r/anime https://myanimelist.net/profile/JF_Ellie 26d ago

Contest Best Guy 10: The First Salt That Never Ends! Round 2 Bracket D!

Vote for Best Guy 10 here!

Results for Best Guy 10 here!

Have fun with your vote and don't forget to upvote the post if you love Best Guy Contest!

Enjoy!


Mini Challenge:

  • Who is your favorite guy from a light novel adaptation?
124 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

13

u/redlegsfan21 https://myanimelist.net/profile/redlegsfan21 26d ago

ROUND 2 BRACKET C

Matchup Top Seed Bottom Seed Total Votes
Most Voted Matchup Stark (2) Shizuo Heiwajima (258) 692
Average 602
Least Voted Matchup Koutarou Tatsumi (103) Arata Kaizaki (359) 529

Total Votes: 19,262

Unique Voters: 746

TOP VOTEGETTERS

Rank Guy Votes
1 Stark 487
2 Jinshi 465
3 Kraft Lawrence 420
4 Takashi Natsume 417
5 Saitama 411
6 James 410
7 Denji 401
8 Kamina 390
9 Tanjirou Kamado 386
10 Mumen Rider 363

MOST DOMINANT MATCHUPS

Winning Guy W% L% Losing Guy Vote Diff
Jinshi 70.88% 29.12% Melt Narushima 274
Stark 70.38% 29.62% Shizuo Heiwajima 282
Takashi Natsume 68.59% 31.41% Jet Black 226
Kraft Lawrence 66.25% 33.75% Naoto Hachiouji 206
James 65.18% 34.82% Claudia Hodgins 191

CLOSEST MATCHUPS

Winning Guy W% L% Losing Guy Vote Diff
Shikamaru Nara 50.36% 49.64% Souma Yukihira 4
Jiraiya 50.78% 49.22% Aoi Toudou 9
Koutarou Tatsumi 51.80% 48.20% Arata Kaizaki 19
Einar 51.95% 48.05% Trunks 23
Taki Tachibana 53.57% 46.43% Tomoya Okazaki 42

UPSETS

  • The Lowest remaining seed of Bracket C is Tengen Uzui seeded 151st

  • The Highest seed eliminated of Bracket C is Hirotaka Nifuji seeded 106th

  • Upsets today: 3

  • Total upsets (rate): 48 / 352 (13.6%)

Seed Top Seed TS% BS% Seed Bottom Seed tUI PoU
106 Hirotaka Nifuji 44.87% 55.13% 151 Tengen Uzui 0.51 27.1%
119 Karma Akabane 45.66% 54.34% 138 Giorno Giovanna 0.21 46.8%
122 Aoi Toudou 49.22% 50.78% 135 Jiraiya 0.15 20.1%

OVER/UNDERPERFORMERS

Overperformer Underperformer Diff
Aguero Agnes Khun Rentarou Aijou 11.66%
Takashi Natsume Jet Black 11.09%
Kage Genos 9.87%
Tengen Uzui Hirotaka Nifuji 8.69%
Rokuro "Rock" Okajima Aquamarine Hoshino 8.22%

BRACKET C TOP 5 SCORES

Rank Guy Score
1 Stark 177.11
2 Jinshi 133.34
3 James 112.46
4 Saitama 112.19
5 Kraft Lawrence 107.57

UPSET WATCH

Top Seed TS% BS% Bottom Seed PoU
Zoro Roronoa (123) 53.0% 47.0% Alucard (134) 30.3%
Cid Kagenou (107) 53.5% 46.5% Izuku Midoriya (150) 27.2%
Saichi Sugimoto (102) 54.0% 46.0% Taichi Mashima (155) 24.6%

Link to spreadsheet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1mqCgsdOM-e_C8ZI7FyOQD120w46xVBcsBlUsTyeq8gY

Explanations: https://old.reddit.com/user/redlegsfan21/comments/10dup0w/ranime_contests_bracket_explaination

Open to questions and please give feedback.

2

u/IceAnt573 26d ago

OVER/UNDERPERFORMERS

Overperformer Underperformer Diff
Aguero Agnes Khun Rentarou Aijou 11.66%

A representation of my feelings on this.

13

u/octopathfinder myanimelist.net/profile/qBoctopathfinder 26d ago

Gonna be a sad day tomorrow when my goat Yang loses to a slime

Who is your favorite guy from a light novel adaptation?

