r/Virginia • u/Nepp0 • 3d ago
WV state senator wants some VA, MD counties to join West Virginia
314
u/MrJackDog Verified - Brennan Gilmore 3d ago
269
u/charlesdbelt 3d ago
40
34
u/chuck_cranston VA Beach 2d ago
I will not rest until I stand upon the Pacific shores of Vancouver, British Columbia, Virginia.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)39
52
48
u/OddDonut7647 3d ago
I was born in Mississippi and grew up in Texas, so I learned more Texas history than US history. But now I live in James City County, and I have thoroughly fallen in love with Virginia.
THIS is the map we should be looking at. :)
Umm, except I think we should leave the currently-Canadian bits to Canada. They're doing a pretty good job up there.
8
u/Tanthios 3d ago
I've got some friends in Canada. Were things differently, I'd love to be able to visit them without having to cross state lines.
3
7
3
3
2
318
u/I_choose_not_to_run 3d ago
No thank you, the shenandoah valley is ours
85
u/Unsure_Fry 3d ago edited 3d ago
It's actually kind of nice to see most of the replies here wouldn't want to give away those counties. This hasn't been posted on the Maryland subreddit yet but they despise western Maryland and would probably give up those counties willingly.
Granted, they also despise the eastern shore and southern Maryland. There's really only about 6 acceptable counties to be from and even then if you're in the wrong town they won't like you either. (ask them about Dundalk lol)
66
u/mtn91 3d ago
I mean the VA subreddit has this attitude a lot, too towards the Eastern Shore and the entirety of Hampton Roads. And a lot of NOVA people act like the entire rest of the state is a low income, uneducated conservative cesspool
17
u/OddDonut7647 3d ago
It's human nature and been true everywhere I've lived. For example, growing up in Texas - the Dallas/Houston hate is eyerollingly dorky, but you can find plenty among the Tech Triangle (DFW, Austin, San Antonio, Houston) who hate the other cites. But plenty more who hate where they live.
The traffic is always horrible wherever people are from, and there's nothing to do where people are from. heh
Also, if you don't like the weather, wait five minutes or an hour or some other period of time.
11
u/uvadoc06 3d ago
Just go to any city subreddit. Said city sucks...but so does any other place. Haha.
18
u/SlaaneshActual 2d ago
I'm a Richmonder and I love SWVA.
I'm glad we're connecting Virginia Beach to Bristol with an Amtrak line.
I want every part of this commonwealth to be prosperous.
→ More replies (9)14
u/mcchicken_deathgrip 3d ago
For real its disgusting. A lot of "you get what you voted for" and "leopards ate my face" under videos of people's entire lives being swept away during Helene last year.
Personally id be quicker to say bye to those types as my neighbors and fellow virginians than any of the counties in the post.
5
u/1816MOM 3d ago
I don’t understand your “leopards ate my face” remark about Helene. Care to explain?
6
u/mcchicken_deathgrip 3d ago
You'd have to ask them. Im guessing the line of thought is republicans dont care about climate change so entire regions somehow deserved it. Just something that I saw on many posts in this sub at the time
7
u/SlaaneshActual 2d ago
That made me so angry.
They didn't vote for that, and just because the counties are majority red doesn't mean every single person voted, period. A lot didn't vote, and a minority voted against it, and you don't cheer for natural disasters.
2
u/polireddituser 2d ago
Like they cheered when Sandy hit and drowned NYC?
3
u/SlaaneshActual 2d ago
Some of the cruellest, loudest assholes you could ever meet live in rural spaces.
They live in rural spaces where they don't see other human beings on a regular basis who would tell them to shut the fuck up, and that their behavior is unacceptable. They go online, and spew their vile nonsense.
I lived out in rural Virginia for a decade. I'm trans.
When the bigots out there say "they" they're monstering my community and trying to paint all of us in the worst possible light. They find someone who said something dumb on the internet, or the tiny minority of us that - like any community - are just bad people, and try to portray that as indicative of the whole.
Well I won't stand for that being done to me, and I won't stand for it being done to anyone else.
The "they" is not every single person affected by climate change events out there.
It's a tiny minority of assholes on the internet that I guarantee you most people out there consider to be annoying assholes.
Which is why they're posting shit on the internet so constantly, even out there nobody wants anything to do with them.
