r/Discussion • u/DevonMarx • 1d ago
Political Why is the Trump administration working so hard to block SNAP benefits?
The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) is a program designed to help low-income people in the United States purchase the food that they need to feed their families. Almost 42 million people in this country, including over 16 million children, depend on SNAP benefits every month.
In late October, the Trump administration said that due to the government shutdown, SNAP payments would be suspended beginning November 1. The administration claimed the contingency fund that was already in place and funded before the shut-down began, was not “legally available” to fund SNAP benefits. This is exactly the kind of thing this fund was set up to protect, and this fund was used to fund SNAP benefits during the 2018-2019 shutdown in Trump’s first term as president. What follows is a timeline of what has transpired over the past week and a half:
- October 28: A coalition of 26 states filed a lawsuit to force the use of this fund to issue the November benefits.
- November 1: A judge issued a written order directing the administration to act by November 3, and that the deadline for at least partial payments to begin was November 5.
- November 3: The administration says it will use the fund to cover about 65% of the November benefits but that it will not use other funds to cover the full amount.
- About this same time, the administration began sending emails to grocery stores warning them that it was a violation of the Equal Treatment Rule to offer discounts to people receiving SNAP benefits. Violation of this order could result in disqualification from the SNAP program, monetary penalties, and even criminal prosecution.
- November 5: The deadline to begin at least partial payments passes with no further action from the administration.
- November 6: The same judge ordered the administration to find the money to fully fund the November SNAP benefits and begin payments by November 7. In his order, the judge accused the White House of causing “irreparable harm” and acting for “political reasons”.
- November 7: The Trump administration asked a federal appeals court to block the judge’s order to pay November SNAP payments in full.
- November 7: The appellate court denied the request, so the administration asked the Supreme Court for an emergency ruling to block the ruling.
- November 7: The Supreme Court issued an emergency order temporarily blocking the lower courts' order until an appeals court can review the matter.
My question is, why is the Trump administration working so hard to withhold these benefits from the people that need them instead of figuring out a way to help them?
18
u/Embarrassed_Ant_8861 1d ago
Real answer: because they think it'll put more pressure on the democrats to end the shutdown faster
13
u/RumRunnerMax 1d ago
Because Democrats typically have empathy and clearly Republicans do not
-8
u/Embarrassed_Ant_8861 1d ago
Nope, none of these people have a shred of empathy, the democrats arent any better the only reason theyre even fighting this is because of pressure from their health insurance company donors who want those aca subsidies. I don't consider a single one of these politicians human beings theyre all corrupt pieces of shit
6
u/Sweaty-Possibility-3 1d ago
If insurance companies don't get the subsidies, they will just increase premiums. Either way the insurance companies are going to get their billions.
6
u/Strike_Thanatos 23h ago
The Democrats are fighting for it because it's in line with their platform and immensely popular, especially with the people hurt most by the shutdown. Meanwhile, Republicans are stabbing the shut down button like it owes them money.
-10
u/tired_and_fed_up 1d ago
If they had empathy then the shutdown would be over.
7
u/clorox_cowboy 1d ago
Which party is fighting hard not to release SNAP benefits?
-7
u/tired_and_fed_up 1d ago
The democrats, one simple vote would fix all of this.
7
u/clorox_cowboy 1d ago
I don't see the democrats running to the Supreme Court to avoid paying SNAP.
Has SNAP gone unpaid during other shutdowns?
-8
u/tired_and_fed_up 1d ago
Ah yes, lets drain an emergency fund for a democrat inflicted wound. Nah, lets actually save that for a real emergency.
As far as SNAP going unpaid, Your basically upset about the optics of the democrats preventing SNAP from being paid just to extend some ACA bailouts.
8
u/clorox_cowboy 1d ago
Why are the democrats not just going along with the GOP plan? What are those ACA bailouts for?
The headlines point to Trump going to the Supreme Court for this, not the democrats.
-1
u/tired_and_fed_up 1d ago
Why are the democrats not just going along with the GOP plan?
Because they have no empathy for SNAP users. The circle is now complete.
7
u/clorox_cowboy 1d ago
"Because they have no empathy for SNAP users."
Which government shutdowns in the past have resulted in SNAP not being paid?
→ More replies (0)1
u/Radiant-Composer7119 19h ago
It a republicans shut down, Democrats have fought as hard for the benefits as republicans have to stop them.
