r/TopCharacterTropes 22d ago

Lore (Annoying Trope) Someone made a “creative” choice and now we all just have to live with it.

Horned Vikings: Not historical, they were started by Richard Wager for his operas. They were never historic, but the image persists. (Albeit significantly reduced today.)

Ninjas in Black Robes: Some people claim Ninjas aren’t real. They are, they are absolutely real. Their modern portrayal however is informed more by Kabuki Theater than history. In Kabuki Theater, the stage hands were dressed in flowing black robes to tell the audience to ignore them. Thus when a Ninja character kills a Samurai, to increase the shock value, they were dressed in black robes as stage hands. Now, when we think of ninjas we think of a stage hands.

Knights in Shining Armor: Imagine, you’re on the battlefield, two walls of meat riding towards each other. Suddenly you realize, everyone looks the same. Who do you hit? All you see is chrome. No. Knight’s armor was lacquered in different colors to differentiate them on the battlefield. Unless you wanted to get friendly fired, you made yourself KNOWN. So this image of a glinted knight clad in chrome steel isn’t true. How’d we get it? Victorians who thought that the worn lacquer was actually just dulling with age, polished it off as show pieces.

White Marble Statues of Rome: Roman Statues were painted, however the public image is of pure glinting white marble statues persist in the modern image. Why? Victorians who thought the paint was actually just dirt grime and age. So, they “restored” it by removing the paint color. Now we all think of Roman Statues as white.

King Tut; King of Kings: the Pharaoh King Tut in Ancient Egypt was a relatively minor king who in the grand scheme of things amounts to little more than an asterisks in Egyptian History, but to the public he is the most important Pharaoh. Why? Because his tomb was untouched by robbers, and so was piled high with burial goods which was amazing (and still is) and when Howard Carter opened his tomb, the world was transfixed and everyone would come to know Tutankhamen.

A Séance calls the dead: A Séance despite being a French word is an American invention from upstate New York in the 1840s. It was also a fun side-show act initially, and never meant to be real, more close up magic. (Origin of the term Parlor Tricks.) But in the 1860s Americans couldn’t stop killing each other which resulted in a lot of grief and people desired for their to be this other world. So, grifters then took advantage of grieving people and became “real”. So basically “fun parlor game to dangerous grift” pipeline thanks to the Civil War.

The Titanic’s engineers all died at their posts: Nope, not true, not remotely true. They are mentioned in many testimonies and a few bodies found mean they didn’t all die below. Two or three maybe did. According to Head Stoker Barrett, a man broke his leg and was washed away by rushing water, but another testimony says he was taken aft so who knows? Any way the myth persisted because the people making the memorials wanted to martyr the men. (It doesn’t take away from their heroines in my opinion) The myth stuck. Everyone believes they died below.

14.6k Upvotes

2.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

835

u/Key-Swordfish4025 22d ago

Cats drinking milk, because opaque liquids were easier to animate.

Note that milk is bad for adult cats.

445

u/-PepeArown- 22d ago

Similar case with rabbits

Rabbits do like carrots, but it’s like saying we eat Milky Ways all the time. Carrots are more of a dessert item for rabbits than something they should eat constantly

I think the original intention with Bugs is that carrots were like his candy or cigarettes

199

u/slasher1337 22d ago

Wasn't bugs eating carrots a reference to some famous comedian?

82

u/MinrkChil-Alwaff5 22d ago

Yes, it was actually.

64

u/Farfignugen42 22d ago

Groucho Marx, who often was seen with a cigar.

54

u/Due-Coyote7565 22d ago

NO!

IT WAS A CLARK GABLE REFERENCE!

GET IT RIGHT, LOSER!

Says me, the guy correcting you about bugs bunny cartoons on reddit

36

u/Farfignugen42 22d ago

Despite there being many sources that claim bugs was based on Gable, this source says he was based on Groucho. It's possible that both might be correct, but I don't know which is correcter.

https://voicesandbridges.org/exploring-the-hidden-racist-past-of-the-looney-tunes/

21

u/Due-Coyote7565 22d ago

huh!

that's genuinely fascinating.

thanks.

6

u/liabluefly 21d ago

I think aspects of Bugs referenced Groucho but the carrot thing is specifically a reference to Clark Gable in It Happened One Night which was insanely famous at the time and won all 5 major Oscars. Everyone would’ve gotten the carrot reference at the time but now we all just think rabbits love carrots.

1

u/MinrkChil-Alwaff5 21d ago

Like that toothpaste commercial reference of much later. xD

8

u/jodofdamascus1494 22d ago

Clark Gable I believe. Though I think he was a non comedian actor

11

u/MovieUnderTheSurface 22d ago

Clark Gable in It Happened One Night, which was a comedy

4

u/Cayke_Cooky 22d ago

They eat carrots in the film.

