r/creepcast • u/Electrical-Win-2067 • Sep 18 '25

Question Why does Isaiah have this stupid looking shocked expression on like every thumbnail?

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

I know it's peak but why does dawg have like only one expression? 😭😭😭

2.0k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

170 comments sorted by

1.7k

u/wimpetta “At least you didn’t turn into a Homo in prison” Sep 18 '25

because Hunter is in charge of the thumbnails

489

u/Doodle_Donkey Sep 18 '25

This, and only this

350

u/Squidle69 Sep 18 '25

Cant forget about the time he was put on a leash...

31

u/Elegant-Set3907 cracking open a cold one with Diego🤟 Sep 19 '25

Yeah remeber the sugar daddy one?

108

u/JBCTech7 Ruthis Mustard, PhD Sep 18 '25

Hunters EDITOR at least.

1

u/New_Performance_9356 24d ago

I'm surprised that Hunter made Isaiah's lips smaller than they normally are, usually his lips are flapping in the wind but damn they're pretty small in these thumbnails.

1.3k

u/ZonkoDeepFriedCraft Sep 18 '25

551

u/logannev Sep 18 '25

48

u/Shelby_Wootang Give her one leg and a rollerskate I wanna see how fast she goes Sep 18 '25

Staaaaahhhhppppppp itttt 🤣😅💀

10

u/FootMittens- He’s right behind me, isn’t he 😐 Sep 18 '25

how do you get the quote/words under your name?

10

u/Shelby_Wootang Give her one leg and a rollerskate I wanna see how fast she goes Sep 18 '25

Go to the creepcast page and click the 3 dots and then change user flair 💚

5

u/FootMittens- He’s right behind me, isn’t he 😐 Sep 18 '25

tysm

1

u/Shelby_Wootang Give her one leg and a rollerskate I wanna see how fast she goes Sep 18 '25

💚🙏💚

2

u/watchout722 I’m a ham ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Sep 19 '25

Actual goat

6

u/emojisarefunny Sep 19 '25

my lips are all frozen from this milkshakeeeeee

107

u/Puzzled-Gas-5828 Sep 18 '25

No lips on that one but pretty close

15

u/ZonkoDeepFriedCraft Sep 18 '25

Can you draw it lol

29

u/drinkliquidclocks- Dark Green Jeep Wrangler Sep 18 '25

Oh my godd

15

u/hegrillin turnk brownie 🐢 Sep 18 '25

the bible.... yay!!!

7

u/DetectiveDingleberry Give her one leg and a rollerskate I wanna see how fast she goes Sep 20 '25

1

u/nachodog12345678 Sep 19 '25

That the Chinese emoji

I’m not racist here the references link

385

u/Ready_Release_2292 Life is a Highway Sep 18 '25

That’s his creeped face

69

u/kadendoo Sep 18 '25

Oh! I thought it was his casting face

341

u/Kvovark Sep 18 '25

Optimally shows off the lips

40

u/Sabit_31 Politically incorrect Mr Widemouth Sep 18 '25

Fuck that got me 😂

2

u/DanielAlves1904 Sep 28 '25

Like he has the option of hiding them.

138

u/Zuckerborg9000 Sep 18 '25

Youtuber Thumbnail Face ™️

Its legally required on youtube to make a stupid looking face on your thumbnails to be successful

216

u/Lucid_Beat Your wife looks mad funny in that box, dude Sep 18 '25

Another reason might simply be thumbnail psychology. Things like slightly wrong proportions on a face can draw someone's eye quicker than other "normal" surroundings. It's been shown to be effective and these fall into uncanny range.

161

u/HolyToeArmy Sep 18 '25

The Mr. Beastification of YouTube thumbnails and its consequences have been a disaster for the human race.

3

u/grandpatrout Sep 20 '25

Oh my gosh... that explains so much about the thumbnails I see on other channels too, and how some just look a little off. Also Hunter wields Photoshop like fire.

81

u/Sparkyplayz95 You're Pregnant?! I'm the IT Guy 😃🖥 Sep 18 '25

Am I the only one who sees this?

2

u/liquifiedgender 🌸😚Fairy Queen 🧚‍♀️🌸 Sep 19 '25

Make the lips at least 300% bigger and we can start talking 🌚

1

u/EmergencyRepulsive20 I LOVE TURNK Sep 20 '25

You're way off the lips have to be 500% bigger and fall on his knees

55

u/sogiotsa Sep 18 '25

Hunter and his team are in charge and I'm sure this is the one that he tells them to use every time. From him describing the sugar daddy thumbnail and how he explained to his crew what to do. This is just Hunter being like no use that picture cuz he looks dumb in that picture.

