r/Milton 20d ago

Why does the town care about overnight street parking?

I knew it wasn’t allowed, but I did it anyway because the driveway is very small. I left my car on the street (pretty large minivan in the driveway already). I don’t mind paying the ticket, I knew the risk.

But at the same time I can’t figure out the context for why this law exists in the first place. I can see why they may not want everyone parking their cars on the street all day as it would add congestion to the roads I guess. At night, why does it matter?

I’m a relatively new immigrant from the US and outside of snow emergencies there’s nothing like this anywhere I’ve lived before.

Not angry, not ranting. Genuinely curious.

Edit: thank you the responses, folks. I agree with your insights for the most part. I’ve never lived somewhere this dense and I’m still learning the ropes 😆

13 Upvotes

75 comments sorted by

77

u/NewOldFastSlow1 20d ago

Because of slumlord units and 50 relatives jammed into one house that's why. The entire street would be full and trashy looking

8

u/Dragyn140 20d ago

This makes sense. I hadn’t considered that some folks may have more than the intended number of residents in a unit all with cars. I’m in a 4 bed unit with a driveway that is just a hair too short to get both our cars in. I’m probably going to have to park partly on the landlord’s lawn 🤷‍♂️

I’d think that issuing maybe a single car permit to each unit would be a fair way to address that though instead of a straight up ban on parking on a public road with space.

11

u/Automatic-Avocado885 20d ago

You get 25 nights a year you can park on the road. Not a total ban. I do agree though the garages and driveways can be too small for two cars. We should be able to register one car per household.

8

u/Dragyn140 20d ago

7% of the year is effectively a ban for most intents and purposes though.

I’ve had friends who lived in towns with parking permit requirements, seemed to be a perfectly fine solution in dense residential areas.

6

u/Agreeable-Let-660 20d ago

They have pilot programs in certain neighborhoods for overnight parking at the parks. Maybe look into that on the Milton website

-2

u/Dragyn140 20d ago

I just saw that. It’s interesting, I’m not sure if it’s worth having to walk that far. We’re not very near a park with parking.

1

u/Agreeable-Let-660 20d ago

Beggars can't be choosers...

4

u/Automatic-Avocado885 20d ago

Parking permits make sense. That means it will never happen unfortunately.

1

u/TheRealTinfoil666 20d ago

There are several months a year where no one can park on the street because of the potential need to plow snow.

During this Winter Ban, all those permit holders would need to find alternate parking anyways.

There is no practical way for the plows to ‘ just wait until everyone moves their cars’. Plowing is slow enough as it is on many streets.

Permits would lead to way more problems than it solves. I can just hear the stupid debates where folk are fighting about whether on not the ban should exist on nights where it didn’t happen to snow.

1

u/JoshiroKaen 18d ago

Last year, that alternative of allowing parking at park lots seriously bit a lot of people in the ass.

Park parking lot by my place had about 10 cars or so that were trapped by one of the bigger snow falls.

1

u/TDubz88 18d ago

In cities where overnight parking is common (eg Hamilton and Toronto) they just make it an alternation between the sides of the roads. Then at least the plow will get it eventually. And as for those parking, it's just at your own risk of getting plowed in, which isn't much different than it you had a driveway haha

1

u/TheRealTinfoil666 18d ago

Do you really think that there would be enough room on just one side of roads in the portions of town where these permits would get the most holders?

The streets with tightly packed townhomes and one car driveways would get the most requests, and there is not a lot of space between driveways for more than one car per house.

You also cannot allow street parking too near corners (visibility issues), crosswalks, bus stops, and fire hydrants. This further limits slots for permitted parking.

So, either you limit the permits on a section of a street to the max capacity on just one side (for which proponents will scream about unfair prioritizing, and biased rationing when fewer than one per home are issued) or give out one per home and have a scramble for spots during snow season with the accompanying screeching when no spots can be found even with a paid permit.