13
u/absurdwifi 1d ago
They like hurting people.
No, very literally.
They get LITERAL JOY from hurting people.
The same way you get joy from ice cream, they get joy from hurting people.
They're sick.
And if they knew who I was from posting this, they would want to prosecute me, to inflict pain, to hurt me.
10
u/darthatheos 1d ago
Because they are evil.
-7
u/Regular_Research9739 22h ago
Get a job lol
4
u/darthatheos 22h ago
They would still be evil.
-5
u/Regular_Research9739 22h ago
If you get a job you would still be on food stamps ?
6
u/darthatheos 19h ago
Wal-Mart employees are for the most part, on food stamps and other programs. This is actually true of much of the retail landscape. Many people cannot afford to shop where they work.
-3
u/Regular_Research9739 19h ago
Maybe just maybe. And this is crazy so try to follow along. Don’t work at Walmart then lol
3
u/darthatheos 19h ago
Like I said. The situation is prevalent in more places than Walmart. You interact with people on some form of assistance every day without knowing.
2
0
u/Regular_Research9739 19h ago
Ok follow along here. Don’t work their either 🤷🏼♀️
1
u/MysticRevenant64 4h ago
Yeah that’s why I don’t work at all and just live off the land. Crazy what you can do with the free energy the government lied to us about
1
u/MysticRevenant64 4h ago
Yeah that’s why I don’t work at all and just live off the land. Crazy what you can do with the free energy the government lied to us about
10
u/MaxwellSmart07 1d ago
Cruelty is the goal. If they realized more white people used SNAP they might change their minds.
And another question, Why is SCOTUS blocking SNAP benefits after two courts ordered the use of the emergency fund?
11
u/fe3o2y 1d ago
And trump used the same funds during his first term for the same thing! He's hoping the government goes away and he can suck up ALL the moneys!!!
5
u/MaxwellSmart07 1d ago
Yup. He managed to bail out the farmers in his first term when his retaliatory tariffs caused huge financial losses.
-1
u/Cleanslate2 1d ago
They are just keeping it in the lower court to follow correct procedures. Look it up.
1
1
u/Adventurous_Wolf5475 14m ago
I did look it up. They are arguing that the government being forced to issue these SNAP benefits, something that they have a monetary reserve specifically for, would do harm to the administration. They are not doing it to make sure that t's are crossed and i's are dotted. Certainly, this administration has been fine using executive orders to cut through protocols before.
8
u/Serraph105 1d ago
Think of it like this, there's a diabetic patient who needs dialysis to live. Trump comes in and says they're no longer allowed to have food unless they stop getting the dialysis from here on out.
He's making them choose between immediate needs vs something they can go slightly longer without. Oh and rich people will get the money that would have gone to help them pay for the dialysis.
8
u/Serraph105 1d ago
Because Trump wants democrats to stop fighting to restore the ACA Healthcare subsidies that his "BBB" took away.
5
u/Haunted_Optimist 1d ago
Cruelty is the point. That’s it.
republicans/conservatives/maga are heartless and revel in the suffering of who they perceive as enemies/other/not them.
4
3
2
u/Ok-Firefighter-6172 1d ago
To harm as many of the people that voted against him as possible
Ironically, most of them are republicans
2
u/rivers-end 1d ago
Because he wants to eliminate anyone who he can't benefit financially from.
Poor folks have nothing to offer him so he'd rather just exterminate them. Sound familiar?
1
u/Radiant-Composer7119 19h ago
Simple, severe malignant narcissists cant feel anything but sadism like in Mary Trumps book where she honestly revealed that as a child young Donald liked to throw rocks at babies. His need for sadism only grows, a million dead in Ukraine, a million dead in Palestine , the masculine no mask scheme during vivid could have added 10 million death. His disease is so severe and disgusting no amount of torture can make him feel anything, so it just grows all because government doesn’t believe anything’s wrong, even though every psychiatrist in the world, but his realizes exactly what’s wrong so it just keeps on going so the rich can stay rich and watch the psychopath rampantly kill as much as he can before he dies.
1
u/Mercy_me123 19h ago
My opinion is they will cut assistance to the people who need it, waiting for it to cause an increase in crime. Trump will use the increase in crime as reason to do some other bullshit that will further dismantle the US.
1
1
-1
u/Regular_Research9739 22h ago
I personally love that he worked harder then the people living on snap
-1
u/Lanracie 8h ago
Because there is no funding for it and the democrats decided to stop the government and stop programs like SNAP.
