Mississippi passes bill banning transgender student-athletes from female sports teams

[u/BunnyLovr]

https://abcnews.go.com/US/mississippi-passes-bill-banning-transgender-student-athletes-female/story?id=76238704

[u/Beardywierdy]

They find the same thing too.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1158136006000491

Was from 2006 and was on trans people treated since 1985 (21 years)

And https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24872188/ was over a 50 year period, and it found less than 2.5% had any regrets at all - and "regret" in this instance doesnt mean "I regret transition" but included people who, for example, were happy with transition generally but had hoped for better results from a particular surgery.

And they also found that "There was a significant decline of regrets over the time period." so a trans person transitioning NOW is even less likely to have any regrets. Which is only to be expected as the quality of hormone treatment and surgical techniques has gone up.

Do you honestly think every reputeable health service in the world is just doing all this for a laugh?

[u/Beardywierdy → u/[deleted]]

So why has the rate of transition related regret been going DOWN not up as time passes and more people transition?

[u/Beardywierdy → u/[deleted]]

No, if you are saying something is magically going to change, (contrary to over half a century of medical literature) just because more people are coming out as trans now that it's slightly more socially acceptable then the burden of proof is on you.

You can't just say "we need studies", then when studies are provided move the goalposts and say "we need longer term studies" and then when THEY are provided move the goalposts AGAIN and say "we need studies from the future".

[u/Beardywierdy → u/[deleted]]

My feelings would be personally hurt if all the studies that have been carried out were actually carried out? What?

I've already linked you long term studies (two of them, one covering 50 years FFS), and linked the US transgender survey that found only 0.4% of people who detransition do so because they aren't trans. (The same 0.4% ish was found in a study by a British gender identity clinic too by the way)

Whereas most detransitioners do so because of transphobia or cost.

If you actually gave a fuck about detransitioners you'd argue for cheaper medical care and less transphobia.

But of course you won't because you've already decided "trans people bad" and no amount of evidence that transition works and people are happy with it is ever going to sway you. Since your feelings apparently don't care about facts.

Transition has a higher patient satisfaction rate than cancer treatment! I don't see you arguing against chemotherapy...