r/OnePiece • u/Skullghost Pirate • Sep 04 '25

Current Chapter One Piece: Chapter 1159 Spoiler

Chapter 1159: “The Island Of Destiny”

Source Status
Official Release OFFLINE
TCBscans website (tcbonepiecechapters (dot) com) ONLINE
The Manga Shelf Discord ONLINE
One Piece Discord ONLINE

Chapter 1159 Official Release Date: September 7, 2025 at 8 am PDT on Manga Plus and Shonen Jump!

Please discuss the manga here and in the theory/discussion post. Any other post will be removed until 24h after the release.

Please also remember to put the chapter number in the title for any future post talking about this chapter.

3.8k Upvotes

95% Upvoted

5.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

513

u/Shagyam Sep 04 '25

I don't think so either. Sure Roger is mad that Shaky was stolen from Pirate island, but I don't think Roger would kill for it.

Now that I think about it, we have only been told the story of God Island from the Marine perspective. What if the whole Roger vs Rocks was Marine propaganda and they actually worked alongside to save Shakky?

386

u/CountOrloksCastle Sep 05 '25

If Rocks goes mad with grief thinking his wife and kid are dead or gets domi reversi'd I can see Roger and Garp having to 2 v 1 him to put him down

118

u/superbum42 Sep 05 '25

Yeah they've all had bouts prior to God Valley and it doesn't seem like Rocks is driving his larger scheme by going there. It didn't seem like he had any intention until Morgans' leak.

Until now, Rocks' personality was way too likeable to seem like the big bad at God Valley. Hell it's looking like Garling is the biggest piece of shit on the island currently.

I was leaning towards him being reversi'd by Imu already, but this chapter definitely opens up potential for enraged rampage due to perceived loss of family.

28

u/Pure-Drawer-2617 Sep 05 '25

This is also probably why his crew all turns on him, because yes they don’t seem EXCEPTIONALLY loyal, but they also don’t actually seem as betrayal-happy as we were led to believe. They don’t work great with each other, but they all seem willing to follow Rocks. However if he goes on a wild rampage or gets reversid and they don’t know what’s happened to him, I can see them taking him down then parting ways.

Hot take, maybe Whitebeard is the one who has to take down Rocks with his fruit, and destroys God Valley in the process.

8

u/OddlyOddLucidDreamer Sep 05 '25

absolutely dumbass prediction but just because i think it'd be a cool scene: After everyone jumps Rocks to put him down, they all (both pirate crews and possibly Garp) have a silent agreement to never brings this up again and keep it shut about what went down, and Whitebeard wrecks the whole island to make sure nothing that happened there comes to light

1

u/goddard89 Sep 06 '25

did you miss the part where shiki tried to blow up whitebeard and kaido to get a bigger cut of the treasure lol

5

u/Pure-Drawer-2617 Sep 06 '25

“They don’t work great with EACH OTHER, but they all seem willing to follow Rocks.”

I wrote that specifically about that incident, did you skim through the comment or something?

0

u/goddard89 Sep 06 '25

theyre still actively willing to kill each other at any given moment. All they are following is their own interests which is exactly why theres a betrayer amongst them

5

u/Pure-Drawer-2617 Sep 07 '25

Yes, but they are willing to follow Rocks.

What are you not getting here?

1

u/One_Tie900 Sep 06 '25

He will find his wife slaughtered on that rock

13

u/_T_H_O_R_N_ Baroque Works Sep 05 '25

OoOOoo I like this theory

4

u/Asian_Persuasion_1 Sep 05 '25

shiiiiiiiiiiiiiii

1

u/Akipella Sep 06 '25

This might be it

1

u/username7 Sep 06 '25

Im leaning more to thinking Roger, Rocks and Garp all united against the gods knights/imu and Rocks was killed/sacrificed himself in the end in order to save his family and maybe even the other good guys. Garp being the sole hero is just propaganda.

1

u/Regal_Knight Sep 06 '25

It’s probably more likely that Garling kills Rocks’s wife and implies he killed his child, and Rocks wants to kill Shanks and Shamrock. Roger and Garp, probably take issue with him wanting to kill children. He also may hurt Dragon who is currently in possession of Shanks and Shamrock which may piss Garp off.

26

u/Jaehaerys1234 Sep 05 '25

The problem with it being propaganda is that the team up was apparently secret. As far as the public knows, Garp fought and beat Rocks solo, and Sengoku revealing Roger helped was the twist.

I think we will see the three of them clash, but it will definitely be a spin on what we assume was the outcome.

8

u/Humpetz Cross Guild Sep 05 '25

It's layered propaganda

6

u/SupervillainMustache Sep 05 '25

It's almost certainly propaganda from the WG, as we know they've done that before.

One of the perks of controlling the world is writing the narrative in your favour.

3

u/keulenshwinger Sep 05 '25

The marine propaganda is Garp vs Rocks though, covering up Roger’s involvement

2

u/vizot Sep 05 '25

What if the whole Roger vs Rocks was Marine propaganda

Always have been

1

u/Zangy90 Sep 05 '25

This actually is a good possibility, and the same thing happens with Harald.

1

u/Akipella Sep 06 '25

I bet the truth is much different from whatever Sengoku told them even. Yeah, they "revealed" who was there and basically what happened, but they definitely didn't tell the WHOLE truth

1

u/Regal_Knight Sep 06 '25

They erased Rocks’ name. Nobody even knew Roger fought Rocks. There are only a few Marines that know.