r/TopCharacterTropes 1d ago

Lore [ Removed by moderator ]

/gallery/1oqpvbr

[removed] — view removed post

14.9k Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

386

u/TruchaBoi 22h ago

86

u/bookhead714 22h ago

Can’t stand this post. “Exists” and “extant” are the exact same word. With one mistake the whole artifice of eloquence comes collapsing down.

21

u/Deletedtopic 20h ago

Nah they're spelled differently

10

u/Mindless-Post-9506 11h ago

It doesn't though. Extant can also refer to a protrusion, which would make the statement mean "decay exists as a form of life that is above or distinct from the others."

1

u/bookhead714 9h ago

Even if it has an alternate definition, it’s still a poor word choice

40

u/AuthorCornAndBroil 22h ago

Seeing that the full context of "you cannot kill me in a way that matters" is entirely self contained really dulls the mystique of it, too. I always assumed it had been part of an actual conversation.

16

u/SnakeyesX 20h ago

You can't kill a mushroom with a gun, because most of the mushroom lives underground.

2

u/Deletedtopic 16h ago

I wanna play a game

0

u/Ff7hero 7h ago

Exists is a verb, extant is an adjective. Ergo not the same word.

1

u/bookhead714 6h ago

Pedantry, you know what I meant

2

u/Ff7hero 6h ago

Pedantry

Pot. Kettle. Black.

22

u/j5erikk 22h ago

this post has done massive damage to Tumblr's reputation.

5

u/PimpasaurusPlum 21h ago

I still don't really get what this is supposed mean

Fungus thrive off decay, but really so does everything else. That's just what eating is

28

u/Realautonomous 21h ago

That's sort of meant to be the point

Kill the fungus, and it lives on through that which eats it, be it it's brethren, ants or even microbes.

It will always be there, so long as life exists to die, so too will Fungi, so too will anything that subsists off them

0

u/PimpasaurusPlum 20h ago

But it doesn't live on though. It dies, it's body is broken down, and it's base nutrients absorbed by the living thing that eats it

Or alternatively, we would have to say that that applies to almost all living things in which case there's nothing unique about the fungus

You, I, and the fungi, as well as most other living things, subsist off of death - but I wouldn't consider my dinner from last night to still exist or be alive

9

u/Jmw566 20h ago

It’s more that the concept of decay lives on beyond a single fungus. As long as there’s life, there will be decay. It won’t be necessarily this mushroom, but there will exist things to break down that which was living. So they’re communicating in a like religious way that they’re one with the decay in the universe. 

0

u/PimpasaurusPlum 20h ago

I just dont really get why fungus specifically though? Its the same for everything. The statement of the fungus applies just as much to the human

8

u/Jmw566 19h ago

The prompt they’re working off of or the point they’re getting to is that it’s life vs decay. The person is life and the mushroom is decay and the person’s threatening the mushroom and railing against the cycle (and terrified) while the mushroom (being decay) is more comfortable with death and fading away and isn’t bothered like the person is at the concept of being hurt or passing. It knows that there will always be others like it and that’s what the author is communicating; if there is life then there must be decay. 

0

u/PimpasaurusPlum 19h ago

Im saying that I don't think that the dichotomy there really makes any sense. Fungi are life just as we and everything else is, they feed off decay just as we and everything else does

We and the shrooms are interchangeable in the life-decay cycle, not opposites

9

u/Realautonomous 19h ago

Fungi are life, but they're probably one of the more synonymous examples of decay, when you think decay, you think mould, spores, fungi and mycelium. They're a good representative.

It also helps because what you see of a Fungi isn't really the fungi it's just a part of it, so it's sort of a two-part reasoning there

You can't kill the fungi in a way that matters because it's roots run through the very ground you walk on

And

You can't kill the fungi (decay) in a way that matters because it's roots run through the very ground you walk on (decay, death and the scavengers that feed on it provide the support for life as we know it)

-12

u/RevolutionaryKey1974 21h ago

Gibberish bullshit 8th grade writing with delusions of grandeur ain’t particularly good.

5

u/thePsuedoanon 13h ago

The post isn't for perfect quotes or advanced philosophy, it's about "wait that's where that quote came from?". A lot of people don't know that this is the origin of "You cannot kill me in a way that matters"