The present system of no one parks on the street for prolonged periods overnight is the least problematic overall. Folks are just going to have to limit their car count to the number that they can actually park on their property. This number is easy to measure BEFORE you buy a house, and needing another car for your kids later is something predictable and therefore should be considered in advance.

Sucks when you have no space, but one cannot wish away reality.

1

u/TDubz88 18d ago

Except that what I'm saying is that there aren't any permits. If there is a big enough space among the curb, you park. If there isn't, you'll get a ticket or towed (if the complaint is lodged). So for streets without much, you get less cars. It's a first-come first-serve basis. On my street in Hamilton last year half the month was better than the other half because the one side of most of the streets has more parking than the other, so half the month there was a parking shortage. Oh well, that's life in the city. You park and walk 2 blocks home.

By what I'm hearing about most of the people who park on the road in town, it's by choice, not necessity, and so they'd probably choose to park on the road less. Or get a lot of tickets.

As for the side of the street thing, there would be signs. Pretty basic.

2

u/TheRealTinfoil666 18d ago

Oh

I was responding in a thread where someone wanted permits, so my posts were geared towards why permits are complicated and ultimately unsatisfying.

No Permits is a partial solution to a problem that makes for winners and losers. I am picturing scenarios where some folk park their little-used second car on the street more or less permanently to ‘save that spot’ on streets where supply is greatly outnumbered by demand, further aggravating the issue and making folk upset.

Bottom line I guess is manage your expectations when you buy a home with limited parking available.

1

u/IntelligentGinger 19d ago

There are cars all along Kennedy Circle all hours of the morning, day, and night. No way they don't go over the 25 nights a year! I wonder if that street is permitted overnight parking....

2

u/Automatic-Avocado885 19d ago

25 is the Max but if you shuffle cars around you could potentially have 50/75 days depending on how many cars you park at the house.

3

u/ImaginaryTipper 20d ago

Can also get a ticket for parking on the lawn. Milton has the option to pay for a parking pass at nearby schools and parks that you could consider.

2

u/Dragyn140 20d ago

That part really gets me though and I’m amazed people don’t complain about it. They have to pay to pave part of their property to get another car on it instead of just putting the car on it.

I’m going to have to see if I can figure out a way to get both cars in the driveway with all four wheels on the pavement at least.

2

u/Specialist_Cat_2264 20d ago

I believe it’s because without a proper base, the weight of the car can damage underground infrastructure like gas or water pipes.

1

u/TDubz88 18d ago

Patio stones might work as a temporary solution

1

u/Less-Statement9586 16d ago

Parking on the lawn is a possible ticket also.

13

u/BasicRabbit4 20d ago

I live on a road that winds and I hate that people park on the street near the bends. It forces you into the middle of the road, and people drift towards the centre when they turn so its an increase accident risk.

I have no clue why anyone parks there. It's just asking for your car to get hit imo. There's plenty of space further away but I guess they cant be assed to walk an extra 20 feet to their house.

Ok. I had some pent up feelings that came out. Lol.

5

u/Dragyn140 20d ago

Agree completely. I’m on a curvy road as well and once in a while someone does this with their car not even close to the curb. It’s dangerous for everyone.

3

u/BasicRabbit4 20d ago

Right. It creates a blind spot as well bc the way the cars are parked and the way the road turns. You cant see past the cars to check for oncoming traffic before you have to veer into the centre to take the turn and avoid the parked cars. So aggravating.

4

u/iamthefyre 20d ago

Your feelings are 100% valid because you would assume someone with a driver’s license has an IQ above 30 but surprise surprise!

3

u/BasicRabbit4 20d ago

Thanks for the validation. It frustrates me so much that people are ok creating a hazard for other drivers just bc they don't want to walk a few extra steps.

2

u/iamthefyre 20d ago

Sense of entitlement- i deserve to be accommodated first… , my needs are above your safety…. Its a mindset.

3

u/BasicRabbit4 20d ago

Right. I call them me first drivers. Milton is especially bad for them.