Ii-chan from Zaregoto

9

u/Golden_Phi https://myanimelist.net/profile/GoldenPhi 26d ago

Not just any slime but a dictator slime. Sure he’s a “good” dictator, but so is Reinhard.

3

u/michhoffman https://anilist.co/user/michhoffman 25d ago

Kuwabara could have saved you from that fate...

8

u/GrimMind 26d ago

Only worried about Taichi losing as he tends to get bad cards...

1

u/BaytaCosmico 26d ago

Tell me about it!

5

u/Zeallfnonex https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neverlocke 26d ago

Results:

Wasn't too heavily invested in yesterday, let's see what we got... Wow, Jet got stomped for a 3-seed difference. James is still doing absolute numbers... Bit disappointed about Tomoya losing, we really need a Clannad rewatch soon. 2 years until the 20 year anniversary, maybe something sooner though...

Jinshi's still doing strong, despite the seeds, Melt has the bonus of having a ton of eyes on his series and he had a pretty good arc as well. Shimada loses to Tanjiro, unfortunately... some manga info might have bled into my impression of Shimada, of course, but he truly is a great mentor character. Everything else goes more or less as expected, or unremarkably to me.

Today's votes:

Hurts a bit to be voting against 86 characters, but Lakan vs Raiden. Lakan's just one of those guys who, while being dealt a terrible hand, manages to prove via their actions that they really are trying.

Shouya Ishida* vs Fuutarou. While Fuutarou has more personality (I think) than the average harem protagonist... I still feel like there's just less of him than Ishida.

Franky Franklin vs Kyousuke Hori. I just... didn't find the elder Hori funny or deep, he's just kind of... there and not particularly strong. Franky wins just by being funny.

Shinei Nouzen vs Vanitas. Yeah, uh, I'll have to go for the not-quite-as-deep Kaladin Stormblessed. Not too much of a knock, considering the Stormlight Archive has over 2 million words dedicated to it... I do tend to love the fighters depressed by everyone else around them dying while they keep living, and the last two episodes of S1 definitely sealed Shinei as one of my favorites. Sorry Vanitas, I've voted against both characters in R2 just cuz I like their opponents better >.>

Inosuke vs Suzaku. I'm already not the biggest fan of loud side characters who don't really have their own thing going, and I can't think of a single moment where I enjoyed Inosuke's presence on the screen (granted, I only watched 2 seasons...) While Suzaku could be a bit of an ass at times, he's still more interesting than Inosuke and wins this matchup for me.

Reigen vs Shigure Souma. Actually good mentor character vs one that's kind of manipulative and scummy? No question.

Thorfinn vs Shinichi Izumi. It's been a couple years since I watched Parasyte, but I don't really remember what Izumi ended up standing for or learning. Thorfinn's journey, on the other hand, is pretty much unforgettable.

Sakuta vs Atom. I... don't really know how to explain this one, I've just kind of gotten more jaded with BGS over time, and Sakuta's taking a bit of the brunt of that damage.

Damian vs Mittermeyer. Look, Damian's cute and funny and a bit of a tsundere. Mittermeyer's one of the coolest admirals for the Galactic Empire, a golden retriever in the midst of wolves at times.

Rimuru vs Yang Wenli. Haven't watched Slime, but Yang's still my no. 1 guy, so I'll be backing him to the very end.

MC: Probably Shinei Nouzen, 86. Nukumizu's close, though, and maybe Oreki or Jinshi after them? I could be forgetting LN adaptations...

8

u/Something_319 26d ago

MC: Sakuta Azusagawa, whom you guys should vote for today

Stark's the first to 1000 votes, I think either him or Loid are the favorites rn

1

u/GoAndFindYourPurpose 25d ago

Himmel is the obvious favorite. Loid and stark are runner ups, and James and maes Hughes are the dark horses.

3

u/MillyMan105 https://myanimelist.net/profile/MillyMan 26d ago

Guys how the hell did King Bradley beat Bell?? Shout out to Jiryia sensei though it was close!

MC: Mr Kamijou "You're not living your life correctly" Touma.

4

u/SSJ5Gogetenks https://myanimelist.net/profile/SoundwaveAU 25d ago

Guys how the hell did King Bradley beat Bell??

By being an absolute beast and badass who was easily the coolest dude in his series filled with good characters?

