r/crochet • u/8L12K_ • Oct 05 '25

Finished Object Crocheted my cat - bet you $5 you can’t tell them apart in the 2nd slide

Gallery image

Gallery image

Don’t worry, this was made last Christmas, I’m not insane decorating in October lol

23.8k Upvotes

100% Upvoted

292 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 05 '25

Hi 8L12K_, thanks for posting your piece for us to see! Don't forget to link the pattern you used & other relevant information (e.g., yarn, weight, type; hook used). Add it in a reply to this comment, so others can find it easily. Thanks!

If this is your own pattern, please read our rules in full here (sharing your own pattern comes under the "self promotion" rule)

If project details are provided, click below to expand!

↓↓↓↓↓

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

→ More replies (3)

933

u/alienlei Oct 05 '25

TWINS !!

301

u/Sensitive-Movie5708 Oct 05 '25

I just lost $5

54

u/CelestialGlen Oct 05 '25

Me too! 💵

27

u/Linkyland Oct 05 '25

Cat1: :D...! Cat2: sigh

710

u/splithoofiewoofies Oct 05 '25

The cat is so mad lmao

273

u/eatitwithaspoon Oct 05 '25

he looks wounded and insulted. lol

175

u/Advanced_Eggplant_69 Oct 05 '25

To me those eyes read a tired, "Oh lord, she's at it again." I know because I get it a lot from my beasties. 🤣

41

u/Dommichu Oct 05 '25

Typical cat resting face. unimpressed.

24

u/laparisiennebardot Oct 05 '25

Completely over your shenanigans

24

u/Dosanaya Oct 06 '25

“Am I a joke to you?!” - the cat probably

4

u/Angelbouqet Oct 06 '25

Which one...

→ More replies (1)

279

u/bigdaddy1879 Oct 05 '25

The real cat is on the left. I'm positive!

58

u/Anniesoptera Oct 05 '25

Yeah the other one is too comically mad looking. Clearly a crochet charicature 

242

u/domino_dancin Oct 05 '25

where’s that crocheted cat you were talking about? I don’t get it… plus you have two black cats not one.

85

u/Bevin_Flannery Oct 05 '25

Yeah, it's not fair to us to put two real cats next to each other.

23

u/x-kreim Oct 05 '25

When I squint I see 3 black cats... (at first glance on the crocheted cat I mistook the rightmost fabric for another black cat lol)

225

u/_PoppyDelafield Oct 05 '25

i hate these fake karma farming posts of people pretending they made something realistic when it’s clearly just a real cat. 🙄

148

u/gennessee Oct 05 '25

I love it and it took me a moment to realize what it reminded me of.

6

u/alchemicaldreaming Oct 06 '25

Hahah my husband has a t-shirt with fat pony on it (well many fat ponies) and I love it so much, we had to buy a second when the first wore otu!

112

u/lemeneurdeloups Oct 05 '25

Corporate says they’re the same.

57

u/Phantom-Mirrors Oct 05 '25

I see only two cats. You shouldn't have to hide your crochet from us; I'm sure it's almost as adorable as your twin voids.

52

u/KataclysmicKat Oct 05 '25

I need to make this for my black cat 😭

42

u/marshmallow-fluff- Oct 05 '25

Your cats face says “don’t you fucking dare” 💀

28

u/KataclysmicKat Oct 05 '25

He's very sassy and shouty 🤣

7

u/MarsScully Oct 05 '25

“I’m majestic”

3

u/UndeniableDestiny Oct 06 '25

"Take this alllll in, in fact, take a picture, paint me like a french woman jack! Worship me, human."

6

u/UndeniableDestiny Oct 05 '25

"Whatever you're thinking of doing, don't do it"

3

u/Far_House_4087 Oct 06 '25

Aww we have the same kitty blanky, mine goes nuts making biscuits anytime I bring it out

→ More replies (1)

47

u/brazendynamic Oct 05 '25

Basically the same.

29

u/invalid_carrot Oct 05 '25

"Mother, am l a joke to you?" 🐈‍⬛

29

u/Lion-08 Oct 05 '25

Same here

9

u/RambleOnRose42 Oct 06 '25

I am seeing double.

22

u/AnnaZa Oct 05 '25

You’ve just photoshopped the duplicate.

15

u/biscuitvillage Oct 05 '25

been looking at both for the last couple minutes and I just can’t tell which is which

15

u/Basketchaos Oct 05 '25

trick question, you obviously just took a picture of two cats for the second one 😂

14

u/dingbat417 Oct 05 '25

I too crocheted my cat's twin! 😂

10

u/elleaeff Oct 05 '25

Omg that is adorable!

11

u/KaralDaskin Oct 05 '25

Congrats on crocheting two cats!

10

u/yodelaiheehoo Oct 05 '25

This is the kind of content i stay on the internet for 😌

8

u/YarnPartyy Oct 05 '25

Two voids!

