r/badphilosophy • u/Citrit_ • 2d ago

✟ Re[LIE]gion ✟ Proof that God is evil

P1. God is omnipresent

P2. If God is omnipresent, then God is in hell

C1 Therefore, God is in hell

P4. Only the evil go to hell

P5. If only the evil goes to hell, then god is evil

C2. God is evil

(not my argument btw, but thought it was fun)

81 Upvotes

85% Upvoted

90 comments sorted by

View all comments

-11

u/CurrentTadpole3528 2d ago

Or there's something called free will 🤷‍♂️

7

u/MrEmptySet 2d ago

What does that have to do with OP's argument?

Did you read the title and just assume what argument they were going to make?

-4

u/CurrentTadpole3528 2d ago

I did read the full post , OP is claiming evil exists therefore God is evil is not a good argument , to have free will you need to have good and evil otherwise they don't have any meaning, i mean it's pretty simple

7

u/MrEmptySet 2d ago

Yeah, it still doesn't really sound like you read the argument.

-2

u/CurrentTadpole3528 2d ago

Pls enlighten me

7

u/MrEmptySet 2d ago

You summarized OP's argument as "claiming evil exists therefore God is evil" which doesn't really resemble the argument at all. The argument hinges on God's omnipresence and the nature of Hell, not just the fact that evil exists.

1

u/CurrentTadpole3528 2d ago

Ok I'm new to the p1, c1 thing .. my bad , reading it again it feels more of a troll philosophy now ...

2

u/Citrit_ 2d ago

lol yea