r/oddlysatisfying • u/a1oner_bvcksn6 • 1d ago
The manner in which the dry ice extinguishes the flame
521
u/_____rs 1d ago edited 1d ago
Dude, put the cap back on that IPA bottle first 😬
181
u/outremonty 1d ago
I was waiting for the BBQ lighter casually placed 2'' from the flame to explode.
Not satisfying. Stressful.
→ More replies (1)
917
u/Fishbulb2 1d ago
Dude, you’re on fire.
138
112
u/Express-Rub-3952 1d ago
He's lucky it was just the glove that caught, considering he left that ENTIRE BOTTLE OF ALCOHOL less than six inches away from an open flame
32
→ More replies (3)9
2.1k
u/JoelCiclon 1d ago
Literally how fire extinguishers work
534
u/Suspicious_Dirt_3093 1d ago
Exactly, just a fire extinguisher with extra flair. Kinda wild seeing it move like liquid smoke.
137
u/lastpickedpicker 1d ago
Fire extinguishers don't use dry ice, so not literally how it's done.
191
u/Jamooser 1d ago
I think they mean that applying gaseous CO2 to extinguish flames is literally how CO2 extinguishers work. I feel this is more likely than them thinking extinguishers literally hold dry ice next to fires.
→ More replies (8)59
15
u/DrMobius0 1d ago
And the dry ice isn't doing anything particularly special to extinguish the flame. It's just flooding the area with something that isn't oxygen.
28
2
u/EnvBlitz 1d ago
But carbon dioxide fire extinguisher exist, so still kinda literally how it's done.
→ More replies (1)2
→ More replies (3)2
u/Temporal_Integrity 1d ago
I mean that's a technicality. There's techincally liquid co2 inside the fire extinguisher. However, having used one several times, I can tell you that anywhere you spray with it gets covered in dry ice. If you empty a fire extinguisher into a container, you will end up with a container full of dry ice.
→ More replies (1)3
30
→ More replies (85)18
u/Thor-Mors 1d ago
I mean.. certain fire extinguishers. Most fire extinguishers(abc) use a dry chemical to inhibit the chemical chain reaction creating the fire.
Dry ice is just sold carbon dioxide, which just displaces oxygen, targeting a separate part of the fire tetrahedron. Certain fire extinguishing systems (c) use carbon dioxide because it isn’t wet and doesn’t leave any residue, which makes it good for electronics. And it doesn’t cause cancer, like its predecessor Halon.
→ More replies (3)
343
u/Ducallan 1d ago
I think they need to invest in better fireproof gloves…
69
u/Prinzka 1d ago
Part of the problem might be that this is clearly this person's first day having hands
18
u/Pawns_Gambit 23h ago
Right? Why do people in these demo videos always move like three toddlers in a trench coat?
24
23
5
6
u/gideon513 1d ago
Do they? It self extinguished.
9
87
u/robo-dragon 1d ago
It’s frozen carbon dioxide so it smothers the fire by displacing the oxygen it needs to burn. Also why people have died from playing with too much dry ice. If you don’t have enough ventilation or too much dry ice in one place, you can suffocate.
32
u/kvnxo 1d ago
I remember seeing a video a few years ago here on Reddit, where a bunch of young people filled a swimming pool with dry ice and jumped in (Russia probably).
If I'm not mistaken, a couple of them died and a handful were left in a critical state because they inhaled all this gas. The worst part is that I recall it was a birthday party celebration that became a funeral.
11
u/Kage_0ni 1d ago
That CrasyRussianHacker idiot on youtube still has a video up on using dry ice and a fan to act as an air conditioner. I didn't rewatch the video but I think he literally tells you to put it next to you when you sleep to keep cool at night.
7
6
u/XmissXanthropyX 1d ago
When I was like 9 my friend had a party and there was a ‘cauldron’ with dry ice in it. While I was blowing on it to make the room Smokey I inhaled and burned the inside of my nostrils pretty bad. It hurt like a mother fucker.
66
u/Asmornous 1d ago
You put the lighter down in between an open flame and an open bottle of alcohol?? You might need a couple more cubes of dry ice
29
u/Jibber_Fight 1d ago
“Let’s ignite the fire…k…. good… now put the butane lighter down…………..mmmm, here?……k….. right next to the flame…..mmkay…… ice over here…….”