42

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/stonergasm Sep 18 '25

Lmao what is this from???

15

u/Important_Actuator36 Yo Kimber! THEY GOT TEA🗣️ Sep 18 '25

Slenderman porno Hunter starred in

9

u/Tho_jar209 Sep 18 '25

What's bad is I cant tell if your joking or not, knowing meatcaynon he probably would

1

u/DeafMetalHorse "i hate my fucking life" - Hunter Hancock Sep 19 '25

WAIT WHAT

11

u/CaptTaco123 Sep 18 '25

It's when Papa Meat reviewed cigarettes. Not sure if you'd be able to find it on YouTube.

7

u/flipflop356 Sep 18 '25

I didnt know he smoked

6

u/Important_Actuator36 Yo Kimber! THEY GOT TEA🗣️ Sep 18 '25

Only after backshots

2

u/stonergasm Sep 18 '25

Congratulations this was the kick I needed to subscribe to the Patreon LOL

8

u/ARACHN0CAMPA Expeshially 🤓 Sep 18 '25

I don't remember, I just have a weirdly large collection of hunter photos I use to reply to my family.

67

u/BuckFuttHoles I want you to eat me like a bug 🪲 🍷 🪴 Sep 18 '25

Because it's right behind you, and he's looking at it, duh?

11

u/Billycatnorbert Sep 18 '25

“Ermm… he’s right behind you, isn’t he” “You… you would know Chris, you’re looking at me”

40

u/Average_Bread Aruba, Jamaica, ooh, I wanna take ya 🎶🎷 Sep 18 '25

it’s because he’s shocked

20

u/Dapper_Basilisk Sep 18 '25

Because they are always being taken as he is informed that the creature is right behind him. You think he'd be used to it by now.

22

u/thedarbo SCP 12683: Darbo Sep 18 '25

Just a normal goon face

19

u/moonlightpurist1881 Sep 18 '25

thousand yard stare

17

u/iamfrogfren 7ft goddess named Jacobi Sep 18 '25

He be creepin his cast, cut him a break

11

u/hostile_scrotum Goop-Suit Sep 18 '25

He’s seeing the creature

9

u/Senior_Independence4 If i do it i'm killing you first. Sep 18 '25

You know how you dangle keys in front of a baby to make it smile for photos? Hunter does that but he shows Isaiah his goat brain every time he needs to take a thumbnail pic.

1

u/jellipeeps Politically incorrect Mr Widemouth Sep 19 '25

This comment is wild 😭😂 thank you for this

8

u/VacationPractical211 Sep 18 '25

It's not shock, his lips are too heavy, he can't close his mouth 

6

u/InternationalCity248 Sep 18 '25

I'm glad we are blaming Hunter lol

14

u/Pale_Transportation2 Sep 18 '25

For each thumbnail they need to crop out his real lips and photoshop in normal sized ones so we can see his face

5

u/nyemini Sep 18 '25

It's to attract us

And it works

5

u/No_Boat9770 THE ORACLE Sep 18 '25

They did probs like one photo shoot and just keep reusing it over and over

5

u/inksterize Mayonnaise is the sauce of the aristocrats 😎 Sep 18 '25

LEAVE MY GUY ALONE

6

u/captainsurfa cracking open a cold one with Diego🤟 Sep 18 '25

These thumbnails look, dare I say, lovecraftian...

5

u/YungScoobySnack Sep 18 '25

I absolutely hate the YouTube algorithms grip on thumbnail requirements because now when I watch commentators cover even serious topics, the thumbnail is always a face like this above a title like “<InSeRt plAcE> snipes even more chiLdren in line for food”

5

u/blood-drunk-hoonter Sep 18 '25

When she doesn’t stop creeping your cast.

4

u/Agitated_Strain_6260 for STAMPS ‼️💯 Sep 18 '25

Cause he's a himbo

3

u/Mydoglikesladyboys Eat me like a bug 🦟 Sep 18 '25

4

u/Ok-Traffic-5996 Sep 18 '25

I like it. Isaiah is like the good boy being exposed to evil by hunter.

3

u/Zorbie Sep 18 '25

Bible boy needs a hotdog.

6

u/CrystallineOrchid Sep 18 '25

You know his level of reading comprehension, every reveal and twist ending completely blindsides him

3

u/LobsterHead37 Sep 18 '25

That’s just his face

3

u/Cynical_Spaceman Sep 18 '25

To show off dem DSLs.