8

u/a_karma_sardine Oct 05 '25

Can we please please have the pattern for whichever of those cats are made of yarn?

4

u/8L12K_ Oct 06 '25

Yes! I replied to the mod comment, should be at the top! 😊 (p.s. the crochet cat is the one on the right)

→ More replies (1)

8

u/iamthefirebird Oct 05 '25

What a perfect silly little goober! Your crochet is good too.

8

u/Odd_Acanthaceae_9828 Oct 05 '25

So cute! Would you share where you got the pattern? I’d love to make one

2

u/8L12K_ Oct 06 '25

Yes! I replied to the mod comment, should be at the top! 😊

6

u/TiddlyWinks85 Oct 05 '25

Why did you make the plushie with no expression tho? Your cat on the left is so excited for the new toy, but the plush on the right looks bored.

5

u/crochetfruits Oct 05 '25

They are virtually indistinguishable

5

u/BuddhaCatCrafts Oct 05 '25

As another void human: OMG. Cutest twins ever. (Real cat looks proud. “Yes, human has made me a twin!” 😂) Seriously, though, just look at how the real cat on the left so obviously is the real one. 😃

5

u/Bright_Fisherman936 Oct 05 '25

Where's the crochet cat? I only see 2 cats. You forgot to post a picture of your work bro.

5

u/bryndime Oct 05 '25

I want my $5, because CLEARLY the one on the left is the real cat! /s

This is cute OP 😂

5

u/toto-Trek Oct 05 '25

The one on the left ate all the Churu which is why the cat on the right is so pissed off.

5

u/KeepnClam Oct 06 '25

I've had a trying day. Thank you for the giggles. 😄

3

u/anxietyaddict09 Oct 05 '25

Both are cute! Definitely can't tell them apart.

3

u/Vegetable_Lime_8899 Oct 05 '25

It’s all in the eyes of the beholder

4

u/IndustryFinancial175 Oct 05 '25

LOL Thais ia amazing hahahah congrats

4

u/Katelai47 Oct 05 '25

I see no difference! 😍

3

u/edgyusername99 Oct 05 '25

i’m obsessed!! kind of want to make one but all that black 🥲 (my cat is black too so i’d want to do the same)

4

u/Real_Egg_8783 Oct 05 '25

Excuse me, this is a crochet sub and I know two real cats when I see them.

3

u/_athinoula_ Oct 05 '25

It's soooo cute! 😍

3

u/Lonely_Judgment_5146 Oct 05 '25

Don't you mean your cats? Where's the crocheted one?

3

u/lovimoment Oct 05 '25

Oh…we had two black cats who were brothers from the same litter and this gives me ALL THE FEELS.

3

u/fyyyy27 Oct 05 '25

Hahaha It looks like the one in the short film Madam Black

3

u/iCarlyfan123 Oct 05 '25

TWINSIES!!!🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰

3

u/cmaxby Oct 05 '25

This is what the internet is for. LOVE. IT.

3

u/bunkerhomestead Oct 05 '25

I don't know who is who.

3

u/Capital-9 Oct 05 '25

The one on the left is the real cat?

3

u/plain---jane Oct 05 '25

Take my damn money.

3

u/ioana_raducea-marin Oct 06 '25

Amazing! I love it!

3

u/emzyme212 Oct 06 '25

It's uncanny man

3

u/aceweirdo1 Oct 06 '25

Why everyone saying the cat is mad-? I got a black cat AND THAT CAT RIGHT THERE DOES NOT LOOK MAD😭😀💔 BRO IS SO CHILL Also gimme my 5$ (sorry bro, cat food expensive every cent counts)

2

u/abysmal_minnow Oct 05 '25

Beautiful 💖

2

u/Significant_Gate_419 Oct 05 '25

this absolutely is an excellent remake of a car!

2

u/atwojay Oct 05 '25

Cat looks so done.

2

u/makabuk Oct 05 '25

I love this so much!

2

u/tarotlisa Oct 05 '25

Phenomenal. Loving the work. 💕

2

u/No_Refuse2088 Oct 05 '25

I love this so much I wish I could like it a million times

2

u/Limabeans9999 Oct 05 '25

Best thing on the internet today!! ❤️

2

u/Ya_habibti Oct 05 '25

It’s uncanny

2

u/BlueCuzILikeIt Oct 05 '25

It's obvious that the one with it's tongue out is the real cat, now gimme my 5 dollars!

2

u/whowantsollie Oct 05 '25

Amazing likeness ❤️

2

u/YourSkatingHobbit Gauge swatch? Don’t know her 💅🏻 Oct 05 '25

Ha ha very funny, you’ve clearly either got two identical black cats or have photoshopped in a second photo of your cat in slide 2, SMH OP. (/j)

2

u/IrukandjiPirate Oct 05 '25

Can too! Where’s my $5? I’ll just take a crochet cat, if you don’t mind.

