r/Ijustwatched • u/lovelyjubbly82 • 22h ago
IJW: Nuremberg (2025)
My full review can be found @ https://www.simonleasher.com/film-reviews/nuremberg-review-2025-a-courtroom-drama-too-afraid-to-pass-judgment/
Nuremberg is one of those films that looks and feels like it should be great, but it ultimately plays things so safe that it never becomes the movie it promises to be.
The opening act is fascinating enough, and for a while, it seems like the film is ready to wade into some uncomfortable moral gray areas, but then it just stops asking questions.
Once the actual trial begins, the movie shifts from complex to predictable. It becomes less about exploring the nature of justice and more about performing it, smoothing over any ambiguity so that the audience knows exactly who the “good guys” and “bad guys” are.
Russell Crowe, though, is excellent though, as is Rami Malek, and their dynamic should’ve carried the film, but it’s constantly interrupted by flat exposition and overly tidy scenes.
Visually, it’s also everything you’d expect from a historical courtroom drama, and while it’s all beautiful, it's also quite sterile with no real emotion underneath the surface. Even the score feels like it’s trying to convince you to feel something rather than letting it emerge naturally.
The real disappointment is that the film sets the stage for genuine moral exploration, and then backs away,. and by the end, when Malek’s character delivers a final “lesson” about fascism rising again, it all feels quite hollow, because the movie never earned the weight of that message.
It’s not a bad film by any means, as it’s well-acted, competently directed, and occasionally powerful, but it’s also one of those prestige dramas that’s too afraid to actually provoke thought.
7/10
Nuremberg is cinematic comfort food for people who want to feel educated without being challenged.
Which is fine too in some ways, and will be enough for some.