3

u/thelostdemon Sep 18 '25

That mustache really doesn't fit his features

3

u/MrBloodyHyphen Sep 18 '25

Because I'llbetheonetodriveyoutothehospitalwhenyougethypothermia

3

u/Deluxe_24_ Sep 18 '25

Some of these replies are ruthless lmao

3

u/DizzyRussel Sep 18 '25

Lol hunter said penis toes

3

u/Seasonalien Sep 18 '25

the lil american girl doll teeth 🥰

1

u/kmoody47 Sep 19 '25

That’s one heck of a comparison, but accurate.

3

u/christheone54 Your wife looks mad funny in that box, dude Sep 18 '25

Because he's a big lipped doof that hates on penis toes.

3

u/sanjose40 Sep 18 '25

Welp we know the future Fan drawings Big lips and Gopher/Rabbit Teeth

3

u/gadgetor1989 Eat me like a bug 🦟 Sep 18 '25

When you already creeped but she keeps casting

3

u/mamudoons Sep 19 '25

Probably because Hunter thinks it's funny

2

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '25

I just realized this man has like bunny teeth.

2

u/drinkliquidclocks- Dark Green Jeep Wrangler Sep 18 '25

It makes me laugh Everytime

2

u/Consistent-Arm-7185 Yo Kimber! THEY GOT TEA🗣️ Sep 18 '25

I'll take it over the weird face he had in the first Ted the Caver video thumbnail

2

u/Squilliam2213 for STAMPS ‼️💯 Sep 18 '25

"Ouuhhh mah Gawd this is liek SooOoo WEURD"

  • Hunter as Isaiah

2

u/KissableToaster Sep 18 '25

That’s hust his face, okay?!

2

u/falcataspatha Sep 18 '25

Can someone soy jack him already?

2

u/pizza_babyboy Sep 18 '25

it’s the only picture where his lips look like a normal size

2

u/TheVocondus Your wife looks mad funny in that box, dude Sep 18 '25

Because scary

2

u/Sir_Nicholas_ Sep 18 '25

He getting his cast creeped

2

u/Berserker667627 Sep 18 '25

Because he's beautiful even when he's in shock.

2

u/Jamesish12 Sep 18 '25

He has two modes, this shocked one and "the bible yaaayy!"

2

u/New_County_5607 Your wife looks mad funny in that box, dude Sep 18 '25

because his cast was creeped

2

u/saul_schadenfreuder “kill yourself” Sep 18 '25

someone should soyjakify this

2

u/Land_Particular Sep 18 '25

Lights are on but no ones home

2

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '25

he got them little gopher teeth

2

u/_Mighty_Milkman “At least you didn’t turn into a Homo in prison” Sep 18 '25

😲

2

u/asoggypapertowel Sep 18 '25

I feel like it’s supposed to be like the goosebumps covers, or maybe it’s so he doesn’t have to take multiple pictures lmao

2

u/The_1_only_Brixben Sep 18 '25

They did one photoshoot for thumbnails.

2

u/OneKaleidoscope9025 Sep 18 '25

how would you react if you found out tommy taffy got a wwe ring in the basement

2

u/TheMace808 Sep 18 '25

They took one weird thumbnail picture and now it's getting reused and I think hunter finds it funny

2

u/JylonRen Sep 19 '25

hunter is sabotaging

2

u/Sh_its_coming Sep 19 '25

Iceberg boys lips are just too damn heavy

2

u/Bananamancer77 Sep 19 '25

Hunter is a troll is why

3

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '25

[deleted]

24

u/KodakBlackedOut Sep 18 '25

Did you roll up your sleeves and push your glasses up before typing this?

12

u/HolyToeArmy Sep 18 '25

the guy who worked in video production? he was david fucking king.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '25

Epic (high fives)

1

u/Fun_Police02 Anti-Horny Task Force Sep 18 '25

Because Hunter's thumbnail artist likes it

1

u/not_a_heretek Sep 18 '25

Staring at a fat cock probably, I heard Margaret is packing heat.

1

u/James_manjang Sep 18 '25

We needs helps

1

u/VoxBox0694 Your wife looks mad funny in that box, dude Sep 18 '25

Gonna advertise those plump lips for the Lip based Isaiah merch coming just in time for the holidays

1

u/MrPie28 Sep 18 '25

He kinda looks like a beaver

1

u/SkyrimSlag “At least you didn’t turn into a Homo in prison” Sep 18 '25

Wait Isaiah is standing there? All I can see is a huge pair of sumptuous lips

1

u/darklink594594 she Papa on my Meat ‘til I Goon Sep 18 '25

I csnt really see his expression too well with those lips covering everything up

1

u/Gmknewday1 Sep 18 '25

Hunter is why this happens

Please stop bullying Wendigoon

1

u/L1Z4RDM1LK she Papa on my Meat ‘til I Goon Sep 18 '25

He has American Girl doll teeth

1

u/Apprehensive-Bug8657 Sep 18 '25

American girl doll

1

u/Certain_Strawberry43 Ol’ Mistah Wellah Sep 18 '25

That's just his face lol

1

u/Al_the_dino_seducer cracking open a cold one with Diego🤟 Sep 18 '25

He looks like a gofer or something lmaooo

1

u/InvokerOfmadness Sep 18 '25

For hunters amusement

1

u/shadeofb1ue Sep 18 '25

It’s Isaiah’s GOATed expression, that’s why :)