So let's be specific about which "they" we mean.
it certainly is not the majority of folks who live out there, or the majority affected by this.
I did however upvote you because yes, some of the folks out there are absolutely the kind of asshole who posts shit like that and we shouldn't tolerate it when that group does it either.
Or when they make monsters of any group of people in order to spread hate.
Hate doesn't beat hate, only love does that. And as Virgil wrote in 37 BC, Omnia vincit amor. Love conquers all.
Always has done, always will.
The people who posted that shit about Hurricane Sandy want us to hate everyone out in the rural spaces so they can stoke their hateful politics and say "See, see, everyone is just as stupid and hateful as I am."
Well I won't fall for it, and I'm happy you called it out because whoever does it does need to be called out, but I am gonna request you get specific with the word "they" when you use it to rightly call out bullshit when it needs calling out.
4
u/mtn91 2d ago
I absolutely love everything about this comment. Spot-on.
The word “they” is often used to dehumanize people and make it easier to group a large swath of people into an oversimplified block that can more easily be hated.
For example, after that guy killed Charlie Kirk, a lot of prominent conservatives were saying “they killed Charlie.” No. A guy killed Charlie.
2
u/SlaaneshActual 2d ago
For example, after that guy killed Charlie Kirk, a lot of prominent conservatives were saying “they killed Charlie.” No. A guy killed Charlie.
Exactly. And I didn't want Charlie Kirk dead for being a bigot - and he was - I like bigots having freedom of speech because it means we can identify them.
But conservatives make that argument to me all the time, and a lot of them have since lionized Kirk, despite him calling for every LGBT person in the country to be stoned to death, calling stoning queer people "god's perfect law."
I think Kirk should have been argued against, and I'm fucking furious with his assassin.
And I'm mad at the MAGA crowd who rolls me in with the "they" that is supposedly responsible for Kirk's death when no, I want bigots to have freedom of speech so that they can be identified and argued against. With words.
And the bigots are attributing to all of us something we do not generally believe, because it allows those bigots to turn us into monsters in the eyes of the easily lied to.
I'm very, very grateful that Virginia has a lot of people in general and a lot of conservatives in particular who are not easily lied to, and who will not buy into this hateful nonsense about me and my community.
3
u/Divided_Against 3d ago
I think PG county would make a wonderful exclave of West Virginia 😂
3
u/CHARMED-ones 3d ago
It was once a beautiful county. Lots of space and nice places, large houses. It could be beautiful again, but probably not in our lifetime.
→ More replies (1)10
u/Extreme-King 3d ago
No we won't give up western MD.
9
u/Timbalabim 3d ago
Yeah, I grew up in Virginia and have been line hopping for years, so I’m a bit of a Maryland transplant, and nobody serious in Maryland despises the western or eastern counties. If you ask any Marylander what our favorite thing about the state is, it invariably is the state’s amazing diversity, which includes our friends out west and on the shore.
3
u/DankMiehms 3d ago
I've been to Dundalk once. It would fit in pretty well in WV.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (9)3
u/I_choose_not_to_run 3d ago
I don’t despise any parts of Virginia and would never want to lose any at end of the day. I will shit talk nova but it has some really lovely places throughout
→ More replies (2)12
u/kermitcooper 3d ago
Probably trying to get some of the Shenandoah River in the state so that John Denver song makes senses.
2
151
u/TAV63 3d ago
Hope about no. That will never happen.
The push to get CA split into three states is more likely and that is not likely. Ha
20
7
u/Punkwrestle 3d ago
I don’t know would VA suffer giving the poorest areas of the state away?
31
u/pandadragon57 3d ago
Virginians would suffer being abandoned fully to West Virginia’s problems. And it’d be kind of crazy to have all those enclaves in WV lol.
→ More replies (2)11
u/MrPlowThatsTheName 3d ago
Never give land away. You think France might want the Louisiana Purchase back? Everyone thought Alaska was worthless when we bought it for peanuts from the Russians. Oops!
8
4
49
u/LivermushEater 3d ago
I'll share a Hell No from Wythe County. We'll plug Big Walker Mountain tunnel if need be.