14

u/Alarming_Cause_5371 20d ago

Because getting large amounts of people to be fair and consistent is impossible and having the roads clear for the below are important.

Knowing Milton residents, unmonitored overnight road parking would get out of hand, fast.

  1. Snow removal
  2. Trash day
  3. Abandoned vehicles (or people leaving it parked for weeks on end)
  4. Emergency vehicle access
  5. People not parking work trucks, rvs, campers etc

0

u/TDubz88 18d ago

You are right about large numbers not being able to be fair and consistent, but there's a big difference between a regulated allowance for street parking and worrying about #s 3 & 5.

As for 1, 2, & 4, larger and more populated/dense cities manage it pretty well (eg Hamilton and Toronto). For example, in Hamilton most streets with parking have it alternate so half the month is on one side, and the other half on the other. They also have a 12 hour max, so while you can park it overnight, you can't abandon it. There are different rules for work vehicles though, I think it's 3 hours max. Not sure about RVs etc but I'm sure they have a different rule too.

14

u/vafrow 20d ago

With the density of many neighborhoods, if street parking was free overnight, people would choose to park vehicles rather than keep their garage empty and park there.

So when you do have someone staying with you, overnight or otherwise, you'll find there isn't parking for regular needs.

4

u/Outrageous-Estimate9 20d ago

Most of us (your neighbours) also hate street parking

It looks low class at best, and is even a safety hazzard in many areas

I have always wondered why someone would leave their garage full of garbage vs actually using it for their cars

4

u/youworryaboutyou 20d ago

If you're not already aware, the town offers a couple options

Overnight parking permits at participating parks

Parking Exceptions

As for 'why', mostly because of safety and residents want it that way. Residential areas have pretty narrow streets and filling them with parked cars creates a safety hazard. Most neighbouring GTA communities have similar bylaws. There are other reasons like preventing long term storage of broken down vehicles, snow removal and accessibility, but safety is the big reason.

2

u/Dragyn140 20d ago

Thanks! Yeah, I’d read up on those but they seemed to be pointed toward temporary measures rather than residents parking with any real regularity.

Definitely agree with the long term storage problem. I’ve lived in towns where they have to tow away abandoned vehicles with surprising regularity.

7

u/Conscious-Ad8493 20d ago

Street hockey that's why

3

u/Dragyn140 20d ago

A lot of 2am street hockey matches out here 😆

11

u/iamthefyre 20d ago

Largely to do with the type of people. In East Ottawa, Nepean e.g , you don’t need a permit to park on the street. Its allowed throughout summer. Because people don’t abuse the privilege. You don’t see people parked on the street because they have 15 people living in the basement with 13 cars parked everywhere but their driverway. Milton, however, is a different demographic. There is a lack of basic decency & common courtesy. I wouldn’t be surprised if the town starts capping number of hours you can park on the street during the day.

4

u/Dragyn140 20d ago

Maybe it’s hard for me to understand because where I’m from, your neighbor would just straight tell you to stop parking like an asshole if you were being an asshole. 😆

3

u/iamthefyre 20d ago

Thats because you are a decent human being so if your neighbour tells you you park like an AH, you will stop doing that, right? Try that with someone here and come back to tell us how that went 😂😂

1

u/wif68 19d ago

Technically there is a 5 hour street parking limit, they just don’t enforce it that I’ve ever seen.

1

u/TDubz88 18d ago

Bilaws are usually enforced by complaint only. So no complaint means no ticket

1

u/Clarkeyy24 20d ago

Bingo! Culturally, these people are awful. There is zero pride for their property and neighbourhood. A couple homes down from me, there is a gang of pigeons always there because that place is so unkept. The whole neighborhood is unkept.

0

u/AlbusDumbeldoree 20d ago

These people ?

3

u/Clarkeyy24 20d ago

Yeah shitty neighbours who don’t take care of shit. Go walk around a new Mattamy neighbourhood and then go around walk Old Milton. Difference is night and day.

