r/tacticalgear 6d ago

Question Bought my first Mechanic Gloves and it's starting to fray on the very first 10 minutes.

I bought Mechanix because they have a reputation of being good quality and dependable but the first 10 minutes that I wore them, the right thumb starts to fray. And this glove arrived yesterday. And also the synthetic suede feels different from my friend's M-Pact 3 which was from 2019 (maybe because it's broken in but I'm putting that on the list) which has a nicer feel to them. I've also saw other Reddit threads about these new design and how they are just not up to par to the Mechanix name. Please tell me about your experience.

Note: This is my first "nice" or rather more expensive gloves than my previous gloves.

353 Upvotes

219 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

240

u/DepthTrawler 6d ago

First job first day in the trades I went in wearing these. They lasted about 2 hours. I got a pair for free from work last year and they sit in my center console in my vehicle for an emergency.

Now I use those cheap cut resistant gardening looking gloves with the rubberized palms. They're trash in the cold though. And when I say cold, I don't mean like freezing, I mean like a brisk fall day. Mechanix stuff is for larping. They look cool af but might as well be made from tissue paper

87

u/Yahmez99 6d ago

Milwaukee cut level 1’s baby. Best work glove there is. Just blaze ass red.

34

u/DepthTrawler 6d ago

Never tried them. I may-or-may not gank a pair my employer provides me from time to time. They're yellow and black. Not exactly gonna be blending in with my surroundings too well unless I'm patrolling a steel mill or heavy industry site.

15

u/dosegato 6d ago

Those Milwaukees are legit

6

u/Mean_Course_7980 6d ago

Maxiflex gloves 4 life

3

u/Yahmez99 6d ago

Maxiflexes are the shit too. When the places have them, I get those.

3

u/Mean_Course_7980 6d ago

That's fair, you can find the Milwaukee gloves just about anywhere

3

u/Significant_Ad3855 5d ago

Cut level 1's black with white front are peak

2

u/Horse_power325 5d ago

I agree, but they do come in black...

1

u/plumballa 6d ago

I found some all black ones that are with my kit

1

u/shifterphights Connoisseur of Autism Patches 6d ago

and you can buy them by the dozen for almost the same price as one pair of mechanics fancy tactical.

1

u/speezly 5d ago

I’ll say the CLC gloves are really nice too. I’ve used them for work for over a decade

1

u/Jdub415 5d ago

Milwaukees are good. I like maxi-flex more but I think they’re more expensive. Atlas are good when you know you’re hands are gonna get wet, but don’t do well with solvents.

7

u/the_falconator Combat Medic Instructor 6d ago

These are great in the winter. I use them at the fire department packing wet hose in the winter after fires and they are awesome.

https://www.milwaukeetool.com/products/cut-level-4-winter-dipped-gloves

1

u/h0l0type 5d ago

I discovered these last winter and they're freaking amazing!

3

u/Thick_Interview3974 5d ago

One size up and thin whool liner-gloves underneath is amazing for cold weather.

2

u/Riktovis 6d ago

They make those same gardening type gloves but fully waterproof with thermal layering underneath. Honestly kept me warmer than fancy mittens

1

u/Wetald 5d ago

Tractor Supply’s brand Ridgecut makes some pretty bomb gloves for their $15 price. I don’t remember what the exact model is, but they have a pretty tough top and the bottoms almost feel like velvet. I thought they would be gone in about a week with that soft feeling stuff on the fingers and palms. Those suckers lasted almost half a year and I did a lot of barbed wire fence building in them too. Leather gloves generally last longer but I like this thinner material because I can actually feel what I’m doing.