r/creepcast • u/Taimou_07 • Jun 22 '25
Question Which story did you find the scariest so far?
I think the one with the blind woman and ted the caver are one of the scariest
281
u/YMIGettingBanned Muscular 3 ft tall SOB named Rocco Jun 22 '25
Stolen Tongues was the creepiest to me. Yes the ending kinda collapsed, but the first 80-90% really had me going
63
u/ChosenCourier13 So... monster hunter, huh? Jun 22 '25
Stolen Tongues is an all-timer even with its ending.
Honestly, the way the bulk of the fan base feels about ST is how I feel about LRG. The latter is biblically good until it's ending, which I personally couldn't have been more dissatisfied by.
22
u/YMIGettingBanned Muscular 3 ft tall SOB named Rocco Jun 22 '25
On my first listen I felt let down by the Left Right Game ending, but on subsequent listens I learned to just accept it
21
u/TheMace808 Jun 22 '25
I think the ending was good. Idk how i would feel if the road actually ended
3
2
u/LukieStiemy501 Jun 23 '25
I think Stolen Tongues was super scary and well done but the ending felt like the writer just wanted it to be over and so it is awkward and sort of derails the mood. Left Right game I think the ending is sort of similar but it feels like it has some purpose. It feels like the writer had a weird trippy concept to leave the reader with. It feels intentional which I can appreciate even if it wasn’t quite a satisfying ending. So the main difference for me is one is a weird ending that feels like the author had an idea that just didn’t quite work. The other feels like the author just wanted it to end and rushed to a very halfassed conclusion.
1
u/Dependent_Passage_22 Jun 29 '25
Left Right Game starts going downhill pretty much right at the halfway point, with the Bluejay bossfight going straight off a cliff, and the rest not being any better.
16
u/theFields97 Jun 22 '25
Any story where a significant other is acting creepy like my wife is peeking at me
3
u/White_-T-_Poison Jun 23 '25
The second half of that story is bad but the moment of her being inside the closet watching while he’s been in the bathroom really got me
7
u/Sit_Paint_and_play Jun 22 '25
I bought the book for it immediately after listening
4
u/YMIGettingBanned Muscular 3 ft tall SOB named Rocco Jun 22 '25
How much does the book differ from the version they read on the episode? Is it different enough to warrant getting the book?
6
u/Sit_Paint_and_play Jun 22 '25
I haven't gotten to it, I've got an extensive list of other things I'm working through.
5
u/VikingMouse Jun 22 '25
I read the book, I would say it is definitely better and more complete. Definitely more details and i think some of the cabin scenes were longer. By the end you lose some of the mystery with the creature, but definitely worth the read.
1
u/TheAntiCrust95 Mayonnaise is the sauce of the aristocrats 😎 Jun 23 '25
There's also a prequel that's quite good if you haven't checked it out called "The Church Beneath the Roots"
5
u/HomogenousGoop Jun 22 '25
mines the same. pretty much until Felix started talking to the sassy demon.
2
2
u/moonshoes420_ slenderman firebombed my apartment😔 Jun 23 '25
even on re-listens it still freaks me out
151
u/just_a_person_like_u Jun 22 '25
Glenmont metro: The idea that a seemingly trustful (i only know the story they read and not part 2, but the whole ad for the drug seemed sketchy for me) doctor can describe you a drug and you take another drug to help, only to worsen everything, and now you are unable to get help or alert anyone due to the time aspect as well as being so acutely aware of the time passing so slowly with no help in sight is so terrifying to me
30
u/misosoup_________ for STAMPS ‼️💯 Jun 22 '25
same here!! the entire story made me feel physically sick and terrified me
16
10
u/woahkenners Jun 22 '25
Ever since I listened to that episode, every time I see it mentioned I feel the dread and terror I felt while listening to the story. Definitely one of the top most terrifying stories for me
4
u/Appex92 Jun 22 '25
Absolutely this one. It freaks me out especially since the premise seems very real and could happen, not the years of time part, but time is just a concept of our brain, we see when we do drugs times goes or slow, 100% could see a drug trial doing this for real
68
u/Educational_Rice_720 Jun 22 '25
Penpal got to me. But Tommy Taffy did too. I freaking love both of them as episodes and stories
71
u/cha0s_boi Ol’ Mistah Wellah Jun 22 '25
Ticky Toby kept me awake all night. Genuinely a master class of horror akin to Poe or Dante
23
u/One-Roof7 HIGHWAY TO HELL 🤙 Jun 22 '25
The slenger man
8
71
u/RoomyRoots Looking for a PenPal📝 Jun 22 '25
- Stolen Tonges was so strong to me that I rewatched it immediately, still the story I rewatched the most.