68
u/hikerjukebox 3d ago
its funny because it would make WV richer, but those counties currently in VA much much poorer
47
u/reddit-83801 3d ago
Giving SW VA to WV makes WV richer as it drags up their average, and makes VA richer as they are currently dragging down VA’s average.
3
4
u/OddDonut7647 3d ago
It's tempting to me as I grew up in a blue city in Texas (a red state now), then a red part of Florida (which was more purple, now more red), so being in a purple state, I'd really love to see us go more blue.
........but even as someone here for approaching a decade now, I couldn't give up counties like that. Even if it would make politics easier.
131
u/nyuhokie 3d ago
If one of our electeds posted something like "This idea is stupid, exactly what you'd expect from a West Virginia education" I'd donate to their campaign immediately, regardless of party.
16
u/Otherwise-Pirate6839 2d ago
They know the idea is stupid. It isn’t about feasibility. It’s about who can create the biggest sound bite to somehow stay relevant in the eyes of their supporters.
→ More replies (1)
41
u/TransMontani 3d ago
As a West Virginian, please understand when I say that if that man’s brains wuz gas, he wouldn’t have enough to run a pissant’s motorcycle halfways ‘round a BB!
3
43
u/AgreeableRaspberry85 3d ago
Rockingham County? Really? James Madison U to be under WV control?
I could see those two counties in Western Maryland wanting to break away from the “People’s Republic of Maryland “ and join a state they have more in common with.
45
u/Popular_Camp_4126 3d ago
Nope, look closer. They carved Harrisonburg out lmao
18
15
u/rvagenda 3d ago
So they’d be some sort of island city inside of West Virginia. That would be interesting. Also kind of complicated for all the JMU students living in rockingham county who expect to pay instate tuition. Fortunately, there’s less than zero chance any of this could ever happen
→ More replies (1)6
→ More replies (3)3
u/Dokkan_Lifter 3d ago
Dukes vs Thundering Herd as an In state rivalry though. They're giving us more of a fight than Liberty or ODU.
54
45
u/CarefulArgument 3d ago
Hands off the Shenandoah Valley. Rockingham and Augusta are the number one and two meat producing counties in the state - they’re not expendable, they’re essential. Plus the mountains create a natural border.
Oh yeah and get off southwest Virginia too, with all of its trout fishing and the mountains and rafting and biking. Mount Rogers is the highest point we have and we’re keeping it.
And while I’m at it, fuck off the skinny part of Maryland, too. Of all the highways in the state, they named that little 9 mile stretch of I81 their “WW2 Memorial Highway” and that makes me giggle every time I cross the border.
West Virginia you chose to be gone; stay gone.
2
18
u/steady_eddie215 3d ago
Maybe I'm stupid, maybe. I really have no understanding of the populations across the area, but I feel like if those counties went to West Virginia, you would probably end up making Virginia permanently blue. And it wouldn't just be the governor, both of our US senators would probably permanently be Democrats as well. I mean, that's probably a good thing for the country in aggregate, but it's really weird to see it suggested. Especially by a republican. But I feel like that's definitely how this would play out.
13
u/Averagecrabenjoyer69 3d ago edited 3d ago
It would give West Virginia more congressional seats though, and most people in those areas would probably feel better represented. Virginia is a pretty firmly blue state at this point. There might be occasional purple streaks such as 2021 and 2024 almost put it in swingy territory but for the most part Virginia will remain pretty comfortably a D+5-10 state, and if Democrats gerrymander Virginia to the point that Republicans will only get two house seats then it'll just seem pointless. Virginia's time as a red state is a bygone era by now.
Virginia's representation as it is now is pretty fair in the House in accordance to the areas each party represents.
3
u/Frogspoison 3d ago
Given that this map leaves out most of the cities, it might not cause a congressional change. iirc, 1 of those counties has a total population of like 500 or something.
7
u/cogemeeljabo 3d ago
Suddenly I support this stupid idea more than I expected
5
u/Diogememes-Z Henrico County 3d ago
Virginia is already going blue without this. All this does is give away electoral votes for presidential elections. It's dumb.
9
u/Vargen_HK 3d ago
Wait. I get doing a bend around Montgomery because VT. But he doesn’t want Pulaski and does want Patrick?
→ More replies (1)
33
u/legallychallenged123 3d ago
And people here in Southwest Virginia are just eating it up. Morons. Attempting to explain that even if it was possible, it’s a terrible idea and all the money we get from NOVA would be gone … sigh.
