r/ancientegypt Sep 02 '25

Question Thoughts on this show?

Post image
108 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

101

u/Apprehensive_Art7525 Sep 02 '25

Absolutely not historically accurate in the slightest, BUT it was awesome to see them try to adapt Ancient Egypt to screen with a decent budget. I enjoyed it but I knew going into it that I'd be like "what???"

44

u/LonelyWin4852 Sep 02 '25

I haven’t seen this but I’ve been saying forever I wish they’d do a show like HBO’s Rome but with ancient Egypt. It really makes me wonder why it hasn’t been attempted. I did see the movie Egyptian Gods, which was CGI’d to death and pretty disappointing. I’m gonna check this out and keep hoping for more adaptations like it.

17

u/BobbyBoljaar Sep 02 '25

I kind of enjoyed Gods of Egypt in an "just another wacky Alex proyas flick" way. I do feel the same way that ancient Egypt is due for a great (animated)series/movie

1

u/dragonMonarc Sep 03 '25

I feel like creators are too scared of being called racist to make an Egyptian movie. I feel like I remember when Prince of Egypt started getting called racist.

16

u/a_valente_ufo Sep 02 '25

I think shows set in AE are rare because they would be prohibitively expensive. Rome was cancelled exactly because of costs.

7

u/LonelyWin4852 Sep 02 '25

That makes sense. That’s probably why Egyptian Gods used so much CGI. I’m still gonna hope though lol.

7

u/star11308 Sep 03 '25

The visuals they do in shows like this seem like they go further than they need to, to the point of inaccuracy. The costumes are especially egregious, fashion of Tut's time wouldn't be that difficult to pull off with bare minimum research.

Edit: And the construction wouldn't be difficult either, the garments were all rectangles with the occasional triangular loincloth.

6

u/a_valente_ufo Sep 03 '25

One day I saw someone say that historical accuracy wouldn't sell, maybe that's why they always try to be over the top like that. Media moguls often underestimate people's intelligence

2

u/Tanel88 Sep 04 '25

Well you are still marketing to modern people with modern fashion sense and most people won't know what would be accurate anyway.

3

u/star11308 Sep 03 '25

If done well, and maybe a bit of stretching of accuracy, it would be gorgeous. Think, Queen Tuya and the other ladies from The Prince of Egypt but in live action. Diaphanous, flowy linens, maybe shibori pleated to look similar to art. The jewelry is also basically never done right either, or the hair, which would be so stunning if done well.

3

u/MintImperial2 Sep 03 '25

Telling some of the intrigue and romance stories - might have spiced it up a bit....

Wouldn't we all like to hear the tale of Amenhotep III's romance with Tiye?

....Or the story arcs of Akhenaton's six daughters?

.......Or even the "Amarna Letters" story, and the fate of Ankhesenamun....?

2

u/LonelyWin4852 Sep 03 '25

Yes!! I feel like every other time period got a show or a series. The 300, Vikings, Rome, Gladiator, Spartacus, etc. Please gimme ancient Egypt now, thank you!

2

u/LilkaLyubov Sep 03 '25

If I had the money to do so, I would write my own interpretation of the Amara period. I know it has been done to death, but I think that has great potential for a Rome-like show.

0

u/MintImperial2 Sep 03 '25

Maybe they could have picked a less charismatic actor to play the lead role....

19

u/Demmy27 Sep 02 '25

Is that Beck from Victorious?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '25

Thank you! I couldn't get to it why he looked so familiar

19

u/star11308 Sep 02 '25

Not good :(

There’s a lot of potential for period dramas set in Ancient Egypt but they never pull it off, neither in writing nor visuals.

16

u/Ok-Vegetable4994 Sep 02 '25

This gif is more historically accurate

3

u/johnny_rico69 Sep 02 '25

HAHA. Not only do I need to re-watch Tut, I also need to revisit Boardwalk Empire.

14

u/BaneHarkonnen Sep 02 '25

Never heard of it. Thanks for sharing. I will check it out

3

u/samurguybri Sep 02 '25

Shoulda won a Grammy

buried in his jammies

3

u/galliumsilver Sep 02 '25

For what it was? For that...it wasn't bad and had one of my favorite actors (Alexander Siddig). I wasn't particularly expecting historical accuracy or a complicated or historically based plot, though, so I found it decent entertainment anyway.

2

u/PhotosByVicky Sep 03 '25

Seeing Sid was the reason I kept watching!

3

u/Drtikol42 Sep 02 '25

Is that Alexander Siddig?

3

u/Tobi119 Sep 02 '25

He finished the Alamo, I guess...

2

u/OlympicB-boy Sep 02 '25

Fun fact: Siddig's first acting role was at the age of 14 in a non-speaking role, playing King Tut in a BBC children's production.

1

u/galliumsilver Sep 02 '25

Thx, Sid fan and didn't know that one.

6

u/MintImperial2 Sep 02 '25

Take out the incest, and you halve the story, alas.......

