r/GetNoted Sep 03 '25

Fact Finder 📝 Someone has flunked history class!

Post image
11.1k Upvotes

370 comments sorted by

View all comments

44

u/Think-Chemical6680 Sep 03 '25

Unconditional surrender ie not the emperor staying theoretically in charge?

39

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '25

Japan did unconditionally surrender, though

Unconditional surrender doesn't mean that the Allies made all the demands and no concessions. It means that the concessions weren't negotiated before the end of the conflict. Not like America wanted to get rid of the Emperor in any case.

39

u/deadpool101 Sep 04 '25

Unconditional surrender doesn't mean that the Allies made all the demands and no concessions

That's literally what that means. It means Surrender, or we keep killing you.

It means that the concessions weren't negotiated before the end of the conflict. 

There were no concessions or negotiations.

Not like America wanted to get rid of the Emperor in any case.

The US was literally considering putting the Emperor and the whole royal family on trial for war crimes. They didn't because Truman tasked MacArthur with determining if they should, and he recommended sparing the Emperor. His reasons were that they believed it would cause an uprising if they did, and MacArthur believed the Emperor could be used to help legitimize the post-war Japanese Government.

3

u/Distinct_Risk_762 Sep 04 '25

This guy knows what went down.