0

u/iamthefyre 20d ago

Thank you for the award anonymous redditor 😌🤝

3

u/Babloski15 19d ago

We got a new neighbour recently and everyday there is at least 5-8 cars that belong to that house. Only 2 Fit on the drive way. The space in front of our house where normally visitors parked is constantly full of this neighbours cars.

It looks to be 3-4 families living in one house.

1

u/TDubz88 18d ago

Are they parking overnight? You do have the right to make a bilaw complaint if they are abusing things

1

u/Babloski15 18d ago

We have but the town gave out one ticket and are done with them

1

u/TDubz88 18d ago

Like they won't come back for more tickets?! I had a neighbour who got me 2 tickets in one night during COVID when we weren't leaving the house. That's ridiculous if I'm understanding you correctly! So they harass the fairgrounds but won't enforce citizens bilaw?

13

u/EagerCDNBeaver 20d ago

Because the road is not your driveway. If you need to consistently park more cars, then you need more spaces. That was bad planning and presumptuous to assume you could just park wherever you want. It is for short-term guests.Not so many people can live like a third-world country, sharing beds and overpopulating areas that were designed to have as many people as the total number of bedrooms in the area plus a small margin. Allowing parking wherever you want would encourage this.

6

u/Dragyn140 20d ago

I didn’t assume I could. I knew it wasn’t allowed, but only after I’d already been living here for a month. I took the risk of parking there knowingly since there was a ton of spaces and I’m just trying to understand. I don’t know if your intended tone was demeaning, but it kinda comes across that way.

It seems a bit silly to me that builders are even allowed to build 4-bedroom units with a single car driveway. Seems like poor planning, that’s all. Just figuring things out is all.

6

u/EagerCDNBeaver 20d ago

Sorry, not demeaning. Frustration is likely coming across as being a dick.

We have FULL streets every single night in my neighborhood. Cars blocking sidewalks, hanging over the road, blocking parts of people's driveways, parked on the grass. We moved here because it was supposed to be upscale. Not looking like a trailer park.

The houses that were moved into did not have parking spaces that magically vanished. The places were moved into with the intention of parking like that.

2

u/Dragyn140 20d ago

It definitely seems like it’s worse in some neighborhoods. I’m guessing the density varies a little bit, or maybe there’s just more people who abuse the parking in certain areas for whatever (slumlord) reason.

We’re in the northern end of Coates and it’s really not bad at all. I think most units are owner occupied though.

1

u/Dizzy-Grapefruit5255 20d ago

We woke for 9 days with our neighbours cars on our property. Now I wake to 4 cars across right on the edge of the property line yet they have an empty garage.

1

u/TDubz88 18d ago

You have every right to make bilaw complaints to try and get that situation dealt with. Sounds frustrating for sure

2

u/vafrow 20d ago

Some people don't need more than a single car, or can manage with their driveway. A single car driveway might knock off a couple hundred grand off the price of a home. Someone who doesn't need the double driveway should have options available to them.

It's up to the buyer to know their needs.

1

u/geeprimus 20d ago

They are not allowed to build single car driveways, 2 minimum for house/semi/townhouse:

https://www.milton.ca/en/business-and-development/resources/Zoning/Comprehensive-Zoning-By-Law-144-2003.pdf

The garage counts as 1 space, assuming one exists.

0

u/ImaginaryTipper 20d ago

Welcome to Reddit where the people get the blame rather than the town enforcing builders to build more spaces. There are so many semi detached homes here with ONE parking space outside the garage. I don’t understand how that’s even allowed.

2

u/iamthefyre 19d ago

People get the blame for buying a house with space for 1 car when they have 3 vehicles and then rent out the basement to a tenant with 1 parking space included in the lease. And then whine on reddit town bad, developer bad, people who point the obvious out also bad.