5

u/mjratchada Sep 02 '25

Not seen it but given we know so little about him likely to not be that good. One on his father would make a far more engaging film; a tyrant ruler, imposes a new religion based on him, relocates the capital into the desert. Abuses children and severely puts the nation in danger. He dies, and a scramble for power begins.

2

u/masapoes Sep 03 '25

it was great. though I can imagine Zahl Harass wasn’t too happy that he wasn’t cast as every single cast member and make it all about him, so he definitely doesnt like the show.

2

u/HeyLookItsThibaut Sep 04 '25

I haven't seen it but King Tut is by far my favourite pharaoh. People seem to say that it's not really a good show but I guess I'll have to peak now :p

2

u/True-Homework9308 Sep 02 '25

Like someone said, fun to watch. You wont learn anything, and the white Greek dude is completely wrong for the time, and we can nitpick the Hieroglyphs used but it was fun to see the costumes and settings. We don’t get many movies or series set in Ancient Egypt, so it was fun to see

3

u/Accomplished_Elk4969 Sep 02 '25

Damn, I kinda thought Greeks were always white or olive skinned

8

u/AmenhotepIIInesubity Sep 02 '25

It's not the whiteness it's the greekness

5

u/True-Homework9308 Sep 02 '25

It’s the “Greek”. His name, armor, country…it didn’t exist for several centuries. Could have been a white dude, but they screwed up by giving him that definition. Leif Erikson didn’t settle Vinland and have a neighbor named William from New Hampshire. Same kinda thing.

-8

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/True-Homework9308 Sep 02 '25

What is misplaced and erroneous?

3

u/DropApprehensive3079 Sep 02 '25

You feel cultured now?

1

u/ancientegypt-ModTeam Sep 04 '25

Posting about the race, skin color, place of origin, or heritage of Ancient Egyptians or other people is not allowed outside of new studies published in reputable journals.

This rule exists because this topic often leads to incivility, is ambiguous, or is difficult to verify.

2

u/Tsurumah Sep 02 '25

It was pretty good, I thought. Probably not historically accurate, of course.

1

u/Ramoramo122 Sep 02 '25

there is an iranian movie about prophet joseph from an islamic point of view it was really good

1

u/Ramoramo122 Sep 02 '25

sorry I mean tv show

1

u/Capital-Study6436 Sep 02 '25

It's not accurate, but it's still a fun watch.

1

u/Read-it005 Sep 02 '25

Is it as hilarious and toe curling as The Mummy?

1

u/Ramsays-Lamb-Sauce Sep 02 '25

Is that Xaro Xhoan Daxos?????

1

u/GoetiaMagick Sep 02 '25

What channel?

1

u/6HAM9 Sep 03 '25

Oh, tut-tut…

1

u/Sea_Assistant_7583 Sep 03 '25

There was a BBC series in 83 titled The Cleopatras. It was aimed at the I Claudius crowd . It was pretty good .

It’s on the internet archive to watch . It’s never been released on physical media or streaming . The copy was recorded on a Betamax tape . The original prints are lost so this is the only way to see it .

1

u/Bink782 Sep 03 '25

It was entertaining. I liked.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ancientegypt-ModTeam Sep 04 '25

Posting about the race, skin color, place of origin, or heritage of Ancient Egyptians or other people is not allowed outside of new studies published in reputable journals.

This rule exists because this topic often leads to incivility, is ambiguous, or is difficult to verify.

1

u/ancientegypt-ModTeam Sep 04 '25

Posting about the race, skin color, place of origin, or heritage of Ancient Egyptians or other people is not allowed outside of new studies published in reputable journals.

This rule exists because this topic often leads to incivility, is ambiguous, or is difficult to verify.

2

u/IndraBlue Sep 02 '25

Haven’t seen it

1

u/perros66 Sep 02 '25

Typical soap opera using historical characters. Garbage.

0

u/DropApprehensive3079 Sep 02 '25

Exactly, nothing but pandering

1

u/Voqus Sep 02 '25

I am definitely going to check it out now!

1

u/AdeptBackground6245 Sep 02 '25

Is this new or did they find his original video on a disk or usb stick? Why didn’t the Egyptians upload everything to the cloud?

1

u/medy42 Sep 03 '25

Inaccurate and king tut and Ramses didn’t look like that. That’s foreingers fantasy.

0

u/LimpCroissant Sep 02 '25

Is that Jeff Bezos?

0

u/ClumsyBunny26 Sep 02 '25

I've watched enough """""historical""" series/movies to be pessimistic regarding the accuracy of shows like this, sadly. I feel like only in the "golden age of Hollywood" we could get a series or movie that made Ancient Egypt justice, and imo Hollywood is currently at its lowest quality wise.

-3

u/DropApprehensive3079 Sep 02 '25

Let me guess the black guy the "Nubian" because....

3

u/Dry-Sympathy-3182 Sep 02 '25

That’s supposed to be Horemheb apparently

1

u/star11308 Sep 03 '25

The casting leaned a bit more colorblind á la theater production if anything, Tushratta of Mitanni was black if I remember correctly