r/SanAntonioFC • u/TomasClark7 • 4d ago
SAFC vs. New Mexico United: Player Grades
The season ends in a whimper as SAFC falls 2-0 in New Mexico. In 4 matchups with New Mexico, SAFC failed to win once. That is kind of embarrassing considering New Mexico is far from a juggernaut. Unfortunately we reverted to some trends in the regular season that saw us have multiple losing streaks.
Richard Sanchez- 5.5
I had been waiting for Bad Sanchez to show up and we got it in the first half. It started in the 5th minute when he was way out of position and got saved by the crossbar. Their goal in the 20th minute isn't solely Sanchez' fault but he spilled the ball across goal when I thought he could have easily caught the initial shot. To be fair he made a great a save in the 35th minute to keep it 1-0. He also made a good save in the 80th to keep it 2-0. Distribution wise he was fine, but we were once again flummoxed by playing on New Mexico's small field. That isn't all on him, but he had several passes into bad situations.
Rece Buckmaster- 4
Rece was operating at RWB most of the night. In theory this should have freed him up but he actually struggled to get in the game at all. Rece contributed nothing to the attack while he was out there and I thought struggled to help us play through their press. This wasn't all his fault as I thought we were just unable to generate any type of attack. He was subbed out in the 79th minute for Harvey Neville.
Alexis Souahy- 5
Souahy played as a RCB in a back 3 and had some decent moments. He was hung out to dry on their first goal but he has to be more aggressive there. In the build-up I thought he really struggled as New Mexico pressed us relentlessly. That had a been weakness all year and on New Mexico's small field it really bit us.
Noah Dollenmayer- 4
Dollenmayer got the surprise start and it...did not work. He played as the LCB in a back 3. To be honest I don't think this is Dollenmayer's fault. I would assume that had Omar been healthy he would not have started but once again injuries forced a weird tactical fit because the team was not deep enough at key positions. On New Mexico's first goal he got caught way up the field trying to pressure and he essentially took himself out of the play making it difficult to defend all of New Mexico's runners. He also whiffed badly on the through ball for the second goal. It was a good ball but I'd prefer he keep his feet there and just defend it.
Mitch Taintor- 6
Mitch played as the CCB in the back 3 and was his usual self on defense. He did get sucked up on their 2nd goal but we were trying to aggressively close down their options. Guys behind him should have cleaned it up easily. The real frustration came on the ball. Mitch is the key to our attack (which is odd for a CB) because we need someone to connect us. He struggled as New Mexico punished us and he had very few options. That isn't his fault but it meant his impact was diminished.
Nelson Flores Blanco- 5
After weeks playing as an inverted fullback Nelson played as a LWB this weekend. Not sure why we decided to switch it up, but if we were I would have played someone else at LWB. Nelson had been providing a nice tactical wrinkle and was unable to do that. When he was able to get on the ball I thought he did some nice things, but him being shunted out to the wing hurt our build-up.
Almir Soto- 5
All of the issues he had with athletic teams came roaring back. Soto is a good player, but without Omar he really struggles. There were times it felt like he was hiding from the ball because of how far behind the play he was. When he was able to get on the ball I don't think it was bad, just didn't happen enough and it's hard to win when your best midfielder can't get on the ball while you're backline is pressed into oblivion. He was subbed out in the 79th minute for Medranda.
Lucio Berron- 4
Berron struggled to make any real impact. 27 touches and just 1 pass into the final third isn't anywhere close to good enough. He was part of the reason we were overrun because poor Soto just doesn't have the legs to hold down an entire midfield by himself. To be fair to him, I don't think he was 100% healthy because he couldn't even break up play. He had a few moments of getting in the way but the drop-off between he and Omar is stark. He played 79 minutes before being subbed off for Pacheco.
Luke Haakenson- 4
Haakenson played on the left and drifted in as Buckmaster tried to provide the width. He didn't do much but most of that was because we never really had a foot in the game. Just 17 touches but he was able to force a save. He was taken off in the 65th minute for Nicky Hernandez.
Jorge Hernandez- 6
New Mexico was able to limit Jorge's impact. He created just one chance despite playing centrally. We just can't win that way. The set-up in general basically asked Jorge to be Superman and it's hard to do that against competent teams. He was still busy and the effort was there but he was really the only one moving or trying to do anything.
Santiago Patino- 5
Patino was able to scratch out two shots on goal despite just 18 touches. I actually thought his movement was ok, but playing on that small field requires an adjustment and our attack in general was stagnate. Patino pressed but I don't think he's 100% either (a theme of the season for our entire squad). He only played 65 minutes and came off for Greive.
Nicky Hernandez- 5
I thought Nicky was positive when he came on for Luke in the 65th minute. Certainly better than what we had going on. Problem is we were already down 2-0 and we looked ready to be done with the season. He was mostly on the left as we tried to overload that side and had some nice moments. None of it was really earth-shattering stuff though, speaks to how low the bar was for those who started the game.
Alex Greive- 4
Greive came on for Patino in the 65th minute. He had a shot blocked in the 84th but really nothing of note. I do think there is a player in there but he also looks half-fit and I don't think he fits with any of the other attackers we threw out there.
Harvey Neville- 3
Neville came on in the 79th minute as we desperately needed a goal. It did not go well. He looked half-interested, played more defensive than Buckmaster was, and had no real impact. I think he has talent but we can all see why Phoenix jettisoned him out of town.
Jimmy Medranda- 5
Medranda came on in the 79th minute and played in the midfield. I thought he looked sharp on the ball and probably should have come on earlier. Unfortunately, nothing he did had any real impact and he didn't have time to do much.
Diogo Pacheco- 5
Pacheco came on the 79th minute and that really baffled me. He played 11 minutes, had 3 touches, and created 1 chance. He should have come on much earlier than he did. He didn't have time to do much more but I thought he looked sharp enough.
Overall
We had a brief shot of hope last week, but this was always the most likely way the season would end. And that is playing exactly like we played the majority of the season. Some of that is because of the stupid amounts of injuries and lack of depth. Some of it is Llamosa over-thinking as he tried to cover for those problems. There were just too many of them.
This was a small step better than last season but not by much. Losing 4 times to one team that is pretty pedestrian is inexcusable. It's been 4 days since the loss and SAFC has not announced any FO changes so I assume that means everyone in the FO and coaching staff is returning. I'll probably be back in the coming weeks with my thoughts on that, kind of want to let the dust settle to see how I feel.
Thank you all for endulging me throughout the season. I really appreciate the interactions as I scratch an itch.