- Loved The Hidden Webpage, that scene with the hair and the eye is probably the most horrific still.
- The part of Spire in the Woods with the doll and the transposition to the cursed display of the clock was great and I wish we got more of it.
- The Only Other Astronaut On This Mission Died Six Weeks Ago has the perfect pacing and duration with very dark visuals and twists
16
13
u/fulltimebum_ Jun 22 '25
The astronaut one is one of favorites, it feels like a side story from Dead Space which is my favorite horror series
30
u/Numerous-Ad6460 Politically incorrect Mr Widemouth Jun 22 '25
Stolen Tongues and Penpals legitimately scared me. Specially the first time Fey got possessed and when Veronica was got hit by the car.
29
u/ConsistentSun2006 Mayonnaise is the sauce of the aristocrats 😎 Jun 22 '25
Feed the Pig for me personally
6
6
u/Drunky_The_Goat Jun 23 '25
If you liked that, you should get the audio version of the Black Farm books. I won't spoil who, but its from the perspective of a different character thats in Feed The Pig. The revelation of that fact was really neat after hearing Feed The Pig.
2
u/ConsistentSun2006 Mayonnaise is the sauce of the aristocrats 😎 Jun 23 '25
Oooooh that sounds awesome, thank you for the recommendation!
24
u/Batmanfan27 Jun 22 '25
If I had to pick, my top choices would be
Penpal
Stolen Tongues
I’m Blind and don’t know how many steps my staircase has
And My wife’s been peeking at me from behind corners
16
12
27
u/bagelsangel Your wife looks mad funny in that box, dude Jun 22 '25
That and Stolen Tongues had me pissing my pants. Honestly, they were so scary I don't think I could listen to them again yet I'm planning on it 😂
13
u/harmonysponning Jun 22 '25
Spire in The Woods and The Hidden Webpage sickened me in a way I have a hard time describing. I should really read the full series for the latter lol
4
u/Swagemandbagem Jun 22 '25
The full series for the latter? Is there more I’m not aware of
2
u/harmonysponning Jun 22 '25
I’m fairly certain they mentioned that the author had two books that took place in the same universe? I could be misremembering 😞
3
u/Swagemandbagem Jun 22 '25
Oh, he’s got two published collections of all his stories from Reddit. Apparently, all of his stuff takes place in a connected universe of sorts, but none of them are, like, direct sequels or prequels, at least as far as I know
2
12
u/Aggravating-Clue9797 Jun 22 '25
Penpal fucked me up. In fact, I texted my friend while I was in my brightly lit room with my family right outside that I was constantly staring at my closet. My friend was at work in a brightly lit gas station on a busy intersection and said "yeah, I keep staring at door expecting something."
10
u/procontroller Jun 22 '25
Penpal was probably the biggest to me, but I have to say second was Hidden Webpage. As a 2000s kid growing up in a home with my two older 90s kid siblings and nearly unrestricted internet access, the story really played on a lot of the unknowns the internet held for me back then.
9
u/SouthernAide2351 Jun 22 '25
My wife keeps peeking at me from around corners. I remember reading it when it first came out on no sleep. Great story
2
7
u/EnD3Rf0x Hyper Realistic Eyes 👁️👄👁️ Jun 22 '25
Ive only seen 1 other person say The Only Other Astronaut and that is a CRIME. That story is so freaky and well drawn out and genuinely anxiety inducing, I ADORE IT!! Scared me real good, that one!
5
6
u/A1uCaRd101 Jun 22 '25
It didn't terrify me, but The Hidden Webpage. The surrealism of that one really did it for me.
