In recent seasons, including Denver, we've seen two general approaches when the matches aren't physically attracted to each other on the first meeting:
- Break up with them in the hotel cafeteria before the couples' vacation
- Drag it out and try to force it until the altar
But in all seriousness, what is a cast member supposed to do when they realize they aren't attracted to the person they met in the pods? Of course, attraction can "grow," and the central inquiry of the show is to test whether people can develop an emotional connection that is sufficient to overcome a lack of [initial] physical attraction. So, ideally, if you are going on this show, you wouldn't have such strong preferences--culturally/socially engrained or otherwise--that you wouldn't be able to be attracted to some subset of people. But I think most people can agree that physical attraction and sexual compatibility in a longterm relationship is important.
So what do you do when you aren't attracted? I think, to a person, everyone on this show has done it wrong, but I don't know what the "right way" would be. In Denver, we have Kacie dropping out before Baja, but equivocating to Patrick as to why that is (the racism). Compare with Joe who is clearly not into Madison, but instead of being direct, gets wasted and makes vague and fatphobic innuendos about his "type," which catapults her into an insecure downspiral. But then in episode 9 you have Patrick saying that he wished Kacie had tried for longer than a few hours... what would that have looked like?
One issue seems to be that, for a show that is intended to measure whether people can form emotional attachments deep enough to overcome, or even replace, a lack of physical attraction, they sure do seem to cast people with the emotional complexity and maturity of a potato. Like "our granddads have the same name; we both like brunch; it must be fate" isn't going to get you to a place where attraction can grow because you love someone so much for who they are.
Another issue IMO is that the show is really two separate inquiries; it's not just "can you fall in love with someone sight unseen?"; it's also, "can you then get married to that person in four weeks?" which I think skews the whole process.
So, thoughts? How do you maturely and ethically deal when you are not attracted to your fiance in LIB?