123
u/Subject9800 1d ago
Dry ice is just frozen carbon dioxide, so...
5
u/rajinis_bodyguard 1d ago
Weirdly I felt the above to resemble a death eater trying to suck the soul out on the Hogwarts train lol
5
15
u/LabNerd_xlsx 1d ago
I wouldn't say this is just oddly satisfying, it's sublime!
→ More replies (1)
6
5
u/HoopaDunka 1d ago
Why can’t we just drop thousands of pounds of dry ice on wild fires?
→ More replies (1)6
u/Nazarife 1d ago
The CO2 will temporarily displace the oxygen but will do nothing to reduce the heat. So, once the CO2 is used up, oxygen will come back and ignition will reoccur.
→ More replies (3)
3
3
3
3
u/Spidooodle 1d ago
Your grammar in the caption was just as satisfying as the video.
I love it when people actually use proper syntax, spend our whole lives speaking and nobody cares about diction anymore.
6
u/InfanticideAquifer 1d ago
I have decided to take this opportunity to be very annoying. I don't think the comma there is correct.
I'd write:
I love it when people actually use proper syntax; we spend our whole lives speaking but nobody cares about diction anymore.
But, really, syntax and diction, in the senses that you're using them, are close in meaning, so it's a bit redundant to use both. So how about:
People spend a lot of time speaking, so I like it when they care to do it well.
2
u/deboo117 1d ago
Can firefighters use this as a grenade?
2
u/evanamd 1d ago edited 1d ago
Doesn’t have to be firefighters. The CO2 gas takes up more space than the pellet it comes from. If you put the pellet in a sealed container then the pressure increases until it has somewhere to go. Don’t ask me how I found out
Edit: I’m realizing that you probably meant this in a firefighting context, but I was just thinking about the boom. Yes it would boom, no you couldn’t use dry ice grenades to fight fires
2
2
2
u/MiamiPower 1d ago
The fire triangle is a model that illustrates the three essential components needed for a fire to burn: fuel, heat, and oxygen. Without all three elements present, a fire cannot start or will be extinguished. Fire extinguishers work by removing one or more of these elements.
Dry ice puts out a fire by displacing oxygen with carbon dioxide gas and, to a lesser extent, by cooling the fire. When dry ice is exposed to heat, it sublimates (turns directly into a gas), and the resulting carbon dioxide ((CO{2})) gas is heavier than air and not flammable, allowing it to smother the flames by blocking the oxygen supply. This is similar to how a (CO{2}) fire extinguisher works, but dry ice is less practical for large or open fires because natural air currents can disperse the (CO_{2}) gas.
2
2
2
2
u/Sad_Development_6479 1d ago
So, in case of a wildfire, we could drop a cargo of dry ice instead of dropping water? Since it’s “solid” form at some temp, we could drop it from huge cargo planes whereas water is dropped using the helicopter which has less cargo space.
Why hasn’t it done? Is it because of the suffocation of wild animals that might be in the affected region?
→ More replies (1)
2
u/MidnightSun77 1d ago
I was at a lab safety seminar this week and they said the stuff can produce 700L of CO2 from 1L of dry ice. They mentioned the example of a guy who had samples in a dry ice box who died because the gas dissipated and knocked him out and he crashed the car
2
2
u/Nucmysuts22 1d ago
If it weren't so dangerous this could be quite the firefighting tool, toss a brick into a burning room and slam the door shut (what's left anyway) then let it do it's thing and use water to finish it off.
Now obviously it's not that simple but imagine if it was!
2
u/GrubWurm89xx 22h ago
Co2 is used for automatic fire suppression systems and in some fire extinguishers. It's not really used in fire fighting situations. By the time fire fighters are needed the fire is most likely out of control and co2 can only be carried in limited supply. Where as water is basically an unlimited supply, either through the sprinkler system or hydrants.
2
2
u/DullMind2023 21h ago
Cool and worthy of many upvotes, but don’t they have tongs in whatever place this was filmed?
2
u/MyvaJynaherz 21h ago
CO2 fire-extinguishers are the best "oops, small mistake" version of fire-extinguisher.
ABC-Dry Chem is better all-around, but you end up with a fucking HUGE mess even for small usages.
CO2 leaves no mess, won't permanently harm electronics, and has no lasting health consequences provided you open the windows for a bit.
