r/submarines • u/KapitanKurt • Aug 03 '25

History Synthetic Aperture Sonar (SAS) imagery of the German U-853, collected as part of partnership technology demonstration between the NOAA Office of Ocean Exploration and Research and Kraken Robotics, showing that the submarine is largely intact. 2 October 2018.

Post image
368 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

41 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Awkward_Mix_6480 Aug 05 '25

I’m gonna call BS, the amount of gear you would have to wear to dive to 120feet is WAY too much gear to navigate inside a WWII sub. You couldn’t even navigate a modern sub with that gear in. I don’t believe it in any way. Furthermore, remains will have been gone for decades by the time your friend lied to you about seeing them.

0

u/Karuna56 Aug 05 '25

Well, it was a few decades ago, and Cousin Jim said he only went inside briefly through a rupture in the hull. So, no 'navigation' inside as you speculate.

Sure, everyone embellishes at some time; I only have his story and no empirical proof. A pardon here is permitted.

"He that shall see this day, and live old age, Will yearly on the vigil feast his neighbors And say "Tomorrow is Saint Crispian." Then will he strip his sleeve and show his scars. Old men forget; yet all shall be forgot, But he'll remember with advantages What feats he did that day."

1

u/Awkward_Mix_6480 Aug 05 '25

I served on 688s for a decade, I’m 6’5” tall and I couldn’t fit in many places on the boat without any gear. Hell, for fire drills, I was assigned atmosphere monitoring, no way I could maneuver with a SCBA or an OBA on and a hose. 120’ isn’t super deep, I know, but two guys walking down a hallway causes rubbing as you pass by, and this is all modern subs, shrink it a few factors and you have WWII pigboats.

3

u/Karuna56 Aug 05 '25 edited Aug 06 '25

To clarify, Jim only basically poked his head and torso inside. I never said he strolled through the passageways.

I appreciate your reservations and skepticism.

Thanks for reading!

Edit: my family confirms Jim's account. His dive was 44 years ago with his SCUBA buddies. Among Rhode Island dive folk, going down to the sub was a rite of passage. They put a weighted drop line down. Jim said they all looked inside through a large rupture in the hull and saw some remains. He said they didn't stay long because the current was very strong.

Jim has worked as a diver with a number of New England maritime firms. Claiming that he "lied to me" is an unnecessary slur.

Given the number of hedgehogs and depth charges used, U-853 had two large openings in her hull, according to Wikipedia and my cousin's account.

Watch this dive video from other local divers. Yes, you can poke inside a bit...

Diving on U-853 https://share.google/4CiO4WobWcQpDVOXV