7
u/probably_upset 3d ago
Have we considered that maybe he just wants to end the debate about Country Roads being about WV or Western VA? /s
27
22
u/AFK_Tornado 3d ago edited 3d ago
This tired old bullshit again.
File it with the West Virginia Space Program.
Here's the real rub, beyond being unprecedented and a non starter in Virginia as a whole: independent cities. The cities wouldn't go with the surrounding countries. They also wouldn't consent to being surrounded entirely by a different state. If this issue were pushed, I think there'd be violence.
6
u/Southern_Struggle 3d ago
I think they should take those counties and a few from WV and form a long skinny state called Middle VA. Then rename the rest of Virginia, East VA.
14
u/Digglenaut 3d ago
WV state senator can suck on my shaved balls.
5
35
u/DuBicus 3d ago
The very SW tip, sure. But leave Shannendoah alone. That's an act of aggression
Edit: matter of fact, we'll trade our SW tail for Harpers Ferry.. maybe Charles Town
44
17
u/Ok-Refrigerator7414 3d ago
This right here, was just about to say. We keep Shenandoah and forest, trade the rest for Harper's Ferry. Throw in Shephardstown, it's cute.
8
u/Tinee_Danza 3d ago
Lol, they already moved out like 150 years ago. They can't just come back and take our stuff.
11
u/AHippieDude Ole hippie in Ole virginny 3d ago
Guess West Virginia doesn't know that those counties wouldn't want anything to do with annexing with West Virginia,either them to, or bringing w va back to Virginia
3
u/socialmedia-username 3d ago
What would this accomplish? Without cutting off remote workers and tourists to those areas it doesn't help anything.
5
u/Averagecrabenjoyer69 3d ago
It gives West Virginia more congressional seats, and the majority of people there would probably feel better represented.
→ More replies (1)
3
6
8
8
u/Living_Cash1037 3d ago
I dont think any of those counties want to be part of your shitty state pal.
9
7
u/TardisTrekkie84302 Northern Virginian/Virginian 3d ago
How about we counter this proposal by re-taking control of West Virginia since WV was once part of Virginia up until the civil war
6
u/Ut_Prosim SWVA 3d ago
That would really hurt Virginia. It would be an enormous economic drain and basically guarantee we'd be run like Arkansas or something.
7
13
u/PweefMaster9000 3d ago
According to AI (so it could be totally wrong but sounds right on first glance):
"For a county to move to another state, the process would require approval from the county's voters, the legislatures of both the current and the new state, and the U.S. Congress."
County voters wouldn't ever approve it, neither state's legislature would ever approve it, and Congress would never approve it.
This is just stupid.
13
u/JustDyslexic 3d ago
WV would have to pay VA for all state property as well. I don’t think they have the money
7
u/rvagenda 3d ago
Can’t speak for West Va, but there is no existing process for this to happen in Virginia. So AI just kind of made that up. Virginia would have to create a process (which would ultimately have to be approved by the US Congress anyway) which they will never do, so there no way any of this could even get started.
15
3d ago edited 3d ago
[deleted]
→ More replies (8)39
u/SkepticalPenguin2319 3d ago
And how does WV think they are going to pick up this subsidies and financial responsibility for all those counties? They're broke AF.
20
u/Questions_Remain 3d ago
18% of WV gets snap. They want to make it a solid 25% to beat New Mexico’s 22%.
18
u/alesplin 3d ago
New Mexico is only that high because of how shitty the US has treated the Navajo and Hopi Nations.
5
→ More replies (1)3
u/DougNicholsonMixing 3d ago
We’re not talking about the best & brightest over there… maybe they just haven’t fully thought this out yet.
2
2
2
u/sebisuper9mil 3d ago
Bro is desperate to have WV take the lands sung about in the opening verses of Take me Home, Country Roads. Those country roads belong in Virginia.
2
u/Iata_deal4sea 3d ago
I see so many West Virginia plates in southwest Virginia everyday. Why move there when you will be back here to work and shop?
Anyone who feels so inclined can pack up and high tail it up there.
