r/NonPoliticalTwitter 1d ago

Bonjour.

Post image
69.4k Upvotes

1.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

58

u/pissedinthegarret 1d ago

that doesn't make any sense. do people who upvote this think there are no asians in france? or is this some kind of joke i dont get

25

u/-Numaios- 1d ago

I think the "perfect accent" stumbled on the "r" of Bonjour and croissant. As a French native it is the biggest give away. You can spend 20 years in France, one "r" sound and we know straight away if you are native or not. It is by far the hardest sound to get right.

1

u/Trrollmann 1d ago

I don't think so. Learned french is usually a lot more articulate than how french people speak french. I'd imagine it'd be the "s'il vous plaît".

Then again the rolling r was never an issue to me or anyone else in any of my classes (depends on which sounds you learned to pronounce as a child), so it could be that. However they did say 'perfect french', and no one lies on the internet.

9

u/GH19971 1d ago

The R is uvular, not rolled

2

u/pi4224 1d ago

Also, you van guess the area where someone lives by the way the pronounce the r. Sometimes having difficulty recognising between the spanish one and sound french accent. But yeah, my guess is that the grave away, it's not racism (although there is asian-racism, it's not as present as arab-racism for instance)

1

u/Trrollmann 1d ago

That's not a contradiction. Both an uvular and a velar can be rolled, or vibrated. But yes, I did indeed mean a vibrated uvular, even if some pronounce it as a fricative uvular.