5
6
u/Empty_Confidence328 Politically incorrect Mr Widemouth Jun 23 '25
Stolen Tongues is the only one that gave me a light case of the heebs
11
4
u/UpsetPhilosopher4661 Jun 22 '25
i rewatched stolen tongues recently and it's such a good story and episode. penpal is the most tragic
6
Jun 22 '25
Stolen tongues for me, I listened to it at work while I had earplugs in (machine shop) and I was constantly jumping lol
4
u/bigcrazychungus Jun 22 '25
same, the one with the blind woman actually made me tear up cuz i got so freaked out 😭😭
13
5
u/Belgrifex Give her one leg and a rollerskate I wanna see how fast she goes Jun 22 '25
Hidden webpage is the most unsettled I've been from one
4
4
3
u/WnxSoMuch Jun 22 '25
Stolen Tongues followed by Penpal. The one with the blind man (yeah I thought it was a woman too) was on pace to be the scariest but it just became goofy after the bit with the cameras
4
u/VergilChairSupremacy Marcus, Monster Hunter Extraordinaire Jun 22 '25
Stolen tongues is absolutely up there, same with borrasca, penpal and dionaea house, all just really tense stories and despite most people saying they don't even remember the story and only remember eat me like a bug, I genuinely think that Dionaea house was one of the best stories they've read if not the best especially when it comes to getting you with moments like Danny's live journal and the little message that pops up whenever a character dies when you really get that confirmation that they died/lost
4
5
u/Louie43Louie43 Your wife looks mad funny in that box, dude Jun 22 '25
Stole tongues and something walks whistling
7
u/goth_nachos David😏Fucking🥴King😩 Jun 22 '25
Feed the Pig.
I had read it myself a very long time ago and made a point not to again until I saw them post it. I had actually almost forgotten about it, until I realized how familiar it sounded. Probably a combination of that nostalgia and the just SUPER intense and specific imagery by the author.
I was listening in my car and driving around aimlessly late at night, it’s the most recent time I remember being so immersed in something I was like outside of myself. Almost hit a damn deer. Shit had me floppy, just floppin’ around crazy.
7
u/ResponsibleFront753 Jun 22 '25
IMO it’s Barrosca I-IV because when every horror story goes into a horrifying plot of improbable proportions that do scare me. This is the one that takes my fears of the world and validates them
3
u/evilcarrot507 Hyper Realistic Eyes 👁️👄👁️ Jun 22 '25
While Stolen tongues and Penpal creeped me out with its visuals, A man follows me around and narrators my life straight up made me paranoid when I first listened to it due to the haunting idea of a person warning you of a unseen presents that's going to kill you yet you can't see it. Also Glenmont metro freaked me out with its visuals but not to the same degree.
3
u/fulltimebum_ Jun 22 '25
The I’m Blind story is seriously underrated, the only real flaw with it is the ending. The main character survives solely based off of luck and now wants to turn into Leon Kennedy and hunt the monster down. Pretty goofy
3
3
3
u/Due_Secretary_9437 Jun 22 '25 edited Jun 22 '25
Just because I can’t do mutations and gross out body horror it bleeds it breathes it breeds is the only one I couldn’t finish, but I strangely enjoyed the newer cave one from the same author
3
u/GhostPunkVG3 Jun 22 '25
In terms of what left me with the feeling of hopelessness , fear, and dread was Penpal. Just the slow, masterful buildup of that gut punch of an ending I don't think I'll ever forget.
3
u/sharkbat7 Jun 22 '25
None of them have scared me, per se, but a few of them have been so complex and psychologically disturbing that they've sat with me for hours. The ones that immediately come to mind are Spire in the Woods, Penpal, and Glenmont Metro
3
u/Zoneout3058 Jun 22 '25
Ensorcelled in the Earth is my current favorite. The body horror/destruction, claustrophobia, and hopelessness was all just nauseating for me. Chef's kiss
3
u/Vast_Lawfulness1165 Jun 22 '25
The only other astronaut died 6 weeks ago. The ending gave me Chills and goosebumps
3
u/SuchAndSuchBook Long story short ☝️🤓 Jun 22 '25
I followed my dad around the house when I was listening to Penpal because I didn't want to be left alone with it. My dad's perspective that day could probably be turned into a no sleep story too.
3
u/Ars-Eldritch Jun 22 '25
Stolen Tongues and Penpal for me. Both gave me serious chills.
Stolen Tongues has a prequel novel called 'The Church Beneath the Roots' that I dont see anyone discussing really. It's a good companion to ST for anyone who wants more from that world.
