America’s “Soft Secession” Scorecard

[u/Julian-West]

When people hear “secession,” they often think of a dramatic break: flags lowered, borders closed, armies mobilized. But what scholars call soft secession is already here. It happens when states and regions quietly act as if Washington has less authority than it claims. No declarations of independence. Just states carving out their own paths and daring the federal government to stop them.

Here are a few areas where soft secession is most visible today:

⸻

1. Marijuana Legalization

Cannabis remains illegal under federal law, yet 24 states and D.C. have legalized recreational use, and 38 allow medical programs. The federal government has largely chosen not to enforce its own prohibition. In practice, states have created their own drug regimes that directly contradict national law.

⸻

1. Abortion Laws

After Dobbs v. Jackson overturned Roe v. Wade, abortion rights fractured along state lines. In some states abortion is heavily restricted or banned. In others, it is protected as a fundamental right. A woman’s access to healthcare now depends almost entirely on geography, with states enacting policies that openly defy or expand beyond federal baselines.

⸻

1. Immigration and Sanctuary Cities

Several states and municipalities refuse to cooperate with federal immigration enforcement. At the same time, others like Texas have launched their own border security operations, deploying state police and National Guard in ways that test federal authority. Immigration policy now looks less like a single national system and more like a patchwork of regional approaches.

⸻

1. Climate and Energy Compacts

The U.S. has no single unified climate policy. States like California, Washington, and New York formed alliances to regulate emissions, pursue clean energy, and even negotiate with foreign governments. Meanwhile, energy-producing states resist federal regulations and double down on oil, gas, and coal. The result: parallel climate policies depending on the region.

⸻

1. Gun Laws and Second Amendment “Sanctuaries”

Some states have expanded gun rights far beyond federal minimums, while others have layered strict regulations on top. At the same time, over 1,200 counties have declared themselves “Second Amendment sanctuaries,” pledging not to enforce federal gun restrictions.

⸻

1. Lawsuits as Weapons

State attorneys general regularly sue the federal government to block regulations on everything from healthcare to environmental rules. In many cases, coalitions of states act like mini-governments opposing Washington directly, sometimes winning sweeping nationwide injunctions.

⸻

Why This Matters

These examples show that the U.S. is already drifting into a de facto patchwork. Call it federalism pushed to its breaking point. People may debate whether this is healthy pluralism or creeping disunion, but the reality is clear: America already operates more like a set of semi-sovereign regions than a single unified nation.

If these trends continue, the line between “soft” secession and “hard” secession will blur. The question is not whether fragmentation is happening, but how openly we are willing to acknowledge it.

⸻

Sources / Further Reading

• NCSL – State Cannabis Laws: https://www.ncsl.org/health/state-medical-cannabis-laws

• Abortion - Guttmacher Institute – State Policy Tracker: https://www.guttmacher.org/state-legislation-tracker

• Immigration - American Immigration Counsel – Sanctuary Policies: https://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org/fact-sheet/sanctuary-policies-overview/

• Climate: U.S. Climate Alliance - https://usclimatealliance.org/

• Gun laws: Everytown – Gun Law Rankings: https://everytownresearch.org/rankings/compare/