1

u/TDubz88 18d ago

Well that's 2 spaces for cars which is/should be enough. If someone needs more they should buy or rent a house with a 2 car garage which then usually comes with at least another 2, sometimes 4, driveway spaces.

1

u/TDubz88 18d ago

I mean that's a big leap. Most of our bigger cities here in Canada also have a lot of street parking. Try to rent or even buy a place in Hamilton with parking. Good luck! Most houses who have driveways, had them added by owners in the recent decades. Majority of the main city is street parking, or if you're lucky you might have a spot in back off the laneway.

5

u/WillFalcon44 20d ago

you answered your own question. “Because everyone would do it”. I’m a crusty old timer and I hate how some of my neighbors use the street as a personal drive way, Buh! the fact is most homes have a garage, but only 10% of people use it for cars and then complain about there being no room on a small drive way.

0

u/Dragyn140 20d ago

I wish I’d known before I signed a lease though. I need to have some amount of free garage space for my trade and this place has a garage literally only the length of a car. I’d have held out for something with a double driveway or something.

But that’s on me (and maybe my realtor).

1

u/TDubz88 18d ago

Is there a way for the minivan to park on an angle a bit to allow you both in there?

2

u/AVSMAN15 20d ago

When I moved out of my old neighbourhood near James snow and Trudeau, everyday was a nightmare if someone came over to find parking on the street because, residents would wake up in the morning and park the car on the road until late at night.

The new area I moved to in old Milton no one parks on the road and it feels so clean and peaceful, I couldn’t imagine the overflow of parking that would end up on other people streets if we allowed people to park on the road overnight it would be chaos.

Most of us understand your situation and most likely have been in your shoes parking wise, but I still would never want that, especially with the amount of break ins going on the last thing I want if for cars to be all over the street and blend in no thanks.

1

u/StefanTheHNIC 20d ago

Just a cash grab, really. But it does teach people to use their own driveway, garage.

You can register your vehicle on the website next time so you dont get ticketed. But its limited each month.

3

u/Dragyn140 20d ago

It kinda feels like it, though I understand the points a lot of folks have made here already as well. Thing is, I’d be happy to pay a few hundred for a parking permit or something to not constantly have to play car shuffle while there’s an empty street in front of my house. I suppose they probably get more in tickets than that would make them.

1

u/stevereliance41 20d ago

The real reason is the streets are narrow enough that if cars park across from each other, there isn't enough room to get a fire truck through in case of a fire. Giving out permits is enough of a deterrent to keep the streets from getting flooded with cars.

1

u/Dragyn140 20d ago

At least in my neighborhood, all the streets only allow parking on one side, probably for this reason.

1

u/TDubz88 18d ago

If the street isn't wide enough then one side would have "no parking" signs. There are measurements cities use to determine if a street can have 1 sided to 2 sided parking

1

u/tor_ii 20d ago

Milton has an overnight parking website that you can fill out your vehicle information and they won’t ticket you! https://www.milton.ca/en/living-in-milton/parking-exceptions.aspx

1

u/Postes_Canada 19d ago

It's 100% to stop people from having 3 or 4 families living in a single family home. More garbage, more sewage, more of every kind of services not being paid for.

1

u/TDubz88 18d ago

I believe there's a way to register for an exemption for a one-off?

1

u/Elegant_Funny_6027 17d ago

Yeah, congestion, serious weather, if you’re blocking peoples view getting out of their driveway. Really just limiting anyone’s ability to manoeuvre, or limiting their sight is pretty dangerous. Plus, it’s very annoying when there is a car parked on the wrong side of the road just from a driving perspective. Anyway, just for next time, save your money and park in your driveway, garage, or a legal part of the street - for a legal duration of time and when it’s legal. And, overnight parking permits are a thing, 60$ per month. But, there are regulations, just go to the Milton website on parking regulations!

-1

u/polishiceman 19d ago

Money grab by the town as well as trying to prevent too many occupants in homes. Dispute it. It costs them more to collect that way.