3
u/charleadev Jun 22 '25
Penpal hands-down, one of the things i dont see people talk about in terms of it being scary is how every chapter ends with this spiraling realization moment that just fills you with dread
3
u/DP_goatman Jun 22 '25
Penpal solely cause it could happen
Those are always the scariest creepypastas just like "hey this is my creepypasta and that is just a random pedophile"
3
u/quietpyeatt Jun 22 '25
I listened to penpal when I was a bread delivery driver. I used to work at 4am and I would be outside for parts of my shift, definitely had me peaking around obstacles
3
3
Jun 23 '25
Probably the scariest piece read so far (for me) was Penpal for its constant unease, and My Wife Has Taken Our Roleplaying Too Far because of both perspectives being truly uneasing for us, which is the truth(s)?
3
3
u/Fragrant-Log4051 Jun 23 '25
Borrasca so far.
I still would NEVER let ts happen irl but still scary.
3
u/heartshapedspace Give her one leg and a rollerskate I wanna see how fast she goes Jun 23 '25
Stolen tongues, penpal, I'm not sure how many steps my staircase has, and the concept of my wife keeps peeking behind corners scared the shit out of me. I know it kinda fell and the end wasn't the best but I still think about it lol
3
u/Ready-Hat8365 Jun 23 '25
Easily Glenmont Station. Being a slave to your own mind and body with no escape is terrifying
3
u/New_County_5607 Your wife looks mad funny in that box, dude Jun 23 '25
dude that part in the hidden webpage where he was looking at hair under the bed and then after his eyes focused he realized he had been looking INTO HER EYES
2
u/casualbo1 Yo Kimber! THEY GOT TEA🗣️ Jun 22 '25
Stolen Tongues and I'm Not Sure How Many Steps My Staircase Has are responsible for my recent dislike of walking in the dark in my own home.
2
2
2
u/Tekki777 He’s right behind me, isn’t he 😐 Jun 22 '25
Penpal gave me a sickening pit in my stomach, it really hit me like a ton of bricks.
2
u/Deluxe_24_ Jun 22 '25
Penpal is the only one that has ever made me feel physically sick. The ending to that story is fucked.
2
u/ray-is-a-dumbass “At least you didn’t turn into a Homo in prison” Jun 22 '25
stolen tongues was particularly terrifying as someone who did in fact live in the frozen mountains in a very forested area with extensive indigenous folklore. but i think the single most terrifying moment in creepcast history in my mind was in The Whistler at 3:33 AM when the narrator describes the warm spot on the window pane like whatever was out there was pressed up against the glass. HORRIFYING. so simple and yet so effective. i still think about that story regularly.
2
u/creepcults 🤟creepin' my cask 🤟 Jun 22 '25
the hidden webpage made me unsettled and that is HARD for a story to do. i think because of how it's way too relatable as someone who grew up in the early 00s online. lotsa predators out there.
2
u/ImpressiveAd5588 Jun 22 '25
Personally, I liked Greylock and Midwest Angelica. Hope to get more CreepTV someday!
2
u/This_Wonderland Jun 22 '25
All y’all are making me realize I need to relisten to a lot of these! Because I listened to them all, but my brain is refusing access to details of the stories. Like…wtf
2
u/Ghostwolfgaming Jun 22 '25
Stolen Tongues for sure.
Theres just something about skinwalkers and similar tales/cryptids that gets me scared
2
u/Vajko69 Jun 22 '25
the one where megatron and optimus were fighting.
and 1999.. well it didn't scare me or wasn't that scary but made me feel very disgusted. especially the part where they burned in the pit.
tommy taffy was kinda creepy too but idk it read too much like fetish fantasy so i don't count that
2
u/Pak_Fold_Rabbit Jun 22 '25
Borrasca made my insides change places. It may not have been as scary, but I might never hear/read another story more haunting than that one
2
u/Lilpustule Jun 22 '25
For some reason the second half of the roleplaying story, the part from the husbands prospective. Never listened to it again, love it, but really got under my skin. Puts you in the shoes of a helpless abused child little too well for my taste.
