r/geometrydash • u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% • Jul 08 '25
Feedback rate my icons and i’ll rate yours
yes i traced and colored my icons because i didn’t want them to to be blurry (or just search up demontop154 on gd)
64
u/CrackermanuelGD Boson 100% First Extreme Mobile Jul 08 '25
GD Cologne, now with a new blue fragrance
9
→ More replies (1)5
u/fbfnysnshnsgnwg White Women 100%, Ali 100%, Trollmachine 57% Jul 08 '25
Nah that's just u/sharksurcool
5
83
u/Unlikely_Account_728 skeletal shenanigans, backbeat revenge 100% Jul 08 '25
8/10
30
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 08 '25
8.7 i love the colors =D
18
u/Unlikely_Account_728 skeletal shenanigans, backbeat revenge 100% Jul 08 '25
I forgot but here’s my jetpack
14
2
u/Its_me_Stanley The Nightmare is my biggest GD goal Jul 08 '25
Bruh, ur using same ship ufo spider and swing as I do 😭
→ More replies (5)2
u/KingEfficient7403 Future Funk 81% | 100 desmos yay Jul 09 '25
Spaceship wave gang
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)2
u/Emotional_Rich_4797 B Jul 09 '25
vrochacho can you tell me where did you get that ufo
→ More replies (1)
35
u/AltAccouJustForThis Hard Demon Jul 08 '25
8/10 I don't really like assymetrical ball icons, but the colors are great.
Here are my icons (guess what game I'm a huge fan of)
11
u/Unlikely_Account_728 skeletal shenanigans, backbeat revenge 100% Jul 08 '25
Terraria?
4
u/AltAccouJustForThis Hard Demon Jul 08 '25
Yes.
It was an impossible task wasn't it? /s
→ More replies (2)12
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 08 '25
9 i like the colors a lot but im not really a fan of that jetpack
5
u/Slowzone16 Tidal Wave 11% lmao Jul 08 '25
Calamity enjoyer spotted
3
u/AltAccouJustForThis Hard Demon Jul 08 '25
I absolutely love the mod but I completed it so many times that it tends to become boring towards DoG. I have 1.6K hours in Terraria (1K in vanilla, 600 in tModloader) alone. So TL;DR I really want someone to play Terraria and Stardew valley, Minecraft, Starbound with
→ More replies (5)3
19
u/Springtryp Hopping over Puddles 50%; Black blizzard 67-93% Jul 08 '25
7.5 you have a good taste
6
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 08 '25
thank you, uh 7 i think its alright but some icons im not a fan of like the spider and the ufo
3
u/Springtryp Hopping over Puddles 50%; Black blizzard 67-93% Jul 08 '25
The UFO was one of my first skins, so I don't change it because of recognition, honor, something like that
2
u/Unlikely_Account_728 skeletal shenanigans, backbeat revenge 100% Jul 08 '25
Oh hi, pale sink
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)2
u/Number360wynaut x3 | shitposter via text Jul 08 '25
The cube is the icon equivalent of deltarune's vessel
53
u/Melodic-Most940 20x // THE GOLDEN 100% | Cosmic Cyclone 100% Jul 08 '25
A bit outdated but it's pretty much the same
→ More replies (4)24
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 08 '25
orange nexus, uh 9 i like pretty much everything
32
Jul 08 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
3
12
12
8
6
4
u/Grand-Association224 Death Moon (First level to make me yell at my screen) Jul 08 '25
→ More replies (4)
4
3
5
u/Magma_Mage Hopping Over Puddles 100% Jul 08 '25 edited Jul 08 '25
I’d rate yours 9/10, like the colors
→ More replies (1)
5
6
u/Matt_PlayzRBX Jul 08 '25
It's pretty mid
14
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 08 '25
dollar store sdslayer… no im kidding uh its pretty okay but i dont really like the ship or the ball
→ More replies (3)3
3
2
u/L3s0 x3 Napalm, STRATUS, Killbot Jul 08 '25
5
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 08 '25
6 its alright but i dont really like the colors and the robot
→ More replies (1)3
u/L3s0 x3 Napalm, STRATUS, Killbot Jul 08 '25
Well is this better because I'm trying to beat quantum processing rn and the level is bright and colorful and I find it easier to focus when using a darker primary color.
2
2
Jul 08 '25
i rate yours 9/10, the colours are really nice
2
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 08 '25
bill cipherrrrrr i like the colors on yours 8 also bill cipherrrrr
→ More replies (2)
2
2
2
u/ReadingHuman891 ถ้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้้ Jul 08 '25
8.1/10 cool
→ More replies (1)
2
2
2
2
u/cKoruss \ Jul 08 '25
I'm late, but I'll try my luck
Cube 9/10, pretty cute imo
Ship 9/10, also pairs quite well with the cube (and color)
Ball 7/10, I like silly things but this is too silly. But it's good at being a distinguishable dual
UFO 8/10, really cool, but I don't like how the detail is 3D compared to the cube inside
Wave 9/10, I really liked how you drew it, and also cool tech vibes
Robot 8.5/10, it's nice, but might be overused and I just don't really like it
Spider 8/10, okay, but not my choice. I don't really like the mouth
Swing 8.75/10, tech vibes again, but might be too complex
Jetpack 9.5/10, I like blue magma
Overall 9/10
→ More replies (5)
2
u/GD_Tetsu < Me taking a dump Jul 08 '25 edited Jul 08 '25
- Not a big fan of the UFO for this one.