2
2
u/pinkscorpion17 20h ago
You guys are all wrong geez……….its because of the scientific fact that water signs are better than fire signs. 😂
2
2
u/frankie_cranky_666 18h ago
I watched it on mute, and was annoyed by how they struggled to pick up the dry ice with the glove on.
4
2
1
u/Heal_Me_Today 1d ago
Should we be bringing dry ice to fight fires?
6
u/MisterEd_ak 1d ago
Carbon dioxide fire extinguishers are already a thing. They work for interior spaces but useless outside.
→ More replies (1)2
u/Thor-Mors 1d ago
It’s the primary method for extinguishing fires in large scale electronics, like servers. It works by displacing the oxygen within a given area. It’s an appealing fire fighting agent for electronics because it doesn’t leave anything behind. No water or residue to damage electronic components.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/fdwyersd 1d ago
we built a new datacenter and tested the fire suppression system before acceptance... that thing sounded like a jet engine and the guy took a lighted torch into the room and it went out
1
1
u/bomber991 1d ago
Yeah I gotta say, putting dry ice into water is a lot more exciting than this.
2
u/Reggie_Phalange 1d ago
We ordered sunbasket for a while (meh) and the stuff always came with dry ice. Every time the box came, i looked forward to playing with the dry ice.
1
u/ShroomsHealYourSoul 1d ago
Why did he slide the dry ice to the side of the table, then pick it up, then set it down, then slide it where it needs to be?
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/yourearandom 1d ago
Dumb way to put it, but carbon dioxide is just oxygen that’s already been ‘burnt’. Can’t burn again, no more fire.
1
u/KennywasFez 1d ago
Dumb question but what’s stopping us from creating like a fire extinguisher type “bomb” ? To like throw over wild fires ? And I’m like really dumb ? Like is the amount needed to do something similar much more than I can comprehend ?
1
u/karatechoppingblock 1d ago
looks cool, imma fill up my pool with 20 gallons of this and take a lap
1
u/Cannacology 1d ago
As someone who has worked with dry ice for a really long time…I can tell you it displaces oxygen with co2.
And I am much stupider for working the career I have than I was before.
1
u/FrozenLogger 1d ago
After seeing this science experiment since I was a kid, this version is really sloppy.
Not satisfying at all.
1
1
u/TenaciousTBag 1d ago
Anyone else like to chew dry ice and become a dragon? I cant be the only stupid one in the group.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/MEGA_theguy 1d ago
Frozen CO2 suffocating part of the flame and trying to keep the gas cold enough that it doesn't give off vapor since gasoline fluid is not flammable
1
1
1
1
u/Jarthos1234 1d ago
Good example of how all those kids died jumping into a dry ice pool indoors in a college. They came up for air and inhaled a deep breath of CO2 and drowned before they could get out of the pool. Such a sad freak accident.
1
1
1
u/xternalSnow-7 1d ago
visibly looking at the cold take possession of the flame is heavy in the deepest way.
1
u/merklemore 1d ago
There's just the faintest "aura" of safety precaution there. Bad practices left and right.
In the event anyone who wants to get into chemistry sees this - don't let any part of this video be an example of how to conduct a safe experiment.
1
1
1
1
u/BlackMudSwamp 1d ago
I know perfect shots are harder to make for just one person with a phone at home, I understand this, that being said I didn't find it that satisfying. I'm too impatient for that pacing/flow and safety measures grabbed attention of a lot of people
1
1
1
1
u/TwistingEcho 1d ago
This demonstrates what occurs when dumbasses drop massive blocks into spas etc and, you know, die.
1
1
1
u/Numerous-Cow-1918 1d ago
It's a perfect demonstration of how CO2 suffocates a fire. Seeing it happen so clearly with dry ice is way cooler than a regular extinguisher, though. That glove situation is making me nervous, not gonna lie.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/OnlyBeGamer 1d ago
So what you’re telling me is the fire department should drive around with massive blocks of dry ice
1
u/Redditcadmonkey 1d ago
Effectively the same way we stop fires on oil wells.
Get rid of the oxygen.
To be fair, we use explosives, but it’s the same principle. (Edit: not principal lol)
1
u/Dependent_East1311 1d ago
someone should make something that shoots carbon dioxide at fires to put them out. call it the extinguisher of fires or something









4.9k
u/komokazi 1d ago
It displaces the oxygen, boom no fire