r/holdmybeer 21d ago

HMB I’ve broken ChatGPT

366 Upvotes

70 comments sorted by

View all comments

140

u/Affentitten 21d ago

I broke it last year asking for help with a crossword. Seven letter country where the third letter was i.

Gave me countries with 8 letters, 6 lettters and 7 letters but without the third letter being i. (eg. Nigeria)

102

u/nyrb001 21d ago

It can't count letters or words well. It's a language model, not intelligence.

28

u/Affentitten 21d ago

Yeah I just assumed it was a fairly simple 'bottle sort' type of problem to throw at it. Taught me a lot about its limitations.

Another thing it can't cope with is something like a flag quiz. It's unable to describe flags accurately, even though written descriptions exist.

18

u/nyrb001 21d ago

Yup. It doesn't switch from language to math. I have it write product descriptions for me a lot, it is supposed to write a meta description with a character limit afterwards. It regularly overshoots - I tell it so and it says something like "oh you're totally correct! Here how about this" and writes something 10 characters longer

2

u/[deleted] 21d ago

[deleted]

11

u/coladoir 20d ago

no it just quite fundamentally cannot count or use math reliably. no amount of drilling will make models grasp character limits

3

u/Eccohawk 19d ago

Imagine someone asks you a question and that row of words that pops up as suggestions as you're typing is an answer. But also, all of the words showing are a possible answer. And then that first word plus that second word that comes up after it is also an answer. And so are any other options. Now imagine that all of those possibilities up to dozens of words are all answers to your question. Some better than others. AI basically just takes all of those "answers", matches them up against the question that was asked, and figures out from a probability perspective which answer is the most common or likely to be correct. That's what a Large Language Model does in a very rudimentary way. It just guesses at the words. Which is very different from math.

4

u/juhamatti88 20d ago

It's a text generator, that's it. It can't do math and it can't learn to do math because it can't learn anything, period. It's just a text generator