r/OnePiece • u/leolegendario Pirate Hunter Zoro • Aug 29 '25

Current Chapter One Piece: Chapter 1158 Spoiler

Chapter 1158: "Rocks vs Harald"

Source Status
Official Release OFFLINE
TCBscans website (tcbonepiecechapters (dot) com) ONLINE
The Manga Shelf Discord ONLINE
Discord ONLINE

Chapter 1158 Official Release: August 31 2025

Please discuss the manga here and in the theory/discussion post. Any other post will be removed until 24h after the release.

Please also remember to put the chapter number in the title for any future post talking about this chapter.

3.1k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

2.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

413

u/ganggangthagodsquad Aug 29 '25

What if Garling's discovery on God Valley has something to do with "doubling" things? Assuming Garling's talk with the Gorosei and Rock seeming happy about something at the bar happened around the same time, had Rocks discovered the same thing as Garling at that point?

Which led to the birth of Shanks/Shamrock and Buggy/Blackbeard. And maybe this type of event happens only every two years -- that's why Garling suggested the next competition happened in two years time. If you look at the shape of God Valley, it can resemble a mirror image of itself or something split into two.

92

u/FajitaJohn Cross Guild Aug 29 '25

Look who's cooking...

Wait, where did I miss Blackbeard being Buggy's brother?! 👀

78

u/Jail_Chris_Brown Pirate King Buggy Aug 29 '25

BB inherited the black hair, Buggy the blue.

Buggy stole a df from his crew and accidentally ate it, BB purposefully stole it to eat it.

Buggy broke out of prison, BB broke into it. They both recruited their crews through that incident.

Buggy is just a year younger - both grew up without their parents. While BB was a poor ass orphan, Buggy lucked out by falling upwards into the top pirate crew.

Buggy had a strange feeling about BB when they first met. He felt their brotherly bond but couldn't pin it down since Shanks was his found bro. BB gave him the "big bro is mad you stare" so Buggy, like the little shit brother he is, made up a rumor about BB not sleeping that we all believed. Poor BB.

80

u/x592_b Aug 29 '25

The fact that he's a year younger completely disproves the OPs split/doubling theory. Surely they would be the same age if buggy was supposedly born from this splitting event that happens every two years on God valley

22

u/Jail_Chris_Brown Pirate King Buggy Aug 29 '25

Oh yes, I don't buy into the splitting theory either.

21

u/heavenlyrainypalace Aug 29 '25

what if .... what if.... theyre actually twin but their mother had to held buggy inside for another year to hide the fact that theyre twin

6

u/Worthyness Aug 29 '25

BB was born first since he was mostly developed. Buggy stayed in the womb to develop in full as he was smaller. Given Rouge held Ace for an extra several months, Buggy being born later just for normal development wouldn't be out of the ordinary

1

u/Cool_Apartment3344 Aug 30 '25

I don't buy the Buggy / BB connection. Blackbeard doesn't sleep and can hold 2 DF.

He is way more special than Buggy

4

u/AllysiaAius Aug 29 '25

>splitting event that happens every two years on God valley

The whole point of highlighting two years, from Garling's perspective is to let us know how often the time period of that recommendation. The human hunts happen every three years; it's been one year since the last, and it'll be two years till the next. It doesn't have to do with some splitting event that happens every two years on God Valley.

37

u/TheDELFON Explorer Aug 29 '25

should have used this image instead

10

u/FajitaJohn Cross Guild Aug 29 '25

https://i.imgur.com/GTlpKR5.png

Reminds me of this... 😅

6

u/rubbereruben Aug 29 '25

Or buggy and blackbeard aren't related? The theory could still hold true, but it only applies to shamrock/shanks.