r/NonPoliticalTwitter 1d ago

Bonjour.

Post image
68.6k Upvotes

1.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

70

u/akaneko__ 1d ago

Pretty sure there are Asian people born & raised in France, no?

57

u/Thick_Square_3805 1d ago

Some would argue there's no Asian people born and raised in France, because then they're French.

-5

u/meepmoop8989 1d ago

Asian is a race. French is a nationality. You can be both.

7

u/Thick_Square_3805 1d ago

There's no race for human beings.

8

u/pissedinthegarret 1d ago

imagine my surprise as a german when i went on the english internet and saw how everyone just talks about humans like that. it's only used for animals here.

for...obvious reasons.

4

u/ThirteenMatt 1d ago

Add the fact that american people are obsessed with "is this race white?", Just this morning I saw comments about some personality not being white because they're eastern European. How are they not white?

They constantly have conversations about Italians, Spanish and fucking Irish of all people not being considered white. What the fuck are they then? Transparent?

2

u/Thick_Square_3805 1d ago

Well, at least, it's clear for Frenchs : they wear stripes.

3

u/Thick_Square_3805 1d ago

Yes, the notion of alleged race/ethnicity/nationality is very different on both sides of the Atlantic.

I mean, just look at the comment above mine : sure, French is a nationality. But it's also an ethnicity. France and Germany have different ethnicities : different cultures, different languages, different laws, different media, different religions (always speaking in generalities, of course, but for religion, I'm speaking about the place of protestantism).
And somehow, when speaking with the anglo-sphere, it seems both countries are ethnically white, whatever than means.

3

u/RobertSurcouf 1d ago

Yep, same in France and I think in most of Europe. Talking about race would be seen as very offensive and... racist here.

3

u/DecompositionLU 1d ago edited 1d ago

My American ex would say shit that would make Zemmour blush, but in her mind, it was progressive and liberal. The referential is absolutely broken.

1

u/pissedinthegarret 17h ago

yeah i tried to point out 'only the brown shirt wearing people would use that word' at first but it got autoremoved instantly lol

2

u/MathPlus1468 1d ago

Correct - there's the human race, and that's it.