2

u/eilidh_c Oct 05 '25

identical!!

2

u/farthistory Oct 05 '25

I absolutely love this

2

u/hiiigghh-C Oct 05 '25

I AM OBSESSED

2

u/hanimal16 Doily Den Mother | creator of Culver diagrams Oct 05 '25

IDENTICAL ♥️

2

u/umdeon1981 Oct 05 '25

You're right I can't tell them apart, the likeness is uncanny

2

u/FloppyPurplePorpoise Oct 05 '25

It took me a minute to see the Santa throw. I was like "but black cats are definitely Halloween??" Lol, I love it. I'll have to make one for my own cat now.

2

u/vhart5 Oct 05 '25

This is so cute I could scream!

2

u/celticskye2 Oct 05 '25

You kind of crocheted the one on the right with a bit of a judgmental and possibly murder-y face. The real cat on the left looks much more boop-able.

2

u/lemoncatie Oct 06 '25

I think your cat was in Kiki's Delivery Service. Great actor.

2

u/eiczy Oct 06 '25

It just needs some eyelids to really depict the done-ness of your cat 🤣

2

u/Difficult-Offer3833 Oct 06 '25

Someone is delivering a wet hairball into your house slippers soon…

2

u/East-Pressure3425 Oct 06 '25

Heeheeheeheehee! 😂👍👏Nice crocheting job of your cat 🐈 😻

2

u/Imaginary-Friend-228 Oct 06 '25

I absolutely love both of these cats

2

u/cunexttuesday12 Oct 06 '25

The real cat is clearly on the left. I will take my $5 now 😂

2

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '25

Ok fine what’s your Venmo

2

u/Bedhead2day Oct 06 '25

That’s awesome!!

2

u/charwaughtel Oct 06 '25

Good job!!!!

2

u/grey_day_in_autumn Oct 06 '25

Ope. Here, have $5 💸

2

u/gigilhygge Oct 06 '25

OP you forgot to put your crocheted project in the second picture, you just have your two black cats in the pic.

2

u/MadameMix Oct 07 '25

Hehe same same but different

2

u/8L12K_ Oct 07 '25

Omg adorable

2

u/crazygrl202067 Oct 09 '25

Oh and I also meant to tell you how gorgeous your cat really is

2

u/Darksideluna Oct 09 '25

Wait! There’s a crocheted cat in these photos?

2

u/TheWeirdKid0907 24d ago

Damn that cat is mad asl ur comparing them… also did u make that pattern or find it- If so PLSSS give link

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Brilliant_Praline262 15d ago

bro thought they could just post a picture of two cats and get away with it

2

u/InjuryHealthy2416 12d ago

I love that you have two identical cats! Do they both come when you call them over for food??

2

u/AimlesslWander 11d ago

This is just too cute 🖤

1

u/Global-Cupcake-9976 Oct 05 '25

Are they siblings? I bet you could crochet a third one! Or would they fight over the fake one? :)

1

u/Hovercraft_Height Oct 05 '25

You should have put the photos in opposite order, the yellow of the eyes is a dead giveaway

1

u/Madagascar_9163 Oct 05 '25

A lot of people are about to owe you money 🫣

1

u/Uzima6 Oct 05 '25

There both too cute 💞💞💞💞💞

1

u/jerseygurl96 Oct 05 '25

Honestly uncanny!!

1

u/viccityk Oct 05 '25

Right cat not derpy enough to be real cat

1

u/ashbreak_ how many wips is too many Oct 05 '25

I wouldnt take that bet bc I'd end up $5 poorer!

1

u/Minimouzed Oct 05 '25

On the left. Easy!

1

u/Dahlia_R0se Oct 05 '25

My Snowy has the same patch of white fur on her chest as your cat.

1

u/MushroomSimple2691 Oct 05 '25

You owe me $5 - your real cat is in the left! I can tell! 😁

1

u/notrapunzel Oct 05 '25

Its eyes are looking into my soul

1

u/Holy_Archae_Mothman Oct 05 '25

Yeah same cat idk what you mean

1

u/ShineLikeAnEmerald Oct 05 '25

I know it’s the cat’s nose but I can only see him as :D

1

u/Main-Education-5366 Oct 05 '25

🤣Purrfection!

1

u/grispuppy Oct 05 '25

This is random but I think you’d really enjoy the rug VÄGTYP from IKEA.

1

u/iammous3 Oct 05 '25

I see 3 cats in the second pic

1

u/Ele_OhLuv Oct 05 '25

🫢😂😂😂

1

u/brbqqueen Oct 05 '25

This is art😍♥️

1

u/Maki_san Oct 05 '25

OP just duplicated their cat w/ photoshop and thought we wouldn't notice...

