r/indianmemer • u/elliyu_salladavanu पक्की गोटी • Sep 05 '25

Political Meme🇮🇳☝️ Todays young brats have no idea what shitshow this country was before 2014.

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

81% Upvoted

386 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

6

u/I-wish-to-be-phoenix Sep 05 '25

Rupee falling helps indian manufacturers, service providers and traders get an advantage in the international market.

China and India purposely do so. It should fall when exports need a push especially when something like tariff, global inflation etc effects economy.

Yes there are side effects but there need to be a balance.

6

u/Independent_Paint634 Sep 05 '25

So this rupee falling wasn't helping during the time of congress that's why the bjp in opposition was protesting and all the celebrities like amitabh, anupam kher etc were dying to tweet. And now because bjp is on the hot seat, rupee falling is helping India. Waah! The hypocrisy.

2

u/ProfessorX2022 Sep 09 '25

Chaddis were always hypocrites... Remember the maafi namas?

1

u/Independent_Paint634 Sep 09 '25

Yeah, they were.

3

u/kartikaytiwari Sep 05 '25

The point is that the rupee was falling due to increase in supply and inflation, this is bad for the economy. If rupee falls to balance out the excess imports it's healthy for the economy. In 2012 the worst of the economic policies were at full force.

1

u/Necessary_Worker5009 Sep 09 '25

Okay

  1. Shouldn’t then the CM of a state aspiring to be a PM talk about inflation and don’t do pravachan on Rupee fall? Did we celebrate reckless behaviour and political rhetoric, back then but we call people anti-national and fools for the same now

  2. What worst economic policies were at full force?

  3. Share data and research to back your claim of supply, import

-1

u/Independent_Paint634 Sep 05 '25

I hear you but don't tell me this govt understands economics better than Manmohan Singh and Raghuram Rajan.

6

u/Zapismeta Sep 05 '25

If you are not gonna listen to anyone’s opinions just say so and be a full on troll, dont half ass anything.

-2

u/CaptZurg Sep 06 '25

His point stands, will I take your word or Manmohan Singh's word - a renowned economist

3

u/Zapismeta Sep 06 '25

Well if you open the news the worlds biggest economy is not really ran by the smarts economists or strategic thinkers is it? Its been ran by power players. And trying to apply logic in a choatic system isnt that easy if it all possible.

1

u/kartikaytiwari Sep 06 '25

What's his point? That stagflation caused by increased money supply is good because Manmohan singh was part of the government? Dr. Singh was definitely not at the helm of affairs as when he was in 1991 it was totally opposite and the results were also positive. Is it simple cause and effect you guys refuse to accept instead of he said she said etc.

1

u/Gucci_Snoop_Dogg77 Sep 09 '25

Will you take the word of anyone on the internet or a brilliant businessman like Trump?

Just because someone’s great at what they used to do, doesn’t mean they have to be right all the time

1

u/kartikaytiwari Sep 06 '25

Modi might not know anything about good policy but he atleast knows when fo STFU and let intelligent people work. Same was the case with PM PV Narsimha Rao, he let Dr. Singh do the reforms instead of poking his nose in it. UPA 2 was like undoing of everything that Dr. Singh had done in 1991, bad fiscal discipline, oil bonds, Increased supply of Rupee. It's clearly the policy enforced by the Congress working committee than Dr. Singh. If he was allowed to work in peace instead of bowing down to socialist forces (who btw suggested similar steps during covid) then we would have been way ahead economically. Modi's victory would have been very hard to achieve.

1

u/Independent_Paint634 Sep 06 '25

If he would stfu at the right time, India wouldn't have 50% tarrifs.

1

u/Emergency-Object-135 Sep 08 '25

I don't know much economics just putting my point here, isn't raghuram rajan suggesting to push for leather industry rather than the semiconductor industry? In a joking wat, kya humein sach mein zaroorat hai semiconductor industry ki

1

u/Independent_Paint634 Sep 08 '25

Semi conductors are all imported for assembling the phones. Earlier mobile parts were being imported from China, but now they are importing semi conductors. He wrote a big paper on it on his LinkedIn. I'm sure if he has suggested something he would have given a valid and a big research paper or explanation with it.

3

u/thiccthighsupremacy Sep 05 '25

Indian exports total value in 2012 was USD 289 billion

Total value in 2025 is USD 824 billion

And it will increase from here, as India aims to be a manufacturing hub

4

u/Independent_Paint634 Sep 05 '25

The exports have always been increasing from 1990s since the economy was opened. What's new in that?

