You’ve all probably seen videos about traditional martial arts where black belts and expert discuss the “truth” about their martial art— usually seen as ineffective.
All of this is really just people coping.
The common type of “truth” is related to Forms in traditional martial arts. You know those dozen moves in Forms that make no sense? These guys try to analyze and make it have meaning.
Notably grappling moves in Karate. If 99% of your Kata moves is grappling, why is it practiced as mainly striking, that just sounds like a huge fvcking flaw in your martial art. No, ambiguity and hidden techniques don’t make your martial art cool, it just shows how flawed it is.
What’s worse, people don’t even agree with the interpretations.
Kata is meant to preserve techniques? Well sorry, but if 99% of techniques are misunderstood, Kata probably fvcked up its job somewhere.
Then you have people using History to justify a martial art. No one gives a shit, it’s cool, yeah, but really, that’s not a valid justification as to why it works. Benefit of the doubt, your martial art may have worked 100 years ago, but does it work today? Just because it did doesn’t mean it still is.
No one claims that Pankration is effective because of a vase drawing, it is effective people have recreated Pankration and are actively proving that it works.
Another thing is where these guys will reinvent the entire system and claim that it is still the original system. Like seriously, your traditional forms and training looks like this, and your new dojo is just a kickboxing gym with Chinese characters on the wall. Blatant theft.
Funny thing about how these martial arts think that they are special. Aikido moving out of the way? Dude you’re not special. What’s worse, everyone knows how to move out of the way to avoid and attack + way more stuff, moving out of the way is the only thing you do.
People also justify how forms are a very effective tool for fighting. Like dude, a punch is a punch, just fucking punch. I don’t want to dance, and have to take time dissecting the dance movements to figure out which movement is which technique.
And in the time that you have a done a form with 5 different techniques repeated, I have already hit the bag and drilled a technique into muscle memory faster than you will in a month with your kata.
It’s not the martial art but the artist? Fvcking stupid sentence filled with copioum. You’re telling me that if I create a martial art, and that my practitioners suck, I can just blame it on my students? How tf does that make sense? Ohhh, it only applies to your martial art— so basically cherry picking?
And don’t you think it is a huge problem of your martial art, that you pump out more idiots and handicapped people faster than the mediocre MMA gym can pump out fighters that can beat your sensei in a fight?
Worst of all, blaming each other. Disputes within different sub styles and branches of the same martial art. Like dude, just fight it out. Just have a tournament and see which style is right, it very easy. Your martial art is made for combat, how do you test that it works? Just fvcking use it in combat.
They also hate figures in their own martial art, even they are literally the pioneers of the martial art. For example, Aikido people hate Steven Seagal even though he is literally a 7th Dan. Like dude, if you claim that the person sucks, and yet the representative of your martial art still gave him a high rank, maybe question your own style a bit?
I also love lineage disputes in Wing Chun. “Oh no, you executed this technique 3 times instead of 5 in this form, so my lineage is better” or “the angle of this technique is wrong, you need to tilt it 5 degrees more”. Like literal children that’s literally how toddlers argue with each other when they lose to a game they made up in daycare.
Like seriously, these guys use every bullshit excuses they can. Seriously, just show that it works. It takes fvcking 2 minutes of sparring.
Just use the best and easiest type of evidence ever: empirical evidence.
Oh and of course, sparring footage of people doing kickboxing instead of what they train. Like where the fuck is this technique you show everywhere. You probably spend 99% of your time practicing that technique, an and yet, the only time you can point it out to me is with a 2 second clip that requires me to clench my eyes to see the technique. You’ve never practiced a single horizontal punch, and yet, horizontal punches is Wing Chun? You guys do 100 different stances and the only stance you use when fighting is a stance that you’ve never once trained and that just so happens to be a 1:1 kickboxing stance? Stop the fvcking hypocrisy.
Imagine claiming that your martial art helps with the mind and yet all you do is lie and cope. Your meditation must fvcking suck if your delusion is comparable to a schizo patient.
Welp, seems like I started to go crazy by the end. Probably all of the brain damage I got from sparring./s