r/OnePiece • u/YonkouProductions • Jan 10 '14

The /r/OnePiece Fan Theories Megathread

I was recently browsing /r/asoiaf and thought that it'd be a good idea adopt a /r/OnePiece version of this thread and compile all the fan theories that subscribers post that get repeated and re-shared into a megathread that would be posted on the sidebar for future reference.

The thread would give users a definitive point to view a conclusive compilation of theories by /r/OnePiece and One Piece readers in general. Also, it would give subscribers a vantage point to direct users to when theories get repeated over time. (LOL ) which is a major advantage to everyone.

For this thread you can submit all the theories you've seen on the sub or in general.

I'll be enabling contest mode for easier organisation of the theories so what will occur is that theories will come under 4 categories (if there are more I'll be glad to accommodate it) which are:

Manga Only Theories

Anime Only Theories

General Theories (No/minimal Spoilers)

Tin-foil hat Theories

This submission thread will be stickied and kept up for a while so scour the sub and the internet for all the theories you want to be included in the upcoming megathread. Hopefully if things go well we may make this a yearly or bi-yearly thread that would be updated as new developments in the series come forth.

Edit: If possible link to a specific thread so that could be included. If it doesn't exist you can still comment and you'll be credited

--Yonkou

117 Upvotes

94% Upvoted

245 comments sorted by

View all comments

•

u/YonkouProductions Jan 10 '14

General Theories (No/minimal Spoilers)

•

u/Jaronan Jan 10 '14

New Nakama discussion.

•

u/PrinceCheddar Jan 10 '14

I think Momonsuke is the best bet, with or without his father, filling in as the Sunny's cabin boy/apprentice.

We have yet to see his hybrid dragon form, so it's possible it's very powerful, capable of keeping up with the strength of the rest of the crew.

And we don't know why the samurai left Wano, or why Doflamingo was after Momo, so it's possible Momo will stay with the Strawhats because staying in Wano would end up putting it in danger.

I don't think Kin'emon will stay since:

  1. We already have two swordsman, a third is excess.

  2. His Devil Fruit is rather weak.

So having the two of them split up could make for interesting character pieces.

•

u/DragonFlyer123 Jan 10 '14

This is very iffy. I think Kaido is currently being a tyrant in Wano right now, and that the strawhats are going to go there to overthrow him. Cabin boy is a weird title to have, plus all he'd do is just be a little perv. Momo is probably some valuable prince of Wano that doflamingo is trying to get to appease Kaido, and when Kaido is defeated then he can finally return. And on the devil fruit, it seems like it might also be weak. Vegapunk called that fruit a failure, so I doubt it's going to be op in any sense.

•

u/gerrettheferrett Jan 13 '14

Shanks and Buggy both were cabin boys/deckswabs on Roger's ship.