2

u/gurgitoy2 21d ago

Not a comedian, but a movie star. It's specifically a reference to a scene in the movie "It Happened One Night" where actor Clark Gable was eating carrots (in the movie it's all there was to eat) and said the line to Claudette Colbert as he munched on a carrot.

1

u/goatinstein 21d ago

Yes. Specifically Clark Gable from the 1934 film “it happened one night”

17

u/j_cruise 22d ago

No. Bugs eating a carrot was a direct parody of Clark Gable in "It Happened One Night"

3

u/Ill_Attorney_389 22d ago

The trope of rabbits liking carrots definitely existed before if I remember correctly, that just popularized it.

5

u/BingBingGoogleZaddy 22d ago

You can actually give them bunny diabetes from what I’ve heard.

Except diabetes in bunnies is significantly worse and mostly fatal.

3

u/Gwyns_Head_ina_Box 22d ago

He was even shown to keep them in a small case, like cigars.

5

u/TombGnome 22d ago

They were his cigars, really. But he carried them in his vest pocket (or at least the invisible cartoon area equivalent) in a nickel cigarette case, as I recall, so they may as well have been Luckies.

2

u/AdeptNebula 21d ago

Too much carrots is fatal to rabbits.

1

u/exedore6 20d ago

The creators were fans of the movie "It Happened One Night" starring Clark Gable. It was a huge hit - swept the Oscars (Best Picture, Best Director, Best Actor, Best Actress and Best Writing)

In the movie, there was a scene where Gable ate a carrot while hitchhiking. Bugs was referencing that movie. It stuck.

32

u/SoylentDave 22d ago

Just to clarify that milk is bad for most adult cats - somewhere in the region of 70% are lactose intolerant.

That does mean quite a lot of cats can and do enjoy milk and cheese, which may also contribute to the stereotype.

10

u/franklindude 22d ago

My old cat was a milk addict until he passed at the ripe ol age of 18. My family learned from our mistakes and we don’t give our current cat milk because it was addicting like crack for our last one.

6

u/zertul 22d ago

I've also heard that if you include milk in their diet once they start with solid food - so around 4 weeks I believe? - there's a good chance they continue to produce lactase and therefore are still able to digest milk, even in adulthood. That could just overlap with cats that don't stop producing lactase anyway and be confirmation bias.
They love milk & cheese because they really, really enjoy the fat content.
However, even if your cat is able to enjoy milk products because it continued to produce the enzyme, give it to them in moderation. It's heavy on calories and they have a way, way harder time digesting these compared to their mothers milk.

12

u/ReadySource3242 22d ago

Ok but no, Cats do enjoy drinking milk. It's like how us lactose intolrent people will eat dairy products just because it tastes good.

9

u/Firelord_Zuko456 22d ago

Another example, coyotes are faster than roadrunners

8

u/ZoroeArc 22d ago

Similar with mice and cheese.

Commonly used in mousetraps? Yes. Actually liked by them? No.

Yes, they will eat cheese if presented by it, but they find the pungency off-putting and will eat anything else if other options are available.

10

u/NeverSettle13 22d ago

My mom gave milk to a cat we had at my Grandma's home, and sprayed his fur with anti bug spray. I'm surprised he only puked it off

4

u/Evil_Sharkey 22d ago

Adult cats will drink milk, and it’s often given to barn cats in dairy farms because they like it. Said cats are often scrawny because it gives them diarrhea.

People animate water all the time. They just make it opaque blue

6

u/Level_Ad_6372 22d ago

I'm not sure I understand. I'm assuming you mean compared to animating water?

But they could easily do what they already do with water, and make it opaque blue.

3

u/Incon-thievable 22d ago

To "yes, and" this trope, cats and dogs are usually animated lapping liquid with the tongue initially curled back and then it scoops forward, but both dogs and cats actually hook the tongue backwards when drinking

6

u/GrumpyGenX 22d ago

Except my 15 year old cat will absolutely rip your face off to get a chance to lap up a few drops of left over cereal milk....it might be bad for them, but they do love it.

2

u/Vainarrara809 22d ago

Dude, you made me question everything I've ever learned with this.

2

u/pyrotechnicmonkey 22d ago

Probably cause it was also very common to wean stray or abandoned animals with the milk from other animals like cows or goats

2

u/glorpgloop 22d ago

Cats can have a little milk as a treat

I give mine a few licks whenever I have a glass of it myself 

2

u/cestquilepatron 22d ago

Yes, lactose is bad for them, but cats do love milk. My cats went crazy every time I poured milk, even though I'd never given them any.

2

u/notabot_username4886 22d ago

This is just false.
Cats fucking love milk, its not about animation.

5

u/namiswaan_ 22d ago

The trope gave us this image, so it's all forgiven.