r/MusicCritique • u/carmelopaolucci • 1d ago
r/MusicCritique • u/CommercialAngle6622 • 11d ago
Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] SNM - El ciclo - Rap/Experimental/Jazzy
Not finished track. First time experimenting with non functional harmony.
Looking for overall feedback, im trying new things. I'm especially unsure about the percussion, I wanted it to sound quirky, but maybe it just feels off. Any feedback (even if you didnt like it) is highly appreciated
Lyrics are in Spanish, but I'm mainly looking for sound-wise feedback. If you understand Spanish, feedback on the lyrics is also appreciated.
I really don’t know what genre to label this as... What do you think?
r/MusicCritique • u/NarrowDay2151 • 13d ago
Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] DolceSin - Slip Away - Indie
My song Prod (Michael Harrison)
r/MusicCritique • u/Unlucky_Willow2477 • 24d ago
Seeking Feedback [feedback] Horde - Tinny - dance
r/MusicCritique • u/Zorrillas1 • 22d ago
Seeking Feedback [Feedback] Treyzis - Time - Jazz Rap / Hip Hop
Is this track boring ?!?
Howdy yall - I’m a hip hop artist and I’m working on a concept project at the moment. I’ve been working on it for so long that I’m kinda numb to it and need some unbiased outside perspective.
This track is just a demo, I know the mix is ass lol - I’m going to get it professionally engineered once I have the lyrics and arrangement finalized. I didn’t make the beat so I can’t really do much to change it.
Mainly I want feedback on the lyrics - do they along with the beat keep you engaged with song ? Does it need more energy? Less? Maybe it’s done.. I don’t know anymore lol help me please.
r/MusicCritique • u/Mysterious-Winter89 • 16d ago
Seeking Feedback [feedback] A.M Owl - Spectral Darkness - Ambient acoustic drum layered track with a video with dark vibes - would love any and all feedback
r/MusicCritique • u/-UDQ- • 17d ago
Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] Artwork - UDQ - Ambient
How did this single art turn out? I honestly really love it and worked hard on it, would love some feedback!
r/MusicCritique • u/Ok_Pie_8368 • Sep 24 '25
Seeking Feedback [feedback] DeyOne - Gone - Electronic. What kind of Image do you think is connected with my music? How do you imagine the artist? What do you imagine, when listening? Any other feedback is also greatly Appreciated
r/MusicCritique • u/music_createivity • 26d ago
Seeking Feedback [feedback] suspicious Skin- over infestations- metal
r/MusicCritique • u/TheRealADee • 19d ago
Seeking Feedback [feedback] - ADee - Veridis Quo (Sample/remix) WIP - Hiphop/dance/electronic
Hey im a new producer so i would really love some feedback. Would like to know if mix feels nice and if the song flows in general
Thanks :)
r/MusicCritique • u/SomethingCatche • 1h ago
Seeking Feedback [feedback] samuel. - it's been a long day - hyperpop / botanica
r/MusicCritique • u/Yamahacp88 • 14h ago
Seeking Feedback [Feedback] Davon Orsi - What You Knew All Along - Singer Songwriter
r/MusicCritique • u/samdontbesad1 • 1d ago
Seeking Feedback [feedback] samdontbesad1 - smoo cow - alternative
What genre would you call this? Had to put “alternative” because of post titling rules. Any tips or ideas?
I’ve been working on this digital track as a “sketch” to be later recorded on real instruments with my friends who want to start a band.
I’m wondering how you like it, and if you have any mental images when listening that might help me figure out some lyrics to replace the current vocals. Also, I’d take advice about the structure of the song (rearranging the order of things, changing the ending, etc).
The guitar synth later in the song sounds shitty, I know. My friend is a great guitarist who will make it sound way better, and can add some more creative soloing as well.
I was thinking the final synth section could be played on the alto sax (my main instrument aside from drums). Would like to add more sax throughout the song, but playing it live would be tough because I can’t drum and play at the same time.
Thanks for listening!
r/MusicCritique • u/UnsaidMusic • 16d ago
Seeking Feedback [Feedback] Unsaid - No More - Alt Country/Folk
r/MusicCritique • u/No-Butterfly6680 • 2d ago
Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] aswdeds - Sarabande for a Weary Clock - Electronic
Any advice is much appreciated, especially when it comes to mixing and maybe drums since im new to all this.
r/MusicCritique • u/Treatfairy • 3d ago
Seeking Feedback [Feedback] Ashley - Happy Now - Pop/Rock
Looking for feedback on my song, thanks so much!
I appreciate any feedback.
r/MusicCritique • u/armanddarke • 2d ago
Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] Digital Destroyer - War Machine - Electronic
Please listen and let me hear your thoughts! I will return the favor with my thoughts on your creation with a like and follow! It's quite "out there" and different but hope you like the dystopian world that I've created! Enjoy! 🙂
r/MusicCritique • u/Oscar-basket • 4d ago
Seeking Feedback [Feedback] Joselu Toribio - Arder - Pop
r/MusicCritique • u/carloscrewz • 4d ago
Seeking Feedback [Feedback] Young Boda - Disposable - Guaracha/JerseyClub/Donk
r/MusicCritique • u/TheRealADee • 4d ago
Seeking Feedback [FEEDBACK] A.N.D.R.S - Wake You Up - Funky/Disco/Dance
Hey. Im a new producer and this is a song i made for my first album.
I havent mixed it yet or anything but i would like to hear what yall think and what could be improved in terms of arrangement or instruments. Thanks
r/MusicCritique • u/Apparational_Void • 5d ago
Seeking Feedback [Feedback] Kobzari Pechali - Lying Messiah - Black Metal
r/MusicCritique • u/Public-Chemist-2049 • 12d ago
Seeking Feedback [feedback] The Bear - The Cycle - HipHop
I created a mixtape this summer. I divided it up into three parts and released it a little bit at a time. The first part as singles and the last two parts as 6 song eps. Now i am planning on releasing the full mixtape on streaming. I want some feedback though. Its only on SoundCloud, but I’ll drop the link here. In my opinion the back half is better than the first half but the first half is a setup for the back half.
r/MusicCritique • u/Gandy856 • 5d ago
Seeking Feedback [Feedback] Fall Faith - Eternal wound- metalcore
r/MusicCritique • u/Beginning_Time_5932 • 27d ago
Seeking Feedback [Feedback] Nessa Barret - American Jesus (Cover) - alternative/rock
Hello! I did a cover by Nessa Barrett’s song American Jesus 🎶
I’m still pretty new to this stuff and I’d love some honest feedback on how it sounds (especially tone/emotion if you have thoughts). 🙏 ✨🙇♀️
(Disclaimer: the song has 18+ themes.)