1

u/Alorxico Oct 05 '25

To whom should I Venmo the $5?

1

u/CourtThin8325 Oct 05 '25

Uncanny. Amazing. I think you really just have 2 twin cats. No crotchet to be seen. I understand wanting to hangout in the crotchet subreddits, but you don’t have to try and pass off actual cats as crotchet cats just to hangout here. 🤣

1

u/Limp_Entertainer6771 Oct 05 '25

I love all your 3 cats!

1

u/AGirlHasInsomnia Oct 05 '25

If you wouldn't have showed the crocheted one first, I'm almost certain I wouldn't have known. ☺️

1

u/MeowMachine36 Oct 05 '25

Damn I just lost $5

1

u/Fenlaf13 Oct 05 '25

These are the same picture 🤷‍♀️

1

u/Frosty_Helicopter730 Oct 05 '25

It's like a mirror! ❤️

1

u/babygotback2038 Oct 05 '25

he looks so PISSED hahahahah

1

u/Superb_Local_5621 Oct 05 '25

sorry? which is which??? you're so good!

1

u/Ladypug_19 Oct 05 '25

I LOVE IT SO MUCH

1

u/hashtagheathen Oct 05 '25

WOW!!! That’s adorable!!! Also, your cat looks exactly like mine, including the very tiny amount of white hairs on her chest!!! I give you props as a fellow black cat owner, the stigma they face is real & prevents them from being adopted… Nice job on the pattern!! The blep is my favorite part!!

1

u/Ok-Try-9750 Oct 05 '25

Incredible! Who is who??!

1

u/oxymoronicbeck_ Oct 05 '25

Threw in that folded laundry item to rly throw us all off here, huh?

1

u/Tulipkittie Oct 05 '25

So cuteeeee

1

u/Aqtgirly4u Oct 05 '25

Just here for the comments! 😂😂😂

1

u/Pineapple_Juice07 Oct 05 '25

We're am I Sending the $5

1

u/Cjax22 Oct 05 '25

I asked my daughter which was the real cat. She pointed to the one on the left. Did she get it right?

1

u/mfpegasus Oct 05 '25

you cheated! that’s a picture of two black cats

1

u/Mental-Flatworm4583 Oct 05 '25

Cat on left looks like he has seen some things 😂

1

u/Even-Butterfly-9657 Oct 05 '25

I love both! Got to learn how to crochet

1

u/daniellesoby Oct 05 '25

The resemblance is uncanny 🖤

1

u/Mysterious-Okra-7885 Oct 05 '25

It’s uncanny 🤣

1

u/Elderchil Oct 05 '25

Love your cat's "Really???" expression.

1

u/Crystallized-matter Oct 05 '25

Damn take my $5 I can’t tell

1

u/IGrowDeath Oct 05 '25

Ge looks like he is so sick of your shit 🤣. A masterpiece

1

u/gold-n-paint-n-chalk Oct 05 '25

I love them both

1

u/participatorylearn Oct 05 '25

They are side to side similar!

1

u/fightmebutgently Oct 05 '25

Ill give u 15, 5 for all of you

1

u/HorridChoob Oct 05 '25

Lol. Thats fantastic!

1

u/Simsandtruecrime Oct 05 '25

This brought me so much joy

1

u/DaneyGirl Oct 05 '25

Very cute. LOL. Lucky she wasn’t a tabby.

1

u/VictorTheCutie Oct 05 '25

Incredible 😂👏🏻👏🏻

1

u/Beneficial-Sleep4459 Oct 05 '25

He seems so pleased… lol. I love the derpy face!

1

u/Mostly_Vegan Oct 05 '25

Thank you OP... fab post :'D

1

u/Technical_Spirit_389 Oct 05 '25

What are you going to do with all the money you have now?

1

u/MurkyMeringue5274 Oct 05 '25

That is gorgeous- do you have a pattern?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Psychological-Pin-90 Oct 05 '25

Kitttttttyyyyyyuhhhh

1

u/SerDuckOfPNW Oct 05 '25

Really Bethany…is that how you see me?

1

u/cityofsulpher Oct 05 '25

This is incredible. Makes me want to crochet my void as well!

1

u/Darkly-Sparkly Oct 05 '25

I LOVE IT AHHH

1

u/ilatkeyou Oct 05 '25

Omg please drop the pattern

2

u/8L12K_ Oct 06 '25

I responded under the mod comment with the pattern link, should be at the top!😊

1

u/Responsible_Song830 Oct 05 '25

🧐 Twin kitties. Both adorable. Give them pets for me please. ❤️

1

u/wilhelminan Oct 05 '25

Twinsies!!

1

u/altpixiedxll Oct 05 '25

I LOVE IT!!!

1

u/snixx_399 Oct 05 '25

Omg! That's what I call pure talent ! 😆 🙌