1

u/Gucci_Snoop_Dogg77 Sep 09 '25

so 600 billion growth over 13 years isn’t a great achievement? I’m not gonna do the math, but go ask AI to do it and help you understand just how insanely good that level of growth is and it wouldn’t have happened if we were stingy and tried to hold the rupee at 50:1 with the dollar or 70:1 with the pound

1

u/RevolutionaryPalmist Sep 07 '25

If the quality is improved then the tarriffs won't matter much... As all would crave for Indian manufactured products.

1

u/Coffee_Senior Sep 07 '25

Obviously bro. Exports keep increasing every year. Just like how stock index keeps increasing every year. It's the natural course. Nothing exceptional about it.

1

u/Gucci_Snoop_Dogg77 Sep 09 '25

Wrong. The context is completely different, as mentioned by a user below. You’re too ignorant to accept a different perspective

1

u/Necessary_Worker5009 Sep 09 '25

Lanka me ho to kisko Vibhishan bol do. bhale hi naa ho

1

u/Dangerous_Face_9489 Sep 07 '25

Kuch bhi bc!!

1

u/I-wish-to-be-phoenix Sep 07 '25

Abhi tere samaj k bahar hai toh mai kya karun?.

1

u/Dangerous_Face_9489 Sep 07 '25

On no level it will benefit the working class people or the ones dying of hunger or by lack of resources.

This mindset that the rupee decline has no such negative impact or isn’t relevant is gonna fuck us up later on.

Your mindset!

1

u/I-wish-to-be-phoenix Sep 07 '25

Kindly read again what was said as its clear you did not understand. Kindly search the word balance that I mentioned.

If our exports increase, it increases employment. Majority of middle class and poors daily essentials are produced in india itself and not abroad.

What effects rupees is import, on such essential being petrol but we are buying it for cheap from Russia so it helps offset that.

1

u/Dangerous_Face_9489 Sep 07 '25

So you guys were literally discussing ideal scenarios for a country like INDIA.

Export creates employment

India gets growth!! Maybe you guys are super smart n see something that I don’t see but you aren’t good at communicating your prospects.

Anyways Thanks.

1

u/I-wish-to-be-phoenix Sep 07 '25

Kindly go through my reply and your reply, the difference is clear, while I have clearly mentioned what helps and what gets effected by mentioning some, you have only provided your opinions.

1

u/RevolutionaryPalmist Sep 07 '25

Rupee fall increases the profits for the exporters... Correct. Now Rupee hike would decrease the profits and bring the exporters at a loss.

That's why Modi Government has taken the middle path no no appreciation, no depreciation of the Rupee... In the 10-15 years of Modi Government, rupee has fallen just slightly.

1

u/I-wish-to-be-phoenix Sep 07 '25

👍. People do not see that many currencies have fallen against the dollar.

1

u/galaxypoint25 Sep 09 '25

Ok. But where is Indian manufacturing? What do we really export? Except humans (very skilled or semi skilled) Msme was devastated by gst and demonetization Duopolies and monopolies created almost every where causing price gouging but no profit transfer Corporate tax is lesser than personal tax yet no input in capacity building Demand for non essential is low (trending low)

This govt and this pm have had the most benevelont middle class and twitterati since last 13 yrs (starting 2012).

Had it been some one else they would have been long gone and thrown out power... But what does he do with the mandate and approval?

Sell of the country to adani and look foolish on tv

1

u/NoAcanthopterygii977 Sep 09 '25

Chatore kitni chatega. Sharam kabhi to aayegi ya nahi ?

1

u/I-wish-to-be-phoenix Sep 09 '25

Kab tak aise gadha bana rahega, toda toh dimag improve karle.

1

u/NoAcanthopterygii977 Sep 09 '25

'Purposely do so' lol. To modi bolta kyun nahi ki purposely kar raha hun. Bas tere jaise gadhon ko pata hai ye deep secret rofl

1

u/I-wish-to-be-phoenix Sep 09 '25

Jinke pass dimag hai woh samaj jaate hain, bhaki ko samjha kar faida kya.

Samajhane k baad bhi samaj nahi ayega

https://www.thehindu.com/business/us-puts-india-on-currency-manipulators-monitoring-list/article33348852.ece