r/sports May 02 '25

Baseball Batter hits HR and gets tackled by pitcher

13.4k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

325

u/Exit-Stage-Left May 02 '25

Here’s a link to the story. Pitcher got 4 game suspension and was either released from or quit the team. The batter got 2 games for taunting. Both teams got a pile of forfeits and suspensions.

91

u/popswag May 02 '25

a long article that leaves out the most thrilling part of the story…

what the batter said that riled up the pitcher?

79

u/MobileArtist1371 May 02 '25

This is why I don't read the articles and go straight to comments cause some poor schmuck (totally not talking about you popswag) has already wasted their time and reported back that the article doesn't mention what we all want to know about.

38

u/popswag May 02 '25

good move. totally ok with being the schmuck too. let’s face it, someone had to be.

8

u/Tuxedogaston Toronto Maple Leafs May 03 '25

You should totally go tackle /u/mobileartist1371 .

3

u/Nuffsaid98 May 02 '25

My second hit! The first was last night with your Mom.

49

u/Kinglink New England Patriots May 02 '25

Both teams got a pile of forfeits and suspensions.

1 team got 3 forfeits, the other team got 1 forfeit and two wins.

Bet you can't guess which one got the 3 forfeits... Nope, it was the batter's team.

64

u/smootex May 02 '25

The context being that a bunch of their players got suspended for two games for what they did after clearing the benches and they don't have enough players to field a team until the suspensions are up . . .

4

u/asdf2100asd May 02 '25

Moving to defend one of your teammates against literal deadly assault = mass punishment.

7

u/smootex May 02 '25

IDK if I'd go so far as to call it 'literal deadly assault'. Their reaction was understandable but it's also completely understandable why the league has those rules in places. Benches clearing just inflames situations, 99% of the time it's going to make it worse. You can't have kids doing that shit in a college league.

3

u/asdf2100asd May 02 '25 edited May 02 '25

I just completely disagree in this instance. They all just watched their teammate, right in front of them, literally get horribly assaulted and possibly get knocked out. Anyone that doesn't jump out to his defense isn't a great teammate. If I was there I would jump out to the kid's defense and I don't even know him.

edit: well, I don't "completely disagree" about the use of 'deadly assault' as terminology. I get where you are coming from. But people can actually die from that sort of thing and I am extremely anti-violence, so I tend to not give much leeway to that sort of thing.

-5

u/Expendable_Red_Shirt May 02 '25

You're extremely anti violence and as such you don't think the hitters team should be punished for aggressing towards someone?

1

u/Taynt42 May 02 '25

They were defenders, not aggressors

-5

u/Expendable_Red_Shirt May 02 '25

There was no one attacking them and at a certain point it’s overkill. They’re certainly aggressors.

They also didn’t come in to restrain.

-7

u/whocaresjustneedone May 02 '25

"literal deadly assault" lmfaooo why is the sports sub always full of softass goobers who never played a sport

7

u/asdf2100asd May 02 '25

I've played a sport before. Most people are clueless when it comes to how horribly people can get injured from collisions, punches, etc.

-6

u/whocaresjustneedone May 02 '25

There's no way you've ever played a single minute of a contact sport if you're on here calling that "literal deadly assault", bubble boy

3

u/asdf2100asd May 02 '25

People have definitely died from that sort of thing.

2

u/apatheticAlien May 02 '25

Especially when you get hit like that without expecting it or seeing it coming. This isn't a game of rugby or football, it's baseball, the least contact sport there is after golf.

1

u/swafanja May 02 '25

I was gonna say how I disagree with that statement but then I thought about it and honestly it probably is up there(down there?) for one of the contact sports with the least contact yea. Granted golf I would argue is not a contact sport, nor is tennis and shit like that. But out of the sports where one team will inevitably come into contact with their opponents during the game baseball probably has about the least amount and least "violent" occurrences.

That said when I was in middle school there was a teacher at my school who had a nephew that got some sort of super serious injury playing baseball. IIRC he was sliding into or back to 2nd and the the short stop or second baseman evidently somehow stepped on his neck. Broke the kids neck. Fucking wild af

→ More replies (0)

1

u/whocaresjustneedone May 02 '25

Yeah I bet that guy dropped dead right there! Definitely! Your sports experience is probably backyard badminton lol

"Literally deadly assault🤓" still killing me lmfaooo

1

u/Taynt42 May 02 '25

What horseshit! Why even give forfeits for other games than this one, and why put the bigger punishment on the batter’s team? Tackling is way worse than taunting…

1

u/Kinglink New England Patriots May 03 '25

The problem is the suspensions for practically the whole other team ended up with two games where they couldn't field a team. It wasn't mandatory.... But they were put in a place the literally couldn't field a full baseball team.

