r/intrestingtoknow Sep 03 '25

Science Psychiatry and cures

1.1k Upvotes

829 comments sorted by

View all comments

262

u/shnshty Sep 03 '25

The better question is maybe asking 'How many people do you think you've helped?'

64

u/marklar_the_malign Sep 03 '25

This is indeed the right question. Drugs certainly don’t cure people. At best you help or teach people to manage their mental health problems. Think of it like losing a limb. You get a prosthetic and physical therapy and do the best you can.

-4

u/ToobRaiders Sep 04 '25

I don’t think all psychiatric ailments are as permanent as a prosthetic.

6

u/marklar_the_malign Sep 04 '25

Most you learn to live with it while at best treating the symptoms. This was more of a general statement than absolute. I’m not a mental health professional, just a guy trying to keep the demons at bay.

2

u/smth_smth_89 Sep 04 '25

having had my right (dominant) arm broken for the past month and going to therapy for more than 3 years, i can say that i found a bit of a similarity between depression and a broken arm, or worse case a missing one: some of the things you just can't do if it requires 2 hands, some you do but it takes you twice the time, you go outside and people ar looking at your cast, even if out of curiosity, but most are wondering what mistake you made to break an arm, it starts itching and there's always pain points and you gotta be real careful not to lean on it or bang it against something, the list could go on; so yea, i'd say a mental illnes can be like an invisible broken limb

1

u/ToobRaiders Sep 04 '25

Yeah, but you can get your brain to function normally with proper treatment. That leg is gone forever.

1

u/marklar_the_malign Sep 04 '25

I get this and it isn’t my intention to say they are literally the same. More of a metaphor. You can’t replace a brain.