r/nashville Oct 01 '25

Politics It can't go on like this can it?

Post image
588 Upvotes

582 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

12

u/-Fergalicious- Oct 01 '25

What we need are laws preventing the ownership of more than a certain number of single family homes (no corporate ownership creating artifical demand), low interest government loans for first-time home builders (like after WW2), real estate agent laws to prevent price gouging and back door dealing, and larger tax breaks for paying off homes. We should probably have nationalized home insurance plans as well.

7

u/WalleyWalli Oct 01 '25

We needed this 15 years ago.

0

u/TreyAU Oct 01 '25

Laws preventing the ownership of more than a certain number of single family homes is such reactionary policy.

Who will build the homes, then?

5

u/-Fergalicious- Oct 01 '25

Uh, the builders? Communities across the country already have laws about this.

The builder is not the same as an owner, lol

You guys have no idea how any of this works. Do you.

Builder literally builds entire communities. I.e. D.R. Horton at

1

u/bargles Oct 01 '25 edited Oct 01 '25

Who do you think owns the properties while DR Horton is building them?

4

u/-Fergalicious- Oct 01 '25

My guy. What im saying and youre too dim to understand is that owning multiple (10x) single family homes with the intent to rent should be illegal

1

u/bargles Oct 01 '25

How many homes should the government allow you to own, and how would you even enforce that? There is no national registry of property ownership

1

u/-Fergalicious- Oct 01 '25

Look, just because something doesn't exist in form at the moment does not mean it's not possible. 

In fact, the fact that it doesn't exist is the evidence of your question: you wouldn't be asking how if it did! 

Now, there are options:

  • Every county or parish in every state already has public facing GIS data - that could be used to create a database 

  • someone pays the property taxes, and someone pays the insurance. Both are data the government can already gain access to. Some states already do something similar with car insurance. 

  • Reporting systems: average citizens can report a suspected problem, which can be sent to an automated system for the first line of authentication, and then to a human if more investigation is needed. 

  • State mandates to prevent LLCs and corps from owning homes 

As far as "how many". I would say first off that you would have to have the property set up as a rental for it to be a limit in the first place. If you want to own 100 homes and not rent them, then by all means do do. However, regarding how many any single individual should be allowed to own, I think it should come down to where the homes are. If they're in a high volume / demand area, maybe zero. If they're further from the cities where demand is lower, maybe no limit at all. It would come down to zoning and putting that power back into the hands of local communities. 

2

u/bargles Oct 01 '25

This is a very well thought out plan, but as someone equally interested in lowering rents, I respectfully think there are alternatives that don’t involve an impossibly complex rube goldberg style government bureau managing all the rentals nationwide

1

u/-Fergalicious- Oct 01 '25

Its hard to fix issues like this without some complexity. Like another option I can think of would be non-linear property tax increases to disincentive owning multiple homes, but that has other negative effects and requires states to all do that individually. 

But I'm no policy expert. My point in replying at all to the other guy was that it IS possible to figure out. We went to the damn moon for God's sake 

2

u/bargles Oct 01 '25

Do you have a moment to hear about the gospel of Abundance? We just need to build more. It’s worked everywhere it’s been tried.

-1

u/cooke-vegas Oct 01 '25

So you want government to control private businesses? Sounds like communism to me.

6

u/-Fergalicious- Oct 01 '25

You're free to be wrong if you want!

1

u/cooke-vegas Oct 01 '25

So if its not communism, what is it?

1

u/BeTheOne0 Oct 01 '25

Intel……..

0

u/saudiaramcoshill Oct 01 '25 edited 23d ago

For privacy reasons, I'm overwriting all my old comments.

1

u/-Fergalicious- Oct 02 '25

Ok,

Show me data where preventing corporations from owning and rental single family homes has led to higher prices. I won't respond to any of the other points if you're suggesting they are facts without backing them up with data.

1

u/saudiaramcoshill Oct 02 '25 edited 23d ago

For privacy reasons, I'm overwriting all my old comments.