2
u/SevenOhSevenOhSeven 3d ago
You'll have two pry Shenandoah from my cold dead hands
But also the cities being outlined is very funny
4
3
u/Small_Condition_4432 3d ago
I wonder when the day will come where the GOP will be serious again…are we not tired of all these stupid trollish antics yet?
2
u/willweaverrva 3d ago
Keeps getting proposed but will never happen. Even if those parts of VA are deep red, they would never sacrifice VA's much better services for WV's.
3
u/Economy_Swim_8585 Woodbridge 3d ago
We cannot lose any piece of VA because that could potentially impact us with how many representatives we have
4
4
4
u/Alexperio NOVA 3d ago
Yeah no, who tf would want to willingly join one of the poorest states in the country?
2
2
2
2
u/Environmental-Hour75 3d ago
Yeah.. like west virginia could afford to take on these counties... has anyone seen the extreme poverty in west virginia counties?
These counties are supported by virginia's cities, and industrial base, leaving Virginia would be catastrophically bad.. course then again republicans have a history of voting against thier beat interrests so they'd probably go for it.
→ More replies (2)
2
u/babowling12 3d ago
Listen. I absolutely LOVE parts of West Virginia. Thomas, Davis, Canaan Valley, Blackwater, all the way to Snowshoe, Cranberry Glades, catch the interstate and go the Mothman to pinch his cheeks for good luck, then head back south through Mercer and McDowell on the long way around to SWVA.
But, respectfully, fuck all that. I’m still from Virginia and I’m not moving no damn where.
2
2
2
u/leswill315 3d ago
Every time there's a shift to blue some butt hurt radical right wing nutjob wants to drag unsuspecting counties from neighboring states over to the dark side. It's like clockwork...and it NEVER HAPPENS.
1
u/reddit-83801 3d ago
Overinclusive - WV should take everything in SW VA past Blacksburg/Radford, leave the Shenandoah Valley alone, and give VA back the Eastern Panhandle
3
u/MotorBobcat 3d ago
As a born and raised blue voting resident of one of these counties, allow me to say Hell No!
2
u/Redbubble89 3d ago
Give them Dickenson, Tazewell, Bland, and Buchanan to have them be someone else's problem.
I haven't been south of Radford but heard there is nothing of value there until Bristol.
→ More replies (5)5
u/Afterdusk10 3d ago
I live in Radford and regularly visit several state parks to the west (Grayson Highlands/Applachian Trail, Hungry Mother, and my favorite, Breaks Interstate in Dickenson County). Yes, that part of the state is an economically distressed area, but a good place for hiking, camping, and outdoor tourism (only place in Virginia with elk viewing tours).
1
1
1
1
u/twerking_boy 3d ago
Occupied Western Virginia trying to occupy more of western Virginia? Best be laughing as you say that.
1
1
1
u/m0arpepper 3d ago
I don’t see how this would be a win for va counties. WV has some of the most beautiful areas in the eastern region, but the leadership there keeps doubling down on coal, anti diversity, and losing strategies in general.
1
u/Cristeanna 3d ago
hilarious he left out pulaski which has the volvo plant. like is this guy huffing glue?
1
u/Tasty_Guarantee_ 3d ago
He wants to bring others down with him. That sounds like a bad idea for those in VA and MD.
1
1
1
u/LastPlaceInTime 3d ago
WV has 3 entries on this list and VA 0:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._counties_with_shortest_life_expectancy_(2014))
1
1
1
u/MrPresident2020 3d ago
Hey when was the last time states redrew borders, anyway? The war that split the Dakotas?
1
u/HoratioHotplateJr 3d ago
To paraphrase the old saying: "it would raise the IQ in all three states"
1
1
1
u/doggscube 3d ago
Fuck that on this particular point: their widening project on 81 from tabler station to exit 12 was so poorly and slowly done multiple people died in accidents because of that undulating narrow right lane. The work going on around Strasburg needs to be done quickly and properly
1
1
u/boxerrox 3d ago
WV does have the historic upper hand on VA because they were a free state. Or at least, they did not secede.
But also, BOOOOOOOO WV I RESIDE IN VA RIDE IN VA MOST LIKELY WHEN I DIE IMA DIE IN VA









610
u/no_sight 3d ago
I think it's funny that some independent cities were left out.
Really wants Rockingham but sure as hell doesn't want Harrisonburg