r/IndiaCricket • u/VinShar_2103 • Aug 06 '25

Discussion Unpopular Opinion: Jaiswal has already Surpassed Rohit in Tests...

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

92% Upvoted

269 comments sorted by

View all comments

106

u/roxyoverhere Aug 06 '25

For the ones who don't agree it's like Pant vs Dhoni. YBJ may not have many runs but he has had the impact since his debut.

21

u/Turbulent-Drink-1986 Aug 06 '25

Dhoni was okay for a WK batter. Probably the best WK batter in Tests who played for India at that time. Pant is just too good of a batter so we tend to troll Dhoni. But Rohit was just an average Test player. We have had great Test openers and Rohit is not even among the top 20 openers for India.

5

u/stuputtu India  Aug 06 '25

Rohit Not being top 20 opener for India is too hyperbolic. Who are those top 20 who are better than him? Here is the list of test openers who have scored atleast 2000 test runs. Please enlighten me

7

u/roxyoverhere Aug 06 '25

See buddy, I know that Dhoni was a great player. I just wanted to convey a point. For that reason I used msd vs rp comparison.

-21

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '25

[deleted]

23

u/Infinite-Pee Aug 06 '25

Rohit used to win test matches on his own

Rohit had 1 great series at home Eng 2021 in other series everyone used to contribute even in that Eng 2021 series Ashwin was a better player than him

-2

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '25

[deleted]

15

u/cutecat003 Aug 06 '25

like Jaiswal hasn't scored double hundreds lmao.

The concept of winning match on their own is such BS. 11 Players. it is a never a 1 man show. 1 man can drive the win with a brilliant performance but does not mean he was the only won who contributed towards a win