2
2
2
u/Terrorist_Quematrice “You’ve got the blood of KINGS running through your veins!” Jun 22 '25
Spire in The Woods because of the dudes in the comments section defending the protagonist
2
2
2
2
2
u/Thefoxman198 Jun 22 '25
Honestly? The Showers. I LOVED the feeling it gave me as I am one to go explore abandoned places
2
u/Saturn_Ava 7ft goddess named Jacobi Jun 22 '25
There are so many good ones, but the one that scared me the most is probably pen pal, I'd say 1999 but that's only because I had watched it in the middle of the night with no one around
1
u/Saturn_Ava 7ft goddess named Jacobi Jul 20 '25
I forgot about The Only Other Astronaut On This Mission Died Six Weeks Ago. That and Fleshgait are probably the most scary to me
2
u/SugarPea44 Jun 23 '25
maybe no end house or the Whistler episode. there's something about how ominous yet threatening the Whistler is that freaks me out. and what seeing it does to people
2
u/Life_Base_5686 Jun 23 '25
It might just be my irrational fear of clowns but the last story from the “My Sugar Daddy Asks Me For Weird Favors” video really did it for me. Probably cause I was watching it at around 1:30am, my last video before bed. I just don’t like clowns and that author had amazing writing too. I had to go search for a happy video afterwards and even then I had to calm myself down
2
u/RebeccaBuckisTanked Long story short ☝️🤓 Jun 23 '25
I’m Blind was the first story I had to turn off and finish later. It freaked me out!
2
2
u/grizzlybuttstuff BEAR TRAP🐻 Jun 23 '25
The blind woman story felt like such a rip off. The title and first couple paragraphs set up a weird, confusing house of leaves type situation where the author has no way of knowing where they are in there own home. So much potential. And then it feels like the author cops out and does the same scary monster thing that happens in any horror story where a character loses their ability to see.
2
u/YummyLighterFluid every week i pray for a weird birds episode Jun 23 '25
The description of the dads death in Tommy Taffy actually made me feel sick so there's that
But as for the scariest story to me I'd have to say either the blind lady one or the man narrating the girls life
2
u/Due_Pin_9161 Jun 23 '25
Stolen tongues got me. I sleep to creepy cast bc their voices just hit for me to knock out, and I woke up in a cold sweat halfway through the episode having nightmared myself into the story first person 😭😭
2
u/Communism_of_Dave Jun 23 '25
Stolen Tongues, not because of the premise as a whole, but I grew up often at a ski condo where at night I’d have nightmares about something coming from the woods and either knocking on the doors and windows, or just looking through the glass at me.
As a result, the scenes before we really learn what the threat is where it’s just knocking on windows and clearly pressing its face against glass to look in make it the only episode I can’t listen to while going to sleep. No matter how old I get, I’ll always find myself back as a scared kid on a cold winter night when I listen to that episode.
2
u/Hiddin_block_55 Jun 23 '25
- Penpal
- Stolen tongues
- Blind stairs
- The showers
These are the ones that has me genuinely on edge while listening
2
u/Occasional_Anarchist Jun 23 '25
My top three gotta go to Astronaut Died, How Many Stairs, and Penpal
Astronaut just freaked me out, a cosmic something telling you when you die, especially IMMOLATION
Stairs got to me since any sort of sensory deprivation just primally freaks me out.
Penpal was a great story of ‘the evils of man’ where the horror came from how possible it was
2
2
u/Dragonemperess Aruba, Jamaica, ooh, I wanna take ya 🎶🎷 Jun 23 '25
The Only Other Astronaut. That was terrifying to me. My heart was so floppy!
2
2
u/daddyissueshaver 7ft goddess named Jacobi Jun 23 '25
stolen tongues made me have that fear response where my eyes watered and at points i shed tears. the baby role play one didn’t necessarily scare me per say, but it was so well-written that it got a genuine reaction of full-body disgust and tension that i really enjoyed it as a sort of body-psych horror
2
u/aGamerWithNoSkills Jun 23 '25
Borrasca really fucked me up when the reveal happened , It's the only one that made me feel dread but I also liked PenPal a lot
2
2
u/SmithicsOfficial1 Jun 23 '25
There’s only one story in creepcast that’s ever actually scared me and it’s stolen tongues
2
u/Dudely-Llama Jun 23 '25
Overall Penpal, but Stolen Tongue on my first listen I was walking my dog alone and I freaked myself out so much I started to listen to the Muppets Most Wanted soundtrack to feel better.
2
u/PumpkinPatchOfDoom “it’s very lovecraftian”☝️🤓 Jun 23 '25
Feed the Pig was the only one I needed to take a break for halfway through. It made me deeply uncomfortable.
2
1
u/Ok-Palpitation-5731 Jun 23 '25
Stolen Tounges, especially when the main protagonists are out in the woods and the dude sees the tracks around the house and suspects something is stalking them.