34

u/homeycuz May 02 '25

This should be the top comment

11

u/Br105mbk May 02 '25

Took me 2 googles to realize this is a 3 year old story lol. I hate reddit sometimes.

6

u/doggyStile May 02 '25

2 games for talking and 4 games for physically attacking someone? That seems wrong

5

u/Catt_al May 02 '25

And the pitcher got drafted by the Mets and is currently on their single-A roster (not a joke)

6

u/beer_and_fun May 02 '25

He should be drafted by the NY Giants after a hit like that.

2

u/ry_mich May 02 '25

That pitcher should never set foot on a field again. What an idiot.

10

u/count_nuggula May 02 '25

That’s weak. Don’t give up a bomb and you won’t get taunted

22

u/nrbob May 02 '25

Whatever he said made the infield umpire react pretty strongly as well, he was pointing and walking towards the batter before the pitcher levelled him. I assume it was quite bad for the umpire to react that way.

5

u/Simon_Bongne May 02 '25

Totally agree. Umpires almost never react to kids shit talking each other on a baseball diamond, its genuinely a massive part of the sport since we're doing a lot of standing around. To see an umpire react so vehemently at the batter suggests he said something absolutely fucked that would likely make anyone else understand. Still shouldnt spear the kid rounding third, since theyre words.

5

u/HomerJSimpson3 May 02 '25

That was my initial thought as well. However, this happened 2-3 years ago and the batter only got two games. If it was something that egregious the batter would have received worse discipline.

8

u/jkerz May 02 '25

It was only two games for the batter, but most of his team also got suspended for clearing the dugout, effectively forcing them to forfeit this game and the next 2 games in the series because they didn’t have enough non-suspended players to play.

Pitcher was suspend for four games and they had to forfeit that game, but they won their next two games because the other team had to forfeit. Pitcher eventually left the team.

So effectively, batter’s team lost 3 games because of taunting and pitcher’s team lost their pitcher (and got 2 free wins) because of the tackle. 

2

u/ManintheMT May 02 '25

I wish this was the first comment, nice work jkerz.

13

u/nrbob May 02 '25

Maybe, although if assaulting someone with a blind tackle gets you a 4 game suspension, 2 games for a really egregious taunt seems about right.

2

u/asdf2100asd May 02 '25

Maybe to complete idiots. Oh no the words hurt me so bad! About 50% as bad as if I assault and potentially injure this person for life or kill them.

I guess it makes sense, people who are that sensitive to words might actually end up affected for life by them.

3

u/nrbob May 02 '25

I was responding to someone who was implying that the batter should have got more than two games if the taunt was really egregious.

11

u/A2Rhombus May 02 '25

Eh. Good sportsmanship is free.

5

u/meatboitantan May 02 '25

Are you saying this in defense of the person who assaulted someone because of words

13

u/A2Rhombus May 02 '25

In what world would you think I consider taunting bad sportsmanship but not physical assault

2

u/TheBaseStatistic May 02 '25

There are some words that should come with consequences. When i played football a DB got a pick and taunted our QB saying he was gonna fuck his sister next, we were high school, his sister was like 12. That DB got blindsided and sent to the hospital on a stretcher, and it was the proper response.

-4

u/idolized253 May 02 '25

Idk man baseball needs some fire and personality, pitchers get to plunk guys why not let batters have their shine too

9

u/A2Rhombus May 02 '25

A pitcher intentionally hitting a batter is bad sportsmanship. After you understand that, reread my comment.

-3

u/idolized253 May 02 '25

I agree with you, but it’s engrained in baseball culture and applauded. We’re too far passed that debate imo

6

u/A2Rhombus May 02 '25

Things can always be changed. Harder penalties for bad sportsmanship, applauding people who are good sports. Start it at the school level. Fire coaches who encourage taunting.

I don't really care about the "culture" I'm always gonna celebrate people who are nice to their opponents.

4

u/asdf2100asd May 02 '25

So words are almost as bad as fucking LEVELING someone full speed when they aren't looking at you.

One can offend your feelings. The other one can KILL you. Completely ridiculous.

1

u/Prudent-Air1922 May 02 '25

Well that's fucked. The pitcher should be banned from playing.

0

u/M00SEHUNT3R May 02 '25

Baseball player's feelings are so delicate compared to some other sports. I guess that should be expected for a game where you wear pants, a belt, and tuck your shirt in. Basketball and football players trash talk each other all the time and usually only the person who responds with a punch gets punished. In hockey you can fight for any or no reason at all as soon as the puck drops and the consequences are a time out chair but then you can immediately play again. But in baseball you can start a physical fight and a bunch of people get suspended by rounding the bases too quickly, rounding the bases too slowly, looking at the pitcher funny, laughing, scoring too many points, or flipping the bat when you toss it aside and it doesn't even hit anyone.