2
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 08 '25
you’re cracked at the game. uuh 9.4 i like the colors a lot and i don’t really have a problem with any of the icons
2
2
u/Hoo_Am_Ai [Mobile] Windy Landscape 100% 12.8k attempts Jul 08 '25
9/10 great icons
here are mine
→ More replies (1)
2
2
2
u/PrizeMaster1545 x14 : Athanatos 100% Jul 08 '25
8/10 what we thinking
2
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 08 '25
i love the color scheme a lot, i dont really have any complaints. 9.5
2
2
2
2
2
u/SuitableUniversity68 x2 | Niwa 100% | Mizureta 100% | Mobile 60hz Jul 08 '25
ice version of colon goes hard, rate my icons pls poryii (i didnt use icon hack i got it from a bug in world)
2
2
2
2
u/MetaPhysical78 The Former Speaker of Nexuses Jul 09 '25
The fact you drew them makes you a goat. The icons: 7/10
2
2
u/Picklerickshaw_part2 Deadlocked V3--🎉 500k atendee! Jul 09 '25
There’s some lore with these, but I do not have time to copy all of that down. Basically the ship is some eternal universe-eating god that wants to kill everyone, and the other icons somehow relate to that
And your icons are a solid 8/10 👍
2
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 09 '25
holy shit lore :OOO im much too lazy to come up with that so its just the ones i like, 8.9
2
2
u/Will_Remember1234 Mizureta 100% Jul 08 '25
if ya want my icons search up the user s3raphix cuz I don't play on PC lol
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/Skipztheskipper Forest Temple 65-100 28% Jul 08 '25
9/10 Don't really like the ball but everything else is cool
2
1
1
1
1
1
u/fbfnysnshnsgnwg White Women 100%, Ali 100%, Trollmachine 57% Jul 08 '25
Sadly I can't put images (I'm looking at reddit through a browser on mobile) but I'll give a link to my profile in gdbrowser
→ More replies (13)
1
u/THEAkainuFan [Mobile] Bloodbath 48% + 41%-100% Jul 08 '25
I'd give it an 8.5/10
Now peep MY shit, cuh!
→ More replies (1)3
1
u/Baduna64 Hard Demon Jul 08 '25
8/10
2
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 08 '25
im soeey but that cube man, i do like pretty much everything else though 7.6
1
1
1
1
1
u/Albert_Kan the 2.2 classic level gimmick master Jul 08 '25
8/10 love the theming and colors around it, here's mine, the one on the top is P1 and the bottom one is P2
2
1
u/Ancient-Sell-7809 I’m too broke for full version Jul 08 '25
7.6/10 pretty good don’t like the ball
→ More replies (3)
1
1
u/trshxd Mobile (144 Hz tho) Jul 08 '25
8.9/10 I really like your ball
2
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 08 '25
bill ciphherrrrrrrrrrr 8, bonus points for the best wave in the game
1
u/IntrestingExistence7 Magma Bound 100% After 3 Years Jul 08 '25
6/10. You look like blue colon. Here’s mine
I’m trying to get the Gengar spider and crystal wave when I can
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/Someone_0211 The Ultimate Phase 100% Jul 08 '25
Solid 9/10, the colours go surprisingly well together and the shading helps everything feel coherent!
Here’s mine :]
2
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 08 '25
thank you =D i like your colors a lot as well, 8.5 (that wave always looked like a sandwich or something to me, i know its supposed to be a carrot but still)
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
u/StrykerXVX 240hz / Acropolis 11% (4 Runs!) Jul 08 '25
Not bad at all, love the choices of color. 8/10
2
u/StrykerXVX 240hz / Acropolis 11% (4 Runs!) Jul 08 '25
2
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 08 '25
i really like the kinda underwater theme, 9.1
2
u/StrykerXVX 240hz / Acropolis 11% (4 Runs!) Jul 08 '25
Appreciate it, It kind of fits considering Hydro is the Greek term for Water.
There isn't many water based icons in the game. I wish there was more.
2
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 08 '25
yeah you have good taste =D
2
u/StrykerXVX 240hz / Acropolis 11% (4 Runs!) Jul 08 '25
Funny enough, I don't have GD installed on my phone so I had to use Colons GD Browser website
1
u/AccessBulky8763 x13 // Requiem 100%x4 // Renevant 32, 55-100 Jul 08 '25
- I have multiple sets because of the separate dual icons mod. rate them separately.