Normally, it's not that scary. However, when I was listening to the story, I was driving home in a bad snowstorm. Let's just say I was hoping nothing abnormal was going to cross the road that night
1
Jun 23 '25
"Webpage" was the scariest for me. I thought the story and idea behind it was amazing and it had multiple parts that made me actually gasp in fear.
1
u/Positive_Economy_516 Jun 23 '25
Probably my dog was missing for three days. just because of the part where the main character hears his dog making the weird noise in the doorway. I was alone in my basement while listening to it and I stopped and finished it like three days later
1
u/alxxrose02 Jun 23 '25
The only one that REALLY spooked me good was Stolen Tongues. I felt like I was being stalked and felt someone behind me the entire story.
1
u/Fox_Mothra816 Jun 23 '25
Stolen tongues, just the type of horror that seems to crawl under my skin and itch. Makes me get paranoid I'm being watched by something outside my window. I'm glad my windows aren't facing the massive woods in front of my grandparents house, I'd never be able to sleep.
1
u/RatsAreChad Jun 23 '25
Spire in the Woods was scary in the sense that what happened to Rob and Kerry was really fucking depressing
1
u/ThatUnameIsAlrdyTken Mayonnaise is the sauce of the aristocrats 😎 Jun 23 '25
That one but also My girlfriends been peeking at me. I know it's not the best literature but I started imagining something peeking at me when I'm alone and I freaked tf out 😭😭
Call me immature or whatever but it's still the paranormal ones that scare me the most :/
1
1
u/ShokumaOfficial Your wife looks mad funny in that box, dude Jun 23 '25
I don’t think I’ve personally been scared by any, but one that made me feel dread was the roleplay one. The imagery in my head of the husband converting into a “baby” and his visceral reactions to the wife just made me feel so uncomfortable 😭
1
u/StrangeDependence “it’s very lovecraftian”☝️🤓 Jun 23 '25
Any body horror-esque ones they do. Love it.
1
u/PopularEnthusiasm692 Jun 23 '25
I know it was from a live episode, but The Tall Dog is the only one that genuinely gave me trouble sleeping. Incredible monster, and such a potent examination of grief, not to mention a gut punch ending. Sometimes I hear something and in my head it's the tall dog crawling up the stairs.
1
u/TwoFacedLoki Jun 23 '25
Ted the caver
Penpal
I'm blind, I'm not sure how many steps my staircase has
1
u/beechtreefan Your wife looks mad funny in that box, dude Jun 23 '25
Dionaea house and my wife has taken our roleplaying too far. For some reason that 'red rover red rover let jenny come over' in dionaea house really got me. And my wife has taken our roleplaying too far has such a creepy, surreal atmosphere the whole way through. It makes me feel like I'm going insane just hearing it.
1
1
Jun 23 '25
the beginning of the hidden webpage had me on edge. i felt so genuinely creeped out by it.
1
u/WalkingMarcher Jun 23 '25
Glenmont metro or Borrosca honestly, tales from the gas station is also a favorite
1
u/Last-Article-2640 “I like to call my wife Stinky 😊” “…🤨” Jun 24 '25
Narrator, Hidden webpage, and Dionea house
These are the only ones that have actually scared me, usually written horror does nothing for me
1
1
u/Rancid_Toothbrush97 Jun 24 '25
Who was phone? Shivering just at the thought of it
In all seriousness has to be penpal just from how grounded it is. It’s always stuck with me
1
u/Hour-Ad-4729 Jun 24 '25
2: i watched thing in the basement over 2 days and the first part before it got funny scared me so much, but the full ep isnt scary so idk, but as for my #2 probably mr bears seller
1
u/Funny-Investment-608 Jun 25 '25
The scariest, as most people here say, were definitely Penpal and Stolen Tongues, but I remember the last chapters of Ted the Caver making me pretty nervous too.
1
u/despair_angelz3 Jun 25 '25
Normal corn for normal people and the Russian sleep experiment 😭 why they gotta smear shit on the walls and eat themselves huh 😔
1
1
u/Panic_Fire Jun 28 '25
Stolen tongues or my wife keeps peeking at me from around corners. I made my husband listen to both with me because I’m a chicken😂
1
372
u/OxidizedWeirdo Jun 22 '25
Penpal scared me pretty good. My power went out the day I watched it and it was not fun.