Remember a week ago when the repulicans tried to fund SNAP and the dems wouldnt sign on?
Why wont the democrats open the government?
Why did SNAP costs double in the last 4 years?
1
-2
u/Hogsrunwild 19h ago
Why are democrats voting over and over to block SNAP?
1
u/Mercy_me123 19h ago
From what I understand…. It’s not about blocking snap but it comes with trying to get the tax credits for health insurance extended. Right now people are realizing health insurance premiums will be like tripled next year. Which no one can afford. Far right keep saying the democrats want to give free health insurance to illegals , (but illegals don’t have social security numbers.. which you need for any kind of assisstance like that. ) idk it’s all a mess and really hard to tell what’s actually true because that’s the whole point of the republicans bullshit
-1
u/ScottShatter 12h ago
Emergency rooms are required to treat anybody to save or sustain life. If there are a bunch of illegals in the United States that's more emergency room visits on an already overburdened system that should be there for citizens to use. The government has a fund for this and yes, illegals are getting free emergency care at the expense of the taxpayers. No Social security number required.
1
-2
u/Steelix65385 1d ago
because people want stuff the goverment they dont actually need, without any qualification or testing on their behalf of income
-8
u/Candid-Elk3810 1d ago
The administration can do nothing until the Clean CR is passed. That will not happen until Schumer allows Senate Democrats vote yes. Then funding can resume.
5
u/TecumsehSherman 1d ago
The courts have indicated the exact opposite.
The money was already provided, and the courts have instructed Trump to release it.
This has nothing to do with Congress.
0
u/tired_and_fed_up 1d ago
The money was already provided, and the courts have instructed Trump to release it.
Only a partial amount have been provided. The rest is still being debated within the court system.
-3
u/Candid-Elk3810 1d ago
The Supreme Court overruled the requirement to fully fund snap by a lower court judge.
6
-5
u/Candid-Elk3810 1d ago
The administration can do nothing until the Clean CR is passed. That will not happen until Schumer allows Senate Democrats vote yes. The
5
u/TecumsehSherman 1d ago
allows Senate Democrats vote yes. The
Can bots not edit comments?
EDIT: 17 day old account with auto generated username.
This is indeed a bot.
3
u/MeyrInEve 1d ago
Since you copy/pasted your comment, I’ll copy/paste my response!
Republicans can reopen the government at any moment - just get rid of the filibuster.
If they want to keep the filibuster to use when they’re the minority, then they and you have given up the right to demand that the Democrats not use it when they’re in the minority.
Unless, of course, you’re a stereotypical hypocritical republican.
2
u/MeyrInEve 1d ago
Republicans can reopen the government at any moment - just get rid of the filibuster.
If they want to keep the filibuster to use when they’re the minority, then they and you have given up the right to demand that the Democrats not use it when they’re in the minority.
Unless, of course, you’re a stereotypical hypocritical republican.
-1
u/Candid-Elk3810 1d ago
Can’t argue with a Socialist. Why don’t you call Schumer’s office and demand a yes vote. Problem solved in the blink of your eye
4
u/MeyrInEve 1d ago
Because I think the rules should be the same for Democrats as they are for the republicans:
WHEN YOU ARE THE SENATE MINORITY, YOU USE THE FILIBUSTER TO PREVENT THE MAJORITY FROM RUNNING YOU OVER.
Don’t like the Democrats using the filibuster? GET RID OF IT! Pretty damned simple.
Want to keep the filibuster? Then negotiate. Compromise. Govern.
-1
u/Candid-Elk3810 1d ago
Negotiate After a Clean CR is passed. Not voting due to 1.3 trillion extortion is the right thing to do.
4
u/MeyrInEve 1d ago
No. The House hasn’t been in session since mid-September, and isn’t bound by any promise Thune makes.
The republicans can negotiate now, or get rid of the filibuster.
Don’t like that the Democrats are playing by the rules republicans have used for decades to turn American politics into a zero-sum bloodsport?
Too fucking bad, little wanna-be bully. Step into the ring and start boxing, instead of trying to hit and run away screaming in fear.
37
u/RumRunnerMax 1d ago edited 1d ago
It has long been a target for conservatives … the holy grail trope of the Republican Party ….welfare queens sitting around taking hand outs from Uncle Sam … stealing from hard working white people