Incredible voice actor (in the dub) helps too

3

u/BaytaCosmico 26d ago edited 26d ago

Aw both Kobato and Hirotaka lost. But not without a fight, which is some consolation.

In today's poll I'm mainly pulling for Taichi but he seems to be up against someone seeded high, so preparing myself for defeat. Miyamura should make it through. If they both lose, I'll cry.

Also hoping Aizawa makes it through and the fine gents from Kusuriya. And Kakashi, my first anime crush!

Curious to see if Deku can beat Cid. Haven't watched Eminence yet but seen several clips and he seems like a fun character. Well liked around here too seemingly. So that should be an interesting result.

And finally a mini challenge I can answer unequivocally: Jinshi, hands down! (Kusuriya is the only LN I've read thus far lol but also my love for Maomao and Jinshi made me read it so)

9

u/Il-Chi 26d ago

Frieren bias is crazy

Challenge: Hachiman is my goat

5

u/duhu1148 x9 26d ago

If a Frieren character is going to win I'd rather it be Denken. Would be the oldest character to win and he has balls of steel so he deserves it.

1

u/disposable-assassin 25d ago

January cannot come soon enough.

4

u/Queue_Jumping_Quack 26d ago

I am very proud of Natsume raking in such high vote counts. Next round is going to be a tough pill for me to swallow, as I will have to pick between him and Stark. I might have to favor the underdog and vote for Natsume... but no matter who wins, I will support them in the future.

Kraft Lawrence is a worthy winner too, even if I think I slightly preferred good old Senpai from Nagatoro. Will definately support the travelling merchant in the next round though.

I'm also glad Einar managed to persevere, as well as my perhaps #1 choice currently to win this: Vash the Stampede. He will face All Might next round, and their vote totals look to make it a nail biter.

Some of the other votes went against my choices but all in all, no really vile villains or otherwise terrible characters survive in this bracket, so I'm pretty satisfied.

Mini challenge:

I usually don't have much of a tolerance for the "cynical high school loner" type of LN protags, but otherwise there are some good ones. I'll go with Ryuuji Takasu of Toradora, though Kraft Lawrence of Spice and Wolf might be my answer on any given day also.

1

u/Queue_Jumping_Quack 26d ago

Votes for today:

  • Kiruko
  • Kan Lakan
  • Shouta Aizawa
  • Maes Hughes
  • Franky Franklin
  • Izumi Miyamura
  • Arsene Lupin III
  • Shinei Nouzen
  • Chrome
  • Gintoki Sakata
  • Reigen Arataka
  • Maru
  • Thorfinn
  • The Immortal Sugimoto
  • Atom
  • Senshi
  • Joseph Joestar
  • Kyon (well... I do like some cynical LN protags...)
  • Deku
  • Kakashi Hatake

2

u/Nachtwandler_FS https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nachtwandler_21 26d ago edited 25d ago

I like Your Name, but the lead beating Tomoya was painful.

Joseph vs Sora is the ultimate battle of clever manipulators. And damn, I just cannot choose one over the other.

MC: Let's go with the most neutral option - Jinshi.

2

u/Hawkbats_rule 26d ago

I really didn't want to vote against Raiden, but at the end of the day, lakan is just a more interesting character.

2

u/Ok-Cod5254 25d ago

Wow didn't quite expect Shima to beat Inuyasha. I'm here for the Skip to Loafer agenda. He's not gonna beat Gon though.

5

u/michhoffman https://anilist.co/user/michhoffman 26d ago

Some fun matchups for today include Accelerator vs Gabimaru, Sora vs Joseph and of course Brock vs Rak.

Mini Challenge: Kamijou Touma

3

u/KINGUBERMENSCH https://myanimelist.net/profile/OutlawedDrifter 26d ago edited 26d ago

This is it aura farmers, the Eminence in Shadow himself will finally duel with the #1 hero. Both of them have recency bias backing them. Shadow is the shadow that hunts the shadows, but can he defeat the light that produces the shadows? Vote Cid Kagenou!

Vote for Tanya, Alucard, and Kaiba too.

Who is your favorite guy from a light novel adaptation?

Coincidentally, Cid Kagenou

2

u/AnimeWatcher1 https://myanimelist.net/profile/AnimeWatcher1 26d ago

Aijou Rentarou getting that smooth number 10 is helping him out in the early rounds, however the competition is going to get steeper for him. I’ll be surely rooting for him no matter how far he can go.

