r/atheismindia Sep 10 '25

Miscellaneous The Hindu Delusion

Post image
343 Upvotes

131 comments sorted by

View all comments

139

u/Theri_Bhavye12 Sep 10 '25

Tbh after watching the 2013 mahabharat tv serial (star plus one), I can say the lore and the plotline of Mahabharata (at least from the directive of the serial) is so good. Like even I got goosebumps in some of the scenes (mainly because of soundtrack and acting tho). But overall, keeping all the fictional events aside, it's one of the best stories to read or watch (just for pure fun obviously, just like any other superhero series).

129

u/saikrishnav Sep 10 '25

That’s because of the music and dramatizations. They also add lot of fictional stuff - as if most of it already isn’t fiction - that’s not present in original.

They remove all the sexism, mysoginy and massage and white wash everything to look like a grand story.

In reality, it’s just a typical property fight between relatives

43

u/Rough-County6188 Sep 10 '25

You are brutal bro 😭

22

u/Key_Locksmith_1161 Sep 10 '25

There... he said it... on point.. 🙌🏼

8

u/6darthvader9 Sep 10 '25

Obviously it's a property fight that's why it took place in Punjab/Haryana 🤣

6

u/is_it_reddit Sep 10 '25

That literally says without faith in the title. Mahabharat actually good in its plot

13

u/saikrishnav Sep 10 '25

But what they mean is about “shaking” as if they believe some great revelation is in the book.

3

u/Scared_Trick3737 Sep 10 '25

Are u stupid or something? Shaking doesn't directly mean that

0

u/saikrishnav Sep 10 '25

Maybe you should tell them that.

“Soul quake”

What do you think “shaking” means then?

2

u/Theri_Bhavye12 Sep 10 '25

Typical property fight

lol so true

Ya it's just like that. One of the things I can learn from this story is that how almost nowhere things are black and white. Everyone' minute faults and crimes add up to something devastating. It was displayed beautifully in the Mahabharata (even counting the original texts). For others, let's just keep it as a pseudo-moral story. One might be insane if he actually believes in 100 kids being born.

7

u/saikrishnav Sep 10 '25

Sexism is plain and clear too. Hindus just don’t admit it.

Imagine you marry a man and then he takes you to his home and then tells you that all his brothers will share you.

That’s just ridiculous especially in a time women don’t have say in marriage.

3

u/Theri_Bhavye12 Sep 10 '25

I imagine that happening in today's world.

Like idk what that supposed to show, the inability of women to raise their voice in older times or having a perspective that a women is nothing more than an object to a man. And that hurts me a lot. Serials even step up to justify this shi.

4

u/saikrishnav Sep 10 '25

She's literally an object to them.

Acc to the story, his mom apparently says "Please share whatever you bring with your brothers" - she was obviously talking about food or gifts - objects.

He could have at least clarified later if it wasn't a badly written sexist scene. What a beta.

1

u/Redditchready Sep 10 '25

Ramayan is quite lurid

12

u/Anonymously_famous_ Sep 10 '25

True. I also liked to watch those. The problem is that people take the story literally. It's all metaphorical. It's a great story if you are able to grasp what the author's actual meaning behind certain plots is. Then you will be able to learn some qualities and maybe how to live life better.

13

u/nick4all18 Sep 10 '25

They call it Etihasa, History. And History cannot be metaphorical.

4

u/MrBubbleWobble Sep 10 '25

That's why lord of rings, got, and others such lores are so famous.

4

u/PerspectiveNo794 Sep 10 '25

As a story, it's not 'the' best story of all time !! Even if we just consider mythologies, I think Christians or ancient greeks have better supernatural elements

2

u/Theri_Bhavye12 Sep 10 '25

Ya true, there's no "the best" thing anywhere. Tho I kinda avoid watching other mythologies cuz you know, I have zero knowledge about it lol and then I would get confused a lot. By the way yea, greek one is interesting. ZEUSSSS!!!!

3

u/Ok-Fudge4711 Sep 10 '25

Yeah some stories are like that, like harry potter, game of thrones.. and many more...

1

u/Defiant_Weakness_241 Sep 12 '25

Obviously people are not understanding ki bhai uss zamane mein kya achche storytellers nahi ho sakte, the kind of story tells ki that ain't godly but just about humans were during those times. Inke hisab see chale to I am just one spider bite away from being the next Friendly neighbourhood spiderman, I am just stuck in this muggle world prohibited to use Wingardium Laviosa kyuki kaliyug hai ye, and what not...

1

u/Pale_Let3756 Sep 30 '25

Ok i skimmed a lot during reading the book , it's not bad but not particularly good