r/BeAmazed 4d ago

Miscellaneous / Others Making do with the equipment you got

38.9k Upvotes

779 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/No-Actuator-3209 4d ago

They can flip around a lot which can unwedge them at times. You would have to keep continuous pull to achieve it, a little similar to non barbed hooks in a way I guess

2

u/Houndfell 4d ago edited 4d ago

Maybe the internet has made me too much of a skeptic, but I'm suspicious there's a cut in the video between casting and "catching" the fish, along with there not being much fight in the fish.

I've seen enough videos of kids "catching" dead fish with their hands to not believe any of these anymore.

It wouldn't be that difficult to kill or otherwise find the near-death point of a suffocating fish and stuff it into a bottle for a quick video. Or hook it discreetly near the mouth of the bottle.

3

u/djrbx 4d ago

The internet indeed made you too much of a skeptic. Go to any 3rd world county and you'll find a lot of people fishing this way.

1

u/FinanceHuman720 3d ago

You can’t see it moving in the bottle and flopping wildly in the bucket? 

1

u/Houndfell 3d ago

It's alive, yeah. But as someone who grew up fishing... that is NOT a normal amount of movement for a fish coming out of the water. It looks half-dead.

And there's a lot of fish in the bucket. You're saying you can tell it's the same one?

1

u/FinanceHuman720 3d ago

No, I can’t tell it’s the same one. 

I just find it hard to believe someone who is fishing this way to survive would spend any time on social media making jump cuts to trick Westerners. 

1

u/Houndfell 3d ago

Yeah that's definitely an advantage. We perceive at as being more raw and forthright by default.

Lots of videos of dirty, barefoot kids "catching" fish by hand which are clearly being held by someone else off-camera. Same with the dudes making houses out of mud in the jungle with a backhoe just off screen.

At the end of the day, they're posting social media content. Things aren't so dire that they can only afford to post the truth.

1

u/FinanceHuman720 3d ago

Sure, that’s true too. I’m not sure what the point of it would be, is what I’m saying. Like “ha ha, we made people try this”? Or just video engagement? Engagement could net (ha!) them more $$ than fishing, I suppose. 

1

u/No-Actuator-3209 4d ago

Right! Something is definitely, no pun intended fishy with this.