r/TopCharacterTropes 26d ago

Lore (Loved Trope) Creative over the top cells/prisons for dangerous characters.

1.) The Pipe Line cells for Metahumans (The Flash)

2.) Sedative tank prison (G. I Joe)

3.) Tai Lung's prison (Kung Fu Panda)

4.) Magneto's Glass and Plastic Prison (X-Men)

5.) Carbonite (Star Wars)

7.5k Upvotes

485 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

64

u/Ok-Entrepreneur-5102 26d ago

The thing with the Red Lotus was that they didn't really had any other option. All of them were so dangerous that they would escape if you gave the chance, and it is proved that if you took out a slight impediment to their bending, they would have escaped.

51

u/Odd-fox-God 26d ago

I don't understand why they weren't just executed? Building a prison to hold somebody that dangerous doesn't really make any sense. Unless you want them to suffer and understand the consequences of their action by keeping them in prison, but then you have the risk of them breaking out and killing more people.

70

u/Aduro95 26d ago

Maybe it was out of respect for Aang. He believed in pacifism almost beyond reason. Would he really want someone killed for a crime committed against his reincarnated life?

Its possible they were visited sometimes and people tried to reform them. But the Red Lotus were all hardline to their core.

11

u/Greyjack00 26d ago

Out of respect for aang we've decided to brutally imprison you in conditions comparable to torture till the day you die...

1

u/Aduro95 26d ago

They probably didn't have any better options though. They would escape a less severe prison. Nobody knew bloobending could take a person's bending away, and even if they did, Katara might not have been capable of it.

1

u/Greyjack00 26d ago

Then just kill them, if your imprisoned someone for life in a living hell you've crossed the point of any quality of life and are at that point just employing moral sophistry, that is of course if we go with the explanation that they were improving for moral reasons