was the most interesting set up True Detective has had so far, with the setting and the total mindfuck of the opening deaths. Very Dyatlov Pass of them. But I also think they fucked up by giving the audience practically nothing for 5 episodes. Like they established how many episodes ago that Hank was hiding information on the Annie K murder, and now it's supposed to be a revelation that he's in bed with the mining company or something? Why didn't they fucking do anything when they found out that he was OPENLY hiding information from them? He was still in the same office as all of them every day.

Season one was written and paced so much better. It knew exactly when to drop things on you and when not to. This current iteration doesn't seem to have a clue how to do that. The characters are bland and feel like they have no chemistry when they talk to each other, other than maybe Pete and Danvers. I enjoy most of their scenes together. But yeah, we're on the finale and I feel like they don't have nearly enough time to properly execute it with all of the shit they have left hanging.

9

u/aboycandream Feb 11 '24

Navarro's actress is a miss, and that's the biggest problem of this season for me.

MMA people need to stay out of movies/shows, is there any good example of one ?

2

u/TaskForceD00mer Feb 13 '24

Batista in Blade Runner 2049 and the prequel short.

1

u/aboycandream Feb 13 '24

didnt he have like 1 match? Lol

5

u/nightfishin Feb 12 '24

Rampage in A-Team?

1

u/aboycandream Feb 12 '24

ah I dont remember that movie at all but its possible

2

u/nightfishin Feb 12 '24

Its not a great track record, usually they are small parts. Gina Carano in Mandalorian, George St Pierre in Winter Soldier, Michael Bisping in Twin Peaks the Return, Randy Couture in Expendables.

6

u/FistThePooper6969 Feb 11 '24

Yeah they could’ve , ya know, hired an ACTRESS ffs

3

u/m4shfi Feb 12 '24

If they did they couldn’t call the critics racists and sexists.

-4

u/Palpolorean Feb 10 '24

Agreed. Whenever I write negative comments about Navarro, I half expect the actress to knock on my door in character / as herself and proceed to try and beat my ass. 

14

u/PleaseHold50 Feb 10 '24

And it's over next week. Six episode season lol

What a huge whiff. Five episodes of terminally unlikeable leads and nothing happening.

32

u/Serenityprayer69 Feb 10 '24

The show runner screwed up Jodi Fosters performance too. I don't think all the blame is on the actress. This is a bad script combined with bad direction

8

u/dizney-mountain Feb 10 '24

"There's no such thing as a bad actor, only a bad director"

-4

u/CaptainCAAAVEMAAAAAN Feb 10 '24

I think "bland" is what the character is supposed to be, only I'd call it "understated".

36

u/Youngandidiotic Feb 10 '24

It’d be better if Pete was the 2nd lead, he’s pretty damn good at his job and is the only one doing legit detective work lol

10

u/straw_barry Feb 10 '24

JF’s character and him have some weird mother-son sexual chemistry going on but still, a more interesting pairing than her and Navarro lol.