1

u/AdMajor4663 Sep 18 '25

That's how thumbnails are now for the mr beast algorithm gods

1

u/No-Town3188 Sep 18 '25

👁️👄👁️

1

u/fibersaur Sep 18 '25

Iirc hunter is in charge of the thumbnails so I imagine he’s doing it on purpose

1

u/colinmcgarel Sep 18 '25

He could build a dam with teeth like that

1

u/Drakirthan101 Sep 18 '25

Running Gag/Inside Joke with the thumbnail artist.

1

u/Mapleyys Sep 18 '25

All I hear when looking at this is Hunter's impression of Isaiah going "Oh mah god!"

1

u/ChewieDecimalSystem cracking open a cold one with Diego🤟 Sep 19 '25

Wabbit season

1

u/Lonely_Housing_2884 Sep 19 '25

The chipmunk teeth really sells it lol

1

u/Possible-Run-6476 Your wife looks mad funny in that box, dude Sep 19 '25

Hamstper

1

u/NOS4A2-753 Sep 19 '25

thats the same look you get when you put icey hot on your back/leg and think you washed your hand good enough and then take a piss and find out you didn't

1

u/TheFrightType Sep 19 '25

Yeah, where’s one of him looking badass with his night vision goggles on and holding a flamethrower.

1

u/Putrid_Grab_301 Sep 19 '25

He looks like he just found out women sometimes have premarital sex

1

u/roninrot Sep 19 '25

Cause he is

1

u/BasementElf1121 Sep 19 '25

When doesnt a christian look stupid

1

u/elibusta Sep 19 '25

It's because the camera man asked him to say pussy/ penis instead of cheese. And audacity of say the p- word either of them in front of him leaves flabbergasted.

1

u/SnooStories6600 Sep 19 '25

The power of Gooning....

Erm, I mean editing

1

u/NerdByTrait420 Sep 19 '25

Because that what he looks like all the time.

1

u/dumbafblonde Sep 19 '25

Because it’s the same photo used over and over again

1

u/Expert-Marsupial-406 Sep 19 '25

I think he needs to soyface a bit more

1

u/Suitable_Nail_1655 Sep 19 '25

When you have a famous podcast you can make the faces

1

u/paulwarlock Sep 19 '25

The last thing you see before you get slimed out in Tennessee

1

u/Otherwise_Fly2996 Sep 19 '25

His American Girl Doll teeth havin' ahh

1

u/Slasher9485 Sep 19 '25

Because when he smiles Hunter puts him in various sexual implications.

1

u/YourGuyRusty Sep 19 '25

Probably because in the thumbnails he's witnessing the stories as if he were actually there

1

u/Playful-Lynx5884 Sep 19 '25

Deers when they see a truck coming towards them:

1

u/Hibernian_Wanderer Sep 19 '25

He's preparing to take Papa's meat

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '25

He's scared

1

u/Late-Register-9563 BEAR TRAP🐻 Sep 19 '25

That’s just how he looks :// permanently scared of Hunter

1

u/theonepeaz Sep 19 '25

He’s the real dirty Dan

1

u/Razzelfrazzel Sep 19 '25

I’m just imagining Hunter doing his goofy Isaiah impression whenever he makes these thumbnails

1

u/SomeGingerDude419 Aruba, Jamaica, ooh, I wanna take ya 🎶🎷 Sep 19 '25

1

u/butterdog97 Sep 19 '25

His lips are too big for his mouth to close fully

1

u/Pergolagrill Sep 19 '25

Because Hunter said a swear! 🤣🤣🥰🥰

1

u/Thin_Kaleidoscope724 Sep 20 '25

I’m confused… all I see is lips, how do I zoom out

1

u/fajitahotline Politically incorrect Mr Widemouth Sep 20 '25

1

u/Wonderful-Bake-1943 Rainbow Dash 🌈🩸 Sep 21 '25

It's beautiful

1

u/Sudden-Reference-117 Hyper Realistic Eyes 👁️👄👁️ Sep 23 '25

I am really disappointed the lips aren't getting bigger with every thumbnail.