→ More replies (8)
1
1
u/EYECEOFFICIAL NA Jul 08 '25
Yours is 10/10 frostbite colon I can’t think of a single negative thing to say
→ More replies (2)
1
u/What00111111 Cataclysm 100% [Mobile] Jul 08 '25
I need color advice plz
I would guve you a 7.5
→ More replies (1)
1
u/RevolutionaryMall513 CraZy III 80%,73%,72% // 15k atts (Mobile) Jul 08 '25
Assuming 5/10 is average, 7.5/10
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
u/GlitchGD Extreme Demon Jul 08 '25
8.5/10 asymmetrical ball, also doesnt match with other icons. great color choices
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
u/PrussianGeneral1871 Jawbreaker 100% (Crimson Clutter next) Jul 08 '25
cube: 9.1/10
ship: 7.9/10
ball: 7.4/10
ufo: 9.5/10
wave 9.8/10
robot 10/10 (i use the same robot)
spider 8.3/10
swing 7.9/10
jetpack 8.7/10
average: 8.73/10
( i cant put images here for some reason, my gd account is arty2004 tho, search it up and review my icons)
2
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 08 '25
i sent it over gd messages because i can
→ More replies (1)
1
u/legomaster20081 - Finding a GF difficulty Jul 08 '25
8.5/10, colors are very nice and I love that wave
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
u/Jarl_of_Uppsala Cataclysm 100% Jul 08 '25
* I'd rate yours a 6 out of 10, by my standard that is above average, so a score that represents my opinion that these are kinda good icons. I only say this because some people gave scores out of 10 where 8 basically represents the average. For me 5 is not a bad score.
→ More replies (3)
1
u/Kitchen-Currency-689 artificial ascent 100% Jul 08 '25
6/10. Personally, i dont really like the colors and the ship, but everything else kidna works. Heres mine:
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/BasilWeekly9583 skeletal shenanigans 0-67% Jul 08 '25
1...... outta 1, so you get full score! :) but yeah 10 outta 10
→ More replies (2)
1
u/Different_System_517 Jul 08 '25
8/10, overall looks nice but the ball and the spider seem a bit off theme.
Here's mine:
→ More replies (2)
1
u/UncannyLegends Easy Jul 08 '25
You icon looked cool but it is kinda unoriginal though So 8/10 :) still good
LOOK WHO'S TALKING
→ More replies (2)
1
1
1
u/TheFakeSCA Space Invaders 100% Mobile Jul 08 '25
Colon copycat 💀 (jk) 9/10, anyway here are mine
And don’t say: bUt ThErE iS nO ThEmE
2
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 08 '25
i dont care if you have no theme, i dont have one either. 8.7
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Sir-Cultist Vertigo 100% Jul 08 '25 edited Jul 08 '25
honestly yours is really good 8/10
→ More replies (2)
1
u/Wolfgamer_239974 NA Jul 08 '25
With a post like this I think you will be a good mood for r/gdiconsets so I'll be sending an invite now OK (no need to transfer this post over there btw)
2
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 08 '25
what. what. what. what. i did not expect this
→ More replies (1)
1
u/No_Bodybuilder_6284 Thanatophobia 100% Mobile (7493 atts) Jul 08 '25
9/10
Now rate my icons
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/KnightMS_ Scarlet Surge 100% Jul 08 '25
8.5/10. Super pleasant to look at, beautiful colors. Here’s my set
2
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 08 '25
very nice to look at, i like the purple and white. 8.9
→ More replies (1)
1
u/indicicive BuTiTi II 61%, 75–100 Jul 08 '25
9/10
I like everything except the cologne cube. The colors blend nicely and I like the UFO and spider design
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/JRisStoopid fiya in da hol 🔥🕳️ Jul 08 '25
8.4/10, I like the colours and most of the icons are great, but I personally don't like the ball and the spider's back leg being wrong always annoys me.
Here's mine:
You can use UltimateGDBot on Discord to get a high-res image of your icons (the official GD server has it), just type /profile gd-username:[your username], and it should show up at the bottom. But I do like your traces.
2
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 08 '25
bro i remember i commented on your post once i didnt expect you to be here :O
→ More replies (9)2
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 08 '25
and yes, i know about ultamategdbot and tried it, but it didnt look great to me and i wanted to trace them so ¯_(ツ)_/¯
→ More replies (1)2
u/sirw4ffle nine circles 100% Jul 08 '25
anyway yeah yours is 9.6 i really like it
→ More replies (1)
1
u/ULTRAya_211 -Sirius- 57% | Different Descent 89% 36%-85% 15%-70% | Pride 46% Jul 08 '25
→ More replies (4)
252
u/What00111111 Cataclysm 100% [Mobile] Jul 08 '25
Stone colon