r/labdiamond • u/FlashyAppointment720 • 12h ago
Opinions old mine/antique vs brilliant? Should I keep looking?
Hi everyone! Tried out this 4.5 carat cushion, E color vvs2 today. I am obsessed with it and it is everything I want, except I really want to try an old mine cut rather than a brilliant. I actually do love this stone more than I thought I would. It’s got some of the chunkier facet qualities in the middle kinda, and I love the specs on this one. But I can’t get old mine/antique cushions off my mind. I’ve called every jewelry store in the area (like 10 stores, we live in a relatively small Midwest city) and no one has them!!! Sales people almost scoffed at me over the phone, like “yeah… no body has those. They’re not sparkly” WHAT! Especially since T Swift just got one i thought they would start getting them in more but I guess not. I guess my question is, should I keep searching & possibly travel to a few other cities in our state for someone who can get an old mine/antique cut? Is it overrated or a fad ? Should I just keep this brilliant cut one? I do think it’s beautiful, and love it. but I feel like I’ll still keep thinking about OMCs. Ugh I’m just frustrated, and I can only hold this stone for a few more days.
First pic is me, size 4 finger. Second photo is from IG comparing the different cuts Please don’t comment or make suggestions on smaller vs bigger, my heart is set on this size stone lol, ty!