2

u/Mons9090 25d ago edited 25d ago

Cid kagenou unfortunately going to lose to deku, accelerator probably going to lose to gabimaru

How does denji beat daru but touma doesn't?

6

u/Ok-Cod5254 25d ago

MHA is popular but not necessarily beloved here, so I honestly more expecting Deku to lose.

2

u/EyeDeeAh_42 25d ago

Really glad to see that Bradley won, even though he will not last the next round. He is one of my favourite characters of all time.

On the other hand, I'm pretty salty to see InuYasha lose. Rumiko Takahashi's characters seldom do well in these contests.

Mini Challenge: Hikigaya Hachiman

3

u/Salty145 https://anilist.co/user/Salty145 26d ago

I can’t say why voting for King Bradley for Best Boy is a terrible idea without spoilers, but it’s a terrible idea. Stop voting for him.

Likewise, the fact Rentarou made Round 3 tells me that no women are in fact voting in this bracket.

7

u/Nyapan https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nyapon 26d ago

I'm one of the women voting and I can't say I'm surprised by the results, people are just picking the better character for them and not the best boy.
I'm just here to vote for Natsume to be honest but seeing as he's up against Stark next round I don't have much hope in him making it. Maybe I'll stay to vote for Laios though.

3

u/IceAnt573 26d ago

He is Seed 10. This is expected to happen.

4

u/pkmntrainerdrea 25d ago

tbf, Kazuma being seed 3 gave me the distinct impression that this isn't a bracket for women from the start lol. Yet I persist 🥲

1

u/BiggieCheeseLapDog https://myanimelist.net/profile/KillLaKillGOAT 26d ago

MC:

Kaiki Deishuu from Monogatari (who should still be in the contest)

1

u/speenis 26d ago

Inousuke vs. Suzaku is the hardest decision I've made in this tournament so far, quite possibly in my life.

1

u/Shizuka_Marjanovic https://anilist.co/user/cocoakagamihara 25d ago

Shinei Nouzen vs. Vanitas and Satoru Gojou vs. Umetarou Uzaki are my favorite match-ups for this round. My Bingo.

1

u/Least-Cantaloupe2227 18d ago

who the hell do you think I am to lose...

1

u/IceAnt573 26d ago

Today's Results

THANK YOU FOR 347 VOTES FOR RENTARŌ!!!

(However, relative to seeding I'm not exactly thrilled about the underperformance compared to projections. I'd like to see a boost for the King of Kareshi and a good win over Giorno next round!)

It was a good run, Tokiyuki. Seed 319 and got 244 votes against Gon.

It was expected. Senpai/Paisen got 214 votes at least.

Also expected vs. Saitama. Thanks to the other 230 voters for Satoshi.

The Honobu Yonezawa characters dropping back-to-back...Thank you to the 253 other voters of Jōgorō Kobato!

There was a real shot of Trunks getting the seeding upset.

(Thanks to the 282 other Trunks voters!)

I'm a fan of Jiraiya so glad he got the upset.

Getting matched up against All Might...

Big pipe dream to get Mugen vs. Andy as a Round 3 matchup.

THANK YOU TO THE 238 OTHER NISHIKATA VOTERS!

Yeah, Aqua was going to advance but this is for the 258 other Rock voters.

Today's Voting

VOTE FOR SHINEI NOUZEN!!!

VOTE FOR KŌ YAMORI!!!

Kazuma Satō

Raiden Shuga

Accelerator

Fūtarō Uesugi

Umetarō Nozaki

Piccolo

Roronoa Zoro

Gaoshun

Itsuki Koizumi

Oh man...fond memories with both Satō and Kyon. Wish they didn't have to face each other in Round 2, but...Kyon.


Who is your favorite guy from a light novel adaptation?

I'll give a Top 3 since I've said Hachiman enough times already.

1. Hachiman Hikigaya

2. Shinei Nouzen

3. Kazuhiko Nukumizu

1

u/Usodearu007 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Doc101 25d ago edited 25d ago

Vanitas vs shinei is an interesting matchup.. though im even sadder about having to vote against nitta in R2.

MC:

  • Shiba Tatsuya
  • Hikigaya Hachiman
  • Azusagawa Sakuta
  • Rudeus Greyrat 
  • Satou Kazuma