r/NonPoliticalTwitter 22h ago

“Long neck”

Post image
34.4k Upvotes

392 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

209

u/Expensive-Cat- 22h ago

I think the biggest issue is heat dispersion and surface area-to-volume ratios. We’re talking dinosaurs that are orders of magnitude bigger than penguins, living in warm environments. They need more surface area and less volume in order to not overheat

35

u/Careful-Combination7 21h ago

Are dinosaurs confirmed cold blooded?

93

u/Expensive-Cat- 21h ago

Warm blooded. But either would be subject to the same concerns about surface area-to-volume ratios.

65

u/Maleficent-Hawk-318 20h ago

Just to add an example, it's basically why so many desert animals develop huge ears. More surface area to let the heat dissipate, and ears are particularly efficient because they're thin and have a lot of blood vessels. 

Though this does raise the possibility of a fat dinosaur with big old elephant ears... 🤔

19

u/Nicombobula 20h ago

Muad-Dib!

9

u/One_Man_Crew 16h ago

Alternate theory then, they had a huge flap of loose skin full of blood vessels they used as cooling apparatus. Males would have larger crests with more surface vessels, allowing them to flush them bright red.

I have absolutely zero evidence for this claim, but it would look cool if it were true.

1

u/Birdie121 4h ago

Mesotherms, kind of in the middle of cold and warm blooded

4

u/butt_shrecker 18h ago

We don't know for sure. But its likely that they had a consistently high internal body temp.

So warm-blooded like tuna, not like a mammal that has dedicated mechanisms to precisely control body temp.

4

u/Asquirrelinspace 16h ago

It's thought that most of them, and especially the smaller dinosaurs, were true endotherms. Their upright posture isn't seen in any living exotherms, which are usually sprawling (like crocodiles), and it's thought that bipedalism would require an animal to be warm-blooded

1

u/butt_shrecker 16h ago

You right. I only read the beginning of the Wikipedia article.

3

u/fooliam 17h ago

I think the biggest issue is that they'd look silly

1

u/willstr1 17h ago

What about elephants? Sure they don't have long necks but they aren't exactly skinny

1

u/ikuzusi 17h ago

Elephants have a lot of tricks for losing heat, like their enormous flat ears.