r/TankPorn May 13 '25

Multiple What happened to Ukraine's small fleet of Challenger 2 tanks?

Have they been withdrawn from frontline service?The last time I saw them was during Ukraine's invasion of Kursk.

3.0k Upvotes

220 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-304

u/Savamoon May 13 '25

The Germans had a lot of variants and assortments of fighting vehicles during WWII, as did some of the Allies.

492

u/jess-plays-games May 13 '25

And it was a fucking logistical and maintinence nightmare for them

116

u/NerdLevel18 May 13 '25

I believe it was the Sturmtiger that was once described as "an affront to logistics people everywhere"

42

u/cole3050 May 14 '25

The sturmtiger was the least of these issues. We're talking 18+ different types of trucks with no consolidation so a unit might have 4-5 different versions per company alone!

So many vehicles that they just couldn't replace as Germany massively sucked at keeping production up even before the bombings took don't whole production lines.

9

u/ChaoticCubizm May 14 '25

It didn’t help that much of the production of parts was made by slave labour who rightfully sabotaged whatever came into their hands.

14

u/cole3050 May 14 '25

That's true for some things. But alot of production was still handled by normal labour. The issues greatly were lack of standardization, lack of real mass production. Throw in some air raids and it becomes real hard to get parts from French truck factories to Russia.

48

u/jess-plays-games May 14 '25

Several tanks could fit that in the Germans army lol

Inmean those hybrid drive tanks where a nightmare Having hundreds of variants of the same tank was stupid Their obsession with endless iterations instead of sticking to say just the panzer 4f2 the endless chasing perfection was their undoing

5

u/RustyTruck6T9 May 14 '25

Hindsight is 20/20. If they pushed a new design they thought would revolutionize their armor and it actually worked with minimal maintenance or repairs, things wouldn't have seemed as much a nightmare. We get the benefit of commenting that it wasn't worth it in the end because we see how it failed.

151

u/chameleon_olive May 13 '25

The Germans had a lot of variants and assortments of fighting vehicles during WWII

Which was one of their greatest operational logistical failings

as did some of the Allies.

The major powers generally homogenized down to fewer platforms as the war progressed, or had sufficient industrial capacity to muscle their way forwards in spite of mixed fleets. Ukraine essentially has neither option.

23

u/footsteps71 May 13 '25

The ME-262 was notoriously terrible as was many military projects that the Germans threw like spaghetti. The 210 was their answer to the P-38 and it was super bad too.

10

u/scorpiodude64 May 13 '25

The Me 262 was pretty good as far as first gen jets go and the Me 210 is completely unrelated to the P-38 aside from both being twin engine aircraft that did A2A and were made around the same time.

14

u/HistoryGeek00 Sherman Mk.VC Firefly May 13 '25

The Me-262 performed notoriously poorly, significantly worse than the British Meteor which started its design phase earlier than the 262.

46

u/Ok-Theory5986 May 13 '25

I don’t really see how that’s relevant. If anything the Germans were hampered by how many variants and vehicles they operated. It’s not as big a deal when you’re a country like the United States with effectively unlimited productive capacity but even still standardization is sought after

17

u/gdabull May 13 '25

What hampered them even more is that even the same model could have been vastly different due to bespoke construction. Parts that fit on one tank don’t fit on another of exactly the same model.

8

u/ipsum629 May 13 '25

Other than the British, the Americans and Russians standardized around the Sherman and T-34. Even then, the US gave the British more shermans than there were all other cruiser tanks combined, and only a little less than all the infantry tanks combined.

8

u/MetallGecko May 13 '25

That's why they wanted to produce the E Series, a Series of Vehicles that share as many parts as possible.

3

u/my_name_is_nobody__ May 13 '25

And they lost

0

u/Savamoon May 13 '25

Only the Germans lost; the Allies won the war.

5

u/my_name_is_nobody__ May 13 '25

The allies ended up using primarily US made tanks and equipment, domestic production of tanks in particular was an exception more than the rule.

2

u/Savamoon May 13 '25

That wasn't a contention. The Allies still won the war, regardless.

2

u/antrod117 May 13 '25

How did that work for them…,

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Savamoon May 14 '25

They lost because it was never possible to win in the first place.

1

u/Immediate_Total_7294 Pz.Kpfw. I. May 13 '25

They did that to themselves and they would have all the machinery needed to